Spatiotemporal Patterns Induced by Nonlocal Spatial Memory and Nonlocal Interaction ()
1. Introduction
Spatial memory and cognitive ability are crucial factors governing the movement behaviors of animals [1]. To characterize the memory-driven movement of animal populations, Shi et al. [2] established a single-species spatial memory model expressed as follows:
(1)
This model assumes localized spatial memory and interaction among individuals. Subsequent studies have further incorporated nonlocal memory and nonlocal interaction effects to improve the ecological rationality of the model. Song et al. [3] introduced a spatial average kernel integral term into the reaction function to describe nonlocal effects, and verified that only mode-1 stable spatial patterns can form in such systems. An et al. [4] considered a single-species reaction-diffusion model with memory delay, nonlocal maturation delay and hostile Dirichlet boundary conditions. The study reveals that memory-based diffusion can induce novel spatiotemporal patterns. Moreover, the pattern structures of periodic solutions under Dirichlet boundary conditions are different from the checkerboard-type patterns in the Neumann-boundary case; striped patterns arise under Dirichlet boundary conditions.
Shi et al. [5] (2021) considered that animals’ spatial memory does not merely rely on information from a single moment in the past, and memory undergoes biological processes of formation and temporal decay, it is more realistic to characterize the generation and decay of memory by means of distributed delays. A single-species reaction-diffusion model with spatiotemporally distributed memory-based diffusion is established. The time kernels of Gamma-distribution are adopted to distinguish the weak memory kernel from the strong memory kernel, and the Green’s function of the diffusion equation is utilized to realize spatially non-local memory. It is obtained that only spatial steady-state patterns can be generated under the weak-kernel case. For the strong-kernel case, spatially inhomogeneous steady states as well as spatially inhomogeneous time-periodic patterns can emerge. The mean time delay of memory can alter the spatial modes of patterns, and pattern formation requires the intensity of memory-based diffusion to exceed a critical threshold. Shi and Song [6] noted that in reality, animals’ memory does not only store local information at their own current position
from a single past moment
. As animals move, they can acquire population-distribution information of the entire habitat from past time. Their memory covers the whole spatial domain rather than being restricted to their own location. Accordingly, memory is generalized to spatially global non-local memory, and a single-species reaction-diffusion model is constructed. The results show that time delay exerts no influence under weakly memory-driven movement. For strongly memory-driven movement, a small memory delay destabilizes the homogeneous steady state, whereas a sufficiently large memory delay enhances the stability of the homogeneous equilibrium. Delay-induced Hopf bifurcations can generate spatially inhomogeneous periodic patterns, and multiple stability switches may even occur.
To achieve a more realistic description of nonlocal spatial memory, Xue et al. [7] modified the derivative term
by substituting it with an integral term equipped with a top-hat kernel function. The corresponding kernel is defined as
for
and
otherwise. Ecologically, animal memory intensity decays monotonically with the spatial distance
, namely, animals retain stronger memory of nearby habitats than distant regions. In this context, the Green function [8] [9] serves as a more appropriate kernel function to reflect the distance-dependent attenuation characteristics of animal spatial memory.
Based on the above research, this paper investigates the combined effects of nonlocal memory and nonlocal interaction with the model provided by
(2)
where
is the population density of species
at space
and time
,
is the random diffusion coefficient,
is the memory-based diffusion coefficient, Positive values of the memory-based diffusion coefficient (
) represent avoidance of higher remembered population density, while negative values (
) represent attraction toward regions with high remembered population density. and
where
is the Green function of the operator
with Neumann boundary condition. i.e., the solution of
(3)
denotes the memory delay, which indicates that animal movement depends on the population-density gradient at
time‑units in the past. The Green’s function
describes animals’ perception of resources, where nearby resources are perceived more strongly than distant ones. Chen [9] and Ni et al. [8] provide more comprehensive biological interpretations for the Green’s function.
is a valid integral kernel, and we take
in this paper. In this model, the spatial scale of the memory kernel
is determined by the random diffusion coefficient
. Biologically, this choice assumes that the spatial range over which individuals perceive remembered population information is consistent with the characteristic spatial scale of their random movement. Mathematically,
is the Green function of the operator
, so variations in
simultaneously modulate two ecological processes: it adjusts the magnitude of random dispersal motion, and also controls the spatial decay rate of the memory kernel, which governs the spatial smoothing of remembered population information.
The present work extends the studies in [5]-[7], which investigated spatial movement driven solely by nonlocal spatial memory without incorporating nonlocal interaction. In contrast to these references, we couple the Green-function-based memory kernel with an additional nonlocal interaction term. This coupling enables new findings on stability and mode selection: the strength of local interaction
governs the admissible unstable modes. When
, only mode-1 instability can occur, whereas arbitrary modes may lose stability for
, giving rise to Turing-Turing bifurcation. Furthermore, we analyze delay-induced instabilities and derive Hopf bifurcation curves as well as Hopf-Hopf bifurcation points, yielding parameter-dependent stability regions that are not reported in [5]-[7].
The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. Section 2 discusses the stability of homogeneous steady states, derives the critical conditions for Turing bifurcations and delay‑induced bifurcations, and partition the parameter regions corresponding to different dynamical behaviours. Section 3 provides an example for numerical simulation to verify the theoretical results, and explores the joint effects of memory delay and non‑local interactions on the formation of population spatial patterns.
2. Stability and Bifurcations Analysis
Let
denote the homogeneous steady state of (2). The linearized system of (2) at
is
(4)
where
Let
be the solution to the Equation (4). Using integration by part and the boundary conditions in (3), we have
From (3) and the symmetry of the Green function, the above equation equals to
which implies that
The characteristic equation of (4) is given by
(5)
Throughout the rest of this paper, we assume that
, which guarantees that
serves as an asymptotically stable equilibrium of the ODE system
.
2.1. Turing Bifurcation
We first consider the case without memory delay. When
, the characteristic Equation (5) becomes
(6)
Furthermore, we can obtain
for
, where
(7)
Now we investigate some properties for the curve
.
Proposition 1. Assume that
.
1) When
,
is decreasing with the increasing of
for fixed
.
2) Assume that
.
(i) The curve
is decreasing with the increasing of
;
(ii)
is increasing with
and
;
(iii) The curves
and
intersect at
, which is decreasing with
, and
, which is increasing with
.
Proof. When
and
, differentiating both sides of Equation (7) with respect to
, we can obtain
(8)
and then
is decreasing with
. The conclusion (i) is proved.
When
,
. Therefore,
for
. By (7), we have
(9)
This implies that the curve
is decreasing for
. In addition, notice that when
which is increasing with
and
.
Solving
for
, we have
(9)
It is obvious that
is decreasing with
. Substituting
into (7), we have
Furthermore, we can obtain
(10)
which tells us that
is increasing with
. The conclusion (ii) is proved.
From proposition 1(ii), when
, we define
(11)
Then we can prove the following results on the stability and bifurcation for
.
Lemma 1. Assume that
,
,
is defined by (11).
i) For
, when
,
for any
. When
, there exists some
such that
.
ii) For
, when
,
for any
. When
, there exists some
such that
.
Proof. From proposition 1 (i), if
,
for any
, and all roots of Equation (6) are negative. In addition, for
, there exists some
such that
. For fixed
, Equation (6) has the root
provided that
, the conclusion (i) is proved.
From proposition 1 (ii), when
,
for any
, and exists at least one
for
, the conclusions (ii) follow immediately.
Taking the derivative of both sides of Equation (6) with respect to
, we get
the transversality condition holds.
Theorem 1. Assume that
,
and
,
is defined by (9) and (11).
i) When
,
is asymptotically stable for
and unstable for
. Moreover, steady state bifurcations occur at
;
ii) When
,
is asymptotically stable for
and unstable for
, system (2) undergoes Turing bifurcation at
. More specifically, for
with
, system (2) undergoes mode-
Turing at
. Moreover, system (2) undergoes Turing-Turing bifurcation at
with
due to interaction of mode-
Turing and mode-
Turing.
2.2. Spatially Nonhomogeneous Hopf Bifurcation
In this subsection, we investigate the joint effect of the nonlocal interaction and memory delay on the spatiotemporal patterns. For
, consider the second equation of (5)
(12)
Letting
be the solution of Equation (12) and substituting it into (12), we have
(13)
which implies that
(14)
Set
(15)
From (7) and (15),
. Thus, we can get the properties of
from proposition 1. Similar as
, when
, we can define
(16)
for
.
Under the assumption that
is asymptotically stable for
, we have
, i.e.,
We can conclude that for fixed
, when
, Equation (14) has a unique positive root
(17)
and Equation (12) has a pair of purely imaginary roots
at
, where
(18)
Lemma 2. For
and
, assume that
and
are defined by (17) and (18), respectively. Define regions as follows:
1) If
, when
, Equation (12) has a pair of purely imaginary roots
at
,
. When
, all roots of Equation (12) have negative real parts for any
.
2) If
, when
, all roots of Equation (12) have negative real parts for any
. When
, for
, there exists some
such that Equation (12) has a pair of purely imaginary roots
at
, where
Proof. (i) When
, it follows from (7) and (15) that for fixed
,
is increasing with the increasing of
. Therefore, when
,
for any
. Notice that the curves
and
intersect at
(19)
and
for
. Therefore, when
, all roots of Equation (12) have negative real parts for any
. In addition, for
, Equation (12) has a pair of purely imaginary roots
at
. This confirms the conclusion (i).
(ii) If
, when
, Equation (14) has no positive roots, that is, Equation (12) has no corresponding purely imaginary roots. When
, there exists some
such that
, then Equation (12) has a pair of purely imaginary roots
at
. Combined with Theorem 1 (ii), the conclusion (ii) follows immediately.
Lemma 3 For
and
, assume that
and
are defined by (17) and (18), respectively. For
, when
is located on the lower boundary of the region
, i.e.,
, for
, Equation (12) has one zero root
and a pair of purely imaginary roots
at
,
,
, where
.
Proof. By (7) and (12), when
,
is always the root of (12) for any
. Notice that the curve
and
intersect at
, and the curve
is divided into several parts by the intersections
. For the segement of
with
,
is above the curves
,
, which means that
,
, and thus Equation (12) has a pair of purely imaginary roots
at
,
,
.
Taking the derivative of both sides of Equation (12) with respect to
, we get
we have the following transversality condition
Theorem 2. Assume that
.
i) For
a) When
,
is asymptotically stable for
;
b) When
,
is unstable for
;
c) When
,
is asymptotically stable for
, and unstable for
, and (2) undergoes Hopf bifurcation at
with
,
, where
;
d) On the lower boundary of the region
, i.e.,
, for fixed
,
with
, (2) undergoes Turing-Hopf bifurcation at
with
,
.
ii) For
:
a) When
,
is asymptotically stable for
;
b) When
,
is unstable for
;
c) When
, for fixed
with
, when
, there exists a critical value
of delay such that
is asymptotically stable for
and unstable for
. Furthermore, (2) undergoes delay-induced Hopf bifurcation at
, where
;
d) On the lower boundary of
, i.e.,
, system (2) undergoes Turing bifurcation at
, and undergoes Turing-Turing bifurcation at the intersection of
.
3. Example
3.1. Numerical Method
The coupled model (2) is reformulated into an equivalent parabolic-elliptic system and solved numerically. Introducing the auxiliary variable
, and applying the operator
to the convolution integral, the Green’s function identity (3) yields the elliptic equation
. Consequently, the original delayed equation is recast as
where
and . The elliptical relation also provides the identity
(20)
which avoids explicit second-order differentiation of
.
The interval
is divided uniformly into
grid points with spacing
. Second-order centered differences are adopted, and the Neumann boundary conditions are imposed by the method of ghost points (the derivatives at the endpoints remain zero). A semi-implicit scheme is employed with a fixed time step
. The diffusion term, the memory-based advection term, and the reaction-type tensor term and all linear in
are treated implicitly, whereas the nonlinear reaction term
is treated explicitly:
The left-hand operator is tridiagonal, so each time step solves a tridiagonal linear system directly. Implicit treatment of the diffusion/advection operators removes the standard diffusive CFL restriction (
), allowing stable integration with the chosen step size. The elliptic equation
is solved at each step by a sparse LU decomposition (performed once, since the matrix is time-invariant), followed by back-substitution. Because
is fixed and
is imposed as an integer multiple of
via the number of delay steps
, the delayed field is retrieved from a ring buffer of length
storing the most recent
and
. The initial perturbation is
. For
, the history is taken as
, and the elliptic initial condition is
. Solutions are sampled every 0.5 time units for the spatiotemporal plots.
3.2. Numerical Results
In this section, we consider the single-species population model put forward by Britton in [10] [11]. The reaction function
of (2) is given by
(21)
the term
(
) represents a benefit to local aggregation,
(
) mitigates local aggregation, and
under
accounts for the disadvantage arising from nonlocal resource depletion. From (21), we have
, and
,
.
Fix the parameters as
. Choosing
, then
,
. Turing bifurcation curves are illustrated in Figure 1. From (19),
.
Figure 1. Stability regions and bifurcation curves for
. The shadow region refers to the region where
is stable for all
.
1)
and
.
is asymptotically stable for
(see Figure 2(a));
2)
,
based on (7),
.
is unstable and there exists spatially inhomogeneous steady state induced by Turing bifurcation (see Figure 2(b));
Figure 2. The rich dynamical phenomena when
. (a)
is asymptotically stable for
and
. (b) Spatially inhomogeneous steady state for
.
3) For fixed
,
, we have
a) for
, no Hopf bifurcation value can be found in this region;
b) for
, there is a Hopf bifurcation value
and
;
c) for
, there are Hopf bifurcation values
and
;
d) for
, there are Hopf bifurcation values
and
;
e) for
, there are Hopf bifurcation values
and
Furthermore, it follows from Figure 3 that
when we take
,
, and
respectively in Figure 3, system (2) has 2-mode, 3-mode and 4-mode spatially nonhomogeneous periodic solutions induced by Hopf bifurcation (see Figure 4).
4) System (2) undergoes Turing-Hopf bifurcation at
, Hopf‑Hopf bifurcation occurs when
and
(see Figure 3).
Figure 3. Stability regions and Hopf bifurcation curves for system (2).
.
Figure 4. When
, system (2) has (a) 2-mode spatially inhomogeneous periodic solution for
; (b) 3-mode spatially inhomogeneous periodic solution for
; (c) 4-mode spatially inhomogeneous periodic solution for
.
Choosing
, thus
. Turing bifurcation curves are illustrated in Figure 5. From (9), we can get
.
Figure 5. Stability regions and bifurcation curves for
. The shadow region refers to the region where
is stable for all
.
1)
and
,
is asymptotically stable for
(see Figure 6(a));
2)
,
,
based on (11).
is unstable and there exists spatially inhomogeneous steady state induced by Turing bifurcation (see Figure 6(b));
Figure 6. The rich dynamical phenomena when
. (a)
is asymptotically stable for
and
. (b) Spatially inhomogeneous 2-mode steady state for
.
3) For fixed
, we have
a) for
, there is no delay-induced Hopf bifurcation and the positive equilibrium
is asymptotically stable for any
;
b) for
, there is a Hopf bifurcation value
and
;
c) for
, there are Hopf bifurcation values
and
;
d) for
, there are Hopf bifurcation values
and
e) for
, there are Hopf bifurcation values
and
Furthermore, it follows from Figure 7 that
when we take
,
, and
respectively in Figure 7, system (2) has 2-mode, 3-mode and 4-mode spatially nonhomogeneous periodic solutions induced by Hopf bifurcation (see Figure 8).
4) System (2) undergoes Hopf‑Hopf bifurcation when
and
(see Figure 7).
Figure 7. Stability regions and Hopf bifurcation curves for system (2).
.
Figure 8. When
, system (2) has (a) 2-mode spatially inhomogeneous periodic solution for
; (b) 3-mode spatially inhomogeneous periodic solution for
; (c) 4-mode spatially inhomogeneous periodic solution for
.
4. Conclusions
In this paper, we mainly formulate a diffusive single-species model with nonlocal interactions and nonlocal spatial memory. We first explore spatial patterns for the system without delay. Comparative values of the random diffusion coefficient
, memory‑driven diffusion coefficient
, and local interaction strength
jointly govern the stability of the spatially uniform steady state
. When
, the boundary of the stability region is given by
. For
, the boundary of the stability region
is formed by the intersections of
.
After incorporating the memory delay effect, nonlocal interactions and nonlocal memory delay exert a combined influence on the stability of the homogeneous steady state
. Based on the symmetry of
and
, we obtain the stability regions
and
, at which
is locally asymptotically stable for any
. We also get the incomplete stability regions
and
on the
-
parameter plane, at which there exists a critical value
: the homogeneous steady state
is asymptotically stable if
, and loses its stability with the emergence of Hopf bifurcation for
. When
, delay-induced spatially inhomogeneous Hopf bifurcation and Turing-Hopf bifurcation take place. For
, spatially inhomogeneous Hopf bifurcation arises, whereas Turing-Hopf bifurcation does not exist. In regions
and
, Hopf bifurcations of various modes as well as Hopf-Hopf bifurcations can occur.
This work carries several simplifying assumptions that constrain its ecological interpretation. First, we consider only a one-dimensional habitat, while real animal populations move in 2-dimensional or 3-dimensional space. Second, the interaction kernel adopted here is spatially uniform, ignoring spatial heterogeneity of resources or terrain. Third, the memory delay
is treated as a fixed constant, although memory retention may vary with location, time or population status in natural ecosystems. These idealizations limit the direct applicability of our model to animal movement within complex heterogeneous environments. Future extensions could relax these assumptions by introducing two-dimensional domains, state-dependent memory delay and spatially varying interaction kernels.
Funding
The work is supported by National Natural Science Foundation of China (Nos. 12571538 and 11901369).
Author Contributions
Jiajia Tang: Conceptualization, theoretical derivation, writing—original draft; Methodology, numerical simulation, writing—review and editing;
Yanfei Du: Formal analysis, validation, supervision, funding acquisition;
All authors read and approved the final manuscript.