Invariant Quartic Characterization of Delay-Independent Stability in Two-Dimensional Systems with Two Rank-One Delay Channels ()
1. Introduction
Time delays arise naturally in control, communication, biological, mechanical, and networked systems. Even when the undelayed model is finite-dimensional and linear, discrete delays convert the characteristic polynomial into a quasipolynomial with infinitely many roots. A fundamental robustness question is therefore whether asymptotic stability can be guaranteed independently of the delay values.
Necessary and sufficient conditions for delay-independent stability have a long history. Lewis and Anderson studied stability under arbitrary delays for linear autonomous systems with delayed interactions, with a distinction between robust quasi-diagonal-dominance statements and weaker conditions for a fixed system [1]. Cooke and Ferreira developed spectral-limit and global-in-delay stability results for retarded functional differential equations [2], while Hale, Infante and Tsen gave necessary and sufficient all-delay stability conditions for linear retarded and neutral equations [3]. Feng, Liu and Zhao subsequently showed that multidelay delay-independent stability questions can be converted from transcendental to algebraic conditions [4]. Chen and Latchman developed necessary and sufficient frequency-sweeping tests for commensurate and noncommensurate delay structures [5].
For systems with two delays and rank-one delayed matrices, Wu and Ren obtained necessary and sufficient delay-independent stability criteria by reducing the problem to the existence of real roots of auxiliary polynomials [6]. Their work is the closest prior result to the structural class studied here. Gu, Niculescu and Chen characterized stability crossing sets and crossing curves for general scalar quasipolynomials of arbitrary order with two delays [7]. Michiels and Niculescu treated delay-independent stability and delay-interference phenomena for multiple delays, including independently varying and constrained delays [8]. Yu, Zhong and Li also formulated an algebraic criterion for linear differential systems with two delays [9]. Naghnaeian and Gu later studied stability crossing sets for systems with two scalar-delay channels and emphasized the care needed when eliminating mixed exponential terms [10]. Alikoc and Ergenc proposed a general polynomial method based on self-inversive auxiliary polynomials for LTI systems with constant delays [11].
The objective of the present work is not to replace these general theories. Instead, we exploit the exceptional algebra of
matrices to obtain a compact invariant specialization. For
with
, the complete characteristic quasipolynomial can be compressed to seven simultaneous-similarity invariants. The two independent phase variables can then be eliminated analytically, leaving a single quartic polynomial in
.
The contribution is deliberately specialized rather than general. Within this two-dimensional class, the paper provides four linked results. First, the complete characteristic quasipolynomial is compressed to seven simultaneous-similarity invariants. Second, both independent delay phases are eliminated exactly, producing a universal monic quartic
whose nonpositive set is the complete realizable crossing-frequency set. Third, delay-independent stability is reduced to zero-delay Hurwitz stability plus strict positivity of this quartic on
, with a finite decision test because
is cubic. Fourth, the same invariant quartic yields structural information that is otherwise obscured: the factorization of
into four signed determinants, a global Hermitian interpretation, a triangle/Heron geometry when the mixed interaction vanishes, explicit critical-delay reconstruction, and algebraic parameter boundaries. Thus, the novelty sought here is the closed invariant form and the resulting transparency of the exact criterion, not the general existence of algebraic or frequency-domain delay-independent stability tests.
2. Problem Formulation and Algebraic Preliminaries
Consider
(1)
where
and
are independent.
The characteristic equation is
(2)
Definition 2.1. System (1) is called delay-independently asymptotically stable if it is asymptotically stable for every finite pair
For every
matrix
,
(3)
and
(4)
Define
and
Equivalently,
These quantities are invariant under simultaneous similarity
Throughout the main results we impose
(5)
so each delayed matrix has rank at most one.
3. Invariant Characteristic Representation
Proposition 3.1. Under (5), the characteristic quasipolynomial is
(6)
Proof. Let
and
. For a
matrix
,
Now
while repeated use of (4) gives
Using
yields (6). □
Corollary 3.2. Any two matrix triples satisfying (5) and sharing the same seven invariants
have exactly the same characteristic quasipolynomial for every pair of delays.
At zero delay,
Hence
(7)
4. Exact Elimination of the Delay Phases
Let
,
, and write
Define
Then (6) becomes
(8)
Regrouping,
(9)
Lemma 4.1 (Exact phase elimination). For fixed
, there exists
satisfying (8) if and only if
(10)
where
and
Proof. Fix
and set
Equation (9) is
. If
, a unit-modulus solution exists if and only if
in which case
and automatically
. If
, solvability requires
; when this holds, every
is admissible. Thus, including the singular case, existence of a unit-modulus
is exactly equivalent to
No division by D is used to derive this condition, so the elimination neither discards singular solutions nor introduces spurious ones.
Squaring and expanding gives
As
runs over
,
runs over
. Hence a solution exists if and only if (10) holds. □
Remark 4.2 (Relation to singular crossing-set elimination). For quasipolynomials containing a mixed term
, elimination procedures may create spurious crossing sets at singular frequencies if a vanishing factor is divided out. This issue is emphasized by Naghnaeian and Gu [10]. The modulus equivalence above is established before any quotient is formed and explicitly retains the case
; consequently, the crossing criterion below is an equivalence on the original characteristic equation rather than on an associated equation obtained by division.
Because
vary independently, every pair in
is realizable for fixed
. If
, then
is nonnegative for sufficiently large integers
.
5. The Invariant Quartic
Set
Direct calculation yields
(11)
and
(12)
Define
(13)
Theorem 5.1 (Exact crossing criterion). For every
,
(14)
Proof. The phase-elimination lemma gives
By definition the latter quantity is
. Independent delays realize every admissible phase pair. □
Corollary 5.2 (Exact realizable crossing-frequency set). Define
Then
Equivalently,
Thus, positive zeros of F are not, in general, all crossing frequencies. Generically they form endpoints of crossing-frequency bands, while
describes their interiors.
Corollary 5.3 (Number of connected crossing-frequency components). The set
has at most two connected components. Each component is either a nondegenerate interval (possibly accumulating at
) or, in a tangency case, a singleton.
Proof. The polynomial F is a real monic quartic and tends to
as
. At most one component of
can accumulate at
; because
, such a component must terminate at a positive zero and therefore uses at least one positive zero counted with multiplicity. Every other nondegenerate component is bounded away from the origin and requires two boundary zeros, while an isolated tangency component requires an even-multiplicity zero of multiplicity at least two. Hence three connected components would require at least
zero multiplicities if one component accumulates at
, or at least
otherwise. Both are impossible for a quartic. Thus, there are at most two connected components. The homeomorphism
preserves their number and type. □
Remark 5.4. If
and
, the phase equation has two distinct solutions for
. If
and
, these branches merge. The degenerate case
must be treated separately.
The constant coefficient has a useful structural factorization.
Proposition 5.5. Under (5),
(15)
Proof. Since
for
, multiplying the four signed determinants gives
which is exactly
.
Proposition 5.6 (Zero frequency is not a free torus phase). For every finite
,
and hence
Therefore, a finite-delay zero characteristic root exists if and only if
In particular,
does not by itself imply a finite-delay zero root.
Proof. The first identity is immediate at
. Substitution in the characteristic determinant gives the stated formula. The signed determinants in (15) arise from the algebraic limit of the phase-elimination polynomial at
; except for the
configuration, they are not physically realizable zero-frequency phase pairs for finite delays. □
6. Exact Delay-Independent Stability Criterion
Lemma 6.1 (Finite-path spectral continuation). Let the delay pair vary continuously on a compact path contained in
. For the retarded system (1), exponential stability is locally robust along that path, and a change in the number of characteristic roots in the open right half-plane can occur only when a characteristic root reaches the imaginary axis.
Proof. This is a standard consequence of the spectral theory of retarded functional differential equations: the spectral limit depends continuously on the delay data under the relevant perturbations, and only finitely many characteristic roots lie to the right of any prescribed vertical line. For the zero-delay limit in particular, see Michiels and Niculescu ([12], Theorems 1.15-1.16, pp. 12-13): their spectral-abscissa continuity statement explicitly includes points where the retarded system reduces to an ordinary differential system, and their next theorem links stability loss to imaginary-axis roots. See Cooke and Ferreira [2] and the general treatment in Hale and Verduyn Lunel [13]. The compactness of the finite-delay path excludes any need for an infinite-delay limiting argument.
Theorem 6.2 (Main DIS theorem). Under (5), system (1) is asymptotically stable for every finite pair of independent delays if and only if
(16)
and
(17)
Proof. Necessity follows first by setting
, which yields (16). If
for some
, Theorem 5.1 produces finite delays with an imaginary root, contradicting asymptotic stability.
For sufficiency, fix an arbitrary finite pair
. Consider
At
, the matrix
is Hurwitz. By Lemma 6.1, exponential stability persists for all sufficiently small positive
.
Assume, for contradiction, that stability is lost somewhere on the compact path
. Lemma 6.1 then implies that at a first loss of stability a characteristic root lies on the imaginary axis. A zero root is impossible by Proposition 5.6 and (16). A nonzero imaginary root is impossible by (17) and Theorem 5.1. Hence no stability loss can occur on the path, and the target pair
is stable. Since the finite target pair was arbitrary, the system is delay-independently stable. □
Remark 6.3. No separate assumption that A is Hurwitz is needed in the theorem. The proof concerns every fixed finite target pair of delays and never requires extending the continuation path to infinite delay.
Remark 6.4 (The limiting case
). The strict positivity condition is imposed only for
. Proposition 5.6 shows that the torus interpretation used for
cannot be extended literally to
. Consequently,
may coexist with ordinary finite-delay delay-independent stability provided
is Hurwitz and
for every
. Such equality may indicate loss of a uniform margin in an infinite-delay limit, but it is not a finite-delay zero-root condition.
Exact Finite Positivity Test
Write
so that
Proposition 6.5 (Exact quartic positivity test). The condition
is equivalent to the conjunction of the following two finite conditions:
1)
is positive immediately to the right of the origin, namely either
or
and the first nonzero coefficient in the ordered list
is positive;
2) for every positive real root
of
,
Since
is cubic, at most three positive stationary points need to be checked. Equivalently, after classifying stationary points, only positive local minima are decisive; a quartic has at most two of them.
Proof. Necessity is immediate. Conversely, the first condition guarantees
on some interval
. Since
is monic,
If
for some
, continuity together with positivity near
and for sufficiently large
implies that
attains a nonpositive minimum at some interior point
. Hence
and
, contradicting the second condition. □
Remark 6.6. Testing all positive real roots of the cubic
avoids any ambiguity caused by degenerate stationary points with
. The local-minimum formulation is equivalent, but the all-stationary-point version is simpler to implement robustly.
In particular,
immediately rules out positivity on
. When
, the first-nonzero-coefficient rule handles all possible orders of contact with the origin, including
.
A simple sufficient condition is
7. Vanishing Mixed Interaction: Triangle Geometry
Suppose
Then
where
For
, define
Theorem 7.1. For
, a positive frequency
can be an imaginary characteristic root for some delays if and only if
(18)
Proof. At
,
The independent phases rotate the complex numbers
and
freely without changing their lengths. Hence the equation is solvable exactly when three vectors of lengths
close to form a triangle. □
Direct algebra gives
(19)
Whenever the triangle exists,
where
is its area.
Since
while
, the high-frequency non-crossing branch is
. Thus, under zero-delay stability,
8. Critical Delay Reconstruction and Algebraic Boundaries
Suppose
for some
, and set
. Recall that admissible phases satisfy
(20)
Proposition 8.1 (Complete reconstruction of critical phases). Let
satisfy
, and let
.
If
, write
Then all admissible first phases are
(21)
For each such
, define
Equation (20) is equivalent to
. Hence:
1) if
, then
(22)
and automatically
;
2) if
, then
forces
, and every
is admissible.
If
, then
Since
, necessarily
Therefore (20) holds for every
. For each such
, one again has
: if
, the unique admissible second phase is
; if
, then
and every
is admissible.
Remark 8.2. Thus, no admissible solution is lost through the quotient in (22). A vanishing denominator can occur only together with a vanishing numerator once
satisfies the phase condition. The apparently singular case therefore produces a continuum of admissible second phases rather than an obstruction.
If
, every admissible phase pair is realized by finite nonnegative delays
(23)
where integers
are chosen sufficiently large that
. Hence the reconstruction is complete for every
.
The reconstructed critical-delay families locate parameter values at which the characteristic equation has imaginary roots; identifying the stable side of these families also requires checking root multiplicity and the direction of crossing.
Generic parameter-space boundaries occur when a positive local minimum of
touches zero:
(24)
Equivalently,
subject to the positive-real-root and zero-delay stability constraints.
Parameter boundaries must also account for loss of the zero-delay Hurwitz conditions. With
, the equality
gives an imaginary pair at zero delays; the equality
gives a zero characteristic root for every finite delay pair. A separate endpoint mechanism concerns the sign of
as
. Here
alone does not imply finite-delay stability loss: the sign for small positive
, determined by the first nonzero term of the quartic at the origin, must still be checked. These endpoint mechanisms complement the interior positive-frequency tangency
with
.
9. Hermitian Representation
Define
(25)
Its eigenvalues are
and
Proposition 9.1 (Global Hermitian characterization). For a fixed
,
implies that
is definite, but it may be either positive or negative definite. More precisely,
whereas
On the complete positive frequency axis,
(26)
Proof. The pointwise statements follow from the eigenvalues
For the global implication, assume
for all
. Since
we have
for all sufficiently large
. If
were nonpositive at some positive point, continuity would produce
with
. But then
a contradiction. Hence
for every
. Combining
with
gives
, so both eigenvalues of
are positive. The converse in (26) follows immediately from
□
Remark 9.2. The global quantifier in (26) is essential: pointwise positivity of
alone does not imply
.
Thus, the main theorem may equivalently be expressed as
10. Simultaneously Triangularizable Systems
Assume
are simultaneously triangularizable over
:
Then
where
For the scalar equation
independent-delay asymptotic stability is equivalent to
Therefore, the simultaneously triangularizable
system is DIS if and only if, for
,
11. Numerical Illustrations
11.1. Delay-Independent Example
Let
The invariants are
Moreover,
is Hurwitz and
Hence the system is delay-independently stable.
Figure 1. Invariant quartic for Example 1. The polynomial remains strictly positive on the positive frequency axis.
Figure 1 shows the quartic remaining positive for every positive squared frequency.
11.2. Zero-Delay Stable but Delay-Destabilized
Let
Then
and
is Hurwitz. However,
so
Thus
is an admissible crossing frequency.
One critical pair is approximately
and a second fundamental branch gives approximately
up to the periodic replicas generated by
.
Since
,
which satisfy the triangle inequalities.
Figure 2 and Figure 3 show, respectively, the negative frequency interval and the reconstructed critical-delay branches.
Figure 2. Invariant quartic for Example 2. The negative interval identifies frequencies that can be realized as imaginary-axis crossings by suitable independent delays.
Figure 3. Two fundamental critical-delay branches reconstructed from the admissible crossing-frequency band of Example 2. Integer phase replicas generate the remaining crossing curves.
11.3. A Limiting
Case That Remains DIS
To illustrate why the condition in the main theorem is imposed on
, consider
Both delayed matrices have rank at most one, while
is Hurwitz. The invariants are
and direct substitution gives
Hence
The main theorem therefore classifies this system as delay-independently stable for every finite delay pair. This example demonstrates concretely that replacing the condition
for
by
for
would be unnecessarily restrictive.
11.4. Tangency Boundary
Consider
The invariants are
The generic boundary equations
possess the positive solution
hence
At this parameter value the quartic is tangent to the horizontal axis at the positive local minimum
. Figure 4 displays this tangency.
Figure 4. Invariant quartic at the boundary parameter of Example 3. The positive local minimum is tangent to the horizontal axis.
12. Relation to Previous Work
Proposition 12.1 (Embedding in the standard two-delay cross-term form). Under
, the characteristic quasipolynomial belongs to the standard two-delay cross-term family
with the explicit identification
Thus, the present class is a dimension-two invariant specialization of the rank-one/two-channel quasipolynomial structures treated in the previous literature.
Proof. The statement follows directly from the invariant characteristic representation (6). In dimension two, rank-one delayed matrices remove the pure quadratic phase terms
and
, while the mixed invariant
remains as the coefficient of the cross term. □
The general idea of replacing transcendental all-delay stability questions by algebraic or frequency-domain tests predates the present work. Feng, Liu and Zhao [4] gave necessary and sufficient algebraic conditions for multidelay systems, and Chen and Latchman [5] developed necessary and sufficient frequency-sweeping tests. Yu, Zhong and Li [9] later gave another algebraic criterion for systems with two delays.
The closest prior result is Wu and Ren [6], who considered two-delay retarded systems with rank-one delayed matrices in general state dimension and obtained necessary and sufficient criteria through real roots of auxiliary polynomials. Proposition 12.1 makes the relationship explicit at the characteristic level. Accordingly, neither the rank-one setting, the two-delay setting, the cross-term quasipolynomial structure, nor the general existence of a polynomial DIS criterion is claimed here as new.
What is specialized here is not merely the state dimension in an entrywise formula. The 2 × 2 determinant identities compress the complete characteristic equation to the seven simultaneous-similarity invariants
. The subsequent torus elimination closes directly on these invariants and yields the single scalar condition
for realizable crossings, together with the finite positivity test for DIS. This is the structural simplification on which the contribution rests.
Theorem 12.2 (Planar specialization of Wu and Ren’s Theorem 3.1). For the common subclass with
, let
denote the polynomial defined by Wu and Ren [6, Theorem 3.1, Eq. (11), pp. 629-630]. Under the coefficient identification of Proposition 12.1,
Their independent-delay criterion therefore becomes exactly
,
,
for every
.
Proof. To distinguish their auxiliary functions from our invariants, denote the functions in their Equations (7)-(10) by
. Substitution of
,
,
, and
gives
Inserting these eight expressions into their Equation (11) yields
. Also,
so their zero-delay Hurwitz condition gives the first two inequalities. Their remaining condition excludes every nonzero real root of
, equivalently every positive real root of
. Since
is monic and tends to
, absence of positive roots is equivalent to
for every
: a negative value would force a positive root by continuity. This proves the stated specialization. □
Wu and Ren’s Remark 1 ([6], p. 630) permits roots at
, consistently with the admissible limiting case
discussed here. Their planar example already produces an even polynomial of degree eight in
([6], Eq. (27), p. 635), hence a quartic in
. The present formulation supplies its universal coefficients through seven simultaneous-similarity invariants, together with the direct phase-solvability proof that retains singular phases and the explicit critical-delay reconstruction. Wu and Ren assume nonzero rank-one delayed matrices; the direct proofs in Sections 4 and 6 also cover the zero-rank cases allowed in this paper, and the polynomial identity remains valid there.
The present contribution is therefore the explicit invariant specialization to state dimension two. Even-polynomial reductions in the frequency variable already occur in the rank-one two-delay literature, so quartic degree after the substitution
is not claimed by itself as a novelty. Here the entire characteristic quasipolynomial is represented universally by seven simultaneous-similarity invariants; both independent phases are eliminated exactly; and the resulting quartic is obtained in a closed invariant form.
Gu, Niculescu and Chen [7] provide a detailed crossing-set and stability-crossing-curve framework for scalar quasipolynomials of arbitrary order with two delays. Their crossing-frequency set is described by inequality constraints and forms finitely many bounded intervals. The present result is consistent with that geometry but, for the rank-one
matrix class, compresses the crossing-frequency set to the single inequality
.
Michiels and Niculescu [8] provide a general multidelay framework and distinguish independent from constrained delays. That distinction is essential here because the exact torus argument relies on independent phase coverage.
Naghnaeian and Gu [10] show that mixed exponential terms require careful elimination to avoid spurious crossing sets. The present derivation handles the singular case
before division.
Alikoc and Ergenc [11] give a substantially more general polynomial method based on self-inversive auxiliary polynomials. The advantage of the present specialization is not generality but transparency: no phase sweep remains after the seven invariants have been computed.
Table 1 summarizes the comparison with representative exact approaches.
Table 1. Position of the present reduction relative to representative exact approaches.
Method |
Scope |
Type of result |
Main computational object |
Feng-Liu-Zhao |
multidelay LTI systems |
exact DIS |
algebraic equations |
Chen-Latchman |
commensurate and noncommensurate
LTI systems |
exact DIS |
frequency sweeping/structured singular values |
Wu-Ren |
two delays, rank-one delayed matrices, general state dimension |
exact DIS |
auxiliary real polynomials |
Gu-Niculescu-Chen |
scalar quasipolynomials of arbitrary order,
two delays |
exact crossing set |
crossing-frequency inequalities and curves |
Michiels-Niculescu |
multiple delays, independent or constrained |
exact DIS characterization |
spectra of complex matrices |
Naghnaeian-Gu |
two scalar-delay
channels with
cross term |
exact crossing set |
geometric elimination with singular-case correction |
Alikoc-Ergenc |
general LTI systems
with constant delays |
exact DIS |
self-inversive auxiliary polynomials |
Present work |
2 × 2, two independent
rank-one channels |
exact DIS and crossing set |
seven invariants + one explicit quartic |
13. Discussion
The reduction reveals structure that is hidden in a direct entrywise treatment. First, seven scalar simultaneous-similarity invariants encode the complete characteristic quasipolynomial in the rank-one
class. Second, the mixed invariant
is exactly the coefficient of the mixed exponential
, giving it a direct characteristic-level interpretation.
Third, the quartic
carries several complementary meanings. Its sign determines whether a frequency is realizable as an imaginary characteristic root; its positive roots generically delimit crossing-frequency intervals; its local minima decide DIS; its discriminant describes generic parameter boundaries; and its constant term factors into four signed determinants.
The finite critical-point test is also numerically important. A coarse frequency sweep can miss a narrow interval where
, whereas checking the endpoint value
and all positive stationary points cannot miss such an interval in exact arithmetic. To guarantee this conclusion in a finite-precision implementation, all positive roots of
must be isolated and the signs of
certified, using certified root isolation or interval arithmetic. This is particularly important near tangencies, where
and
can be zero or close to zero; an unresolved interval sign must not be treated as a certificate of positivity.
The method has clear limitations. It is dimension-specific: for
, the determinant no longer closes in seven invariants. It is also rank-specific: if
or
, the characteristic equation acquires
and
terms and the present one-phase elimination no longer yields the same quartic. Finally, it assumes independent delays. Constrained or commensurate delays trace lower-dimensional subsets of the torus and require additional compatibility conditions.
A rank-one delayed channel arises when a scalar delayed feedback signal enters through one input direction: its coefficient has the form
, and a second channel has
. The two fixed delay values are treated as independent parameters, as for two feedback or transmission channels whose delays can be chosen separately. At each positive frequency, this independence allows both phase factors to cover the full unit circle without a prescribed relation between the delays, which is the assumption used in the elimination above.
Natural extensions include the full-rank
problem, strong or uniform delay-independent stability, constrained-delay relations, and robust parameter optimization based on the algebraic boundary
.
14. Conclusions
For a two-dimensional linear retarded system with two independent delays and rank-one delayed channels, the delay-independent stability problem admits a compact invariant reduction. The characteristic quasipolynomial is completely determined by seven simultaneous-similarity invariants. Exact elimination of the delay phases reduces the existence of nonzero imaginary roots to the sign of a single monic quartic
in the squared frequency.
The system is asymptotically stable for every finite delay pair if and only if the zero-delay matrix
is Hurwitz and
Because
is cubic, the positivity condition can be tested through at most two positive local minima. The same quartic also yields a determinant factorization at zero frequency, a Hermitian positivity representation, a triangle/Heron interpretation when
, explicit critical-delay families, and algebraic parameter boundaries.
The main value of the result is therefore not a new general theory of multidelay stability, but an explicit invariant characterization of a nontrivial low-dimensional subclass in which a transcendental two-phase problem becomes a transparent univariate quartic test.
Author Contributions
All authors contributed equally to conceptualization, methodology, formal analysis, validation, writing—original draft, and writing—review and editing.
Appendix
A. Expanded Coefficients of the Invariant Quartic
Writing
one obtains
and
B. Cubic Stationary-Point Test
The derivative is
After the substitution
, the normalized derivative becomes a depressed cubic whose coefficients may be written
For a robust exact implementation, compute all real roots of
, retain every positive root, and evaluate
at each of them. Since
is cubic, at most three positive stationary points are tested. This formulation automatically covers degenerate stationary points for which
. After classification, only local minima are decisive, and a quartic has at most two local minima.
The discriminant of the derivative cubic is
Thus
identifies multiple stationary points.
For completeness, the first nontrivial polynomial in the Sturm sequence of
and
, up to the conventional positive scaling, is
These identities provide an entirely algebraic route to root counting when a certified symbolic implementation is preferred over numerical cubic root finding.