Theoretical Predictions of Thermodynamic Behavior for Cd-Tl Melts at Different Temperatures ()
1. Introduction
The Cd-Tl and Cd-Tl-based multicomponent alloys like Sn-Cd-Tl, Bi-Cd-Tl, Pb-Cd-Bi-Tl etc., have potential applications in industries, as semiconductors, as ceramic compounds, as microsensor in technological process, etc. [1] [2]. The phase diagram [3] shows that the composition dependence of thermodynamic functions like excess free energy of mixing,
, free energy of mixing,
and enthalpy of mixing,
are asymmetric while the entropy of mixing,
is symmetric for Cd-Tl melts at 750 K at x = 0.5. In the entire composition region x = 0.1 to 0.9,
and
have positive values at each composition. The activity of both the components i.e.
and
illustrates the positive departures from the ideal mixing behaviour. Therefore, Cd-Tl system at 750 K in molten state has a segregating character [4].
The thermodynamic properties and wide range of applications indicate the importance of the Cd-Tl melts for the researchers. Nevertheless, there is scarcity of data related to the study of thermophysical properties of Cd-Tl in the literature. Earlier, some attempts have been made to explore the thermodynamic properties like
and activity of the components Cd and Tl, and phase diagram by the optimization process on using CALPHAD approach [5] and
, concentration fluctuations,
, diffusivity,
and viscosity of Cd-Tl melts at 750 K by quasi-lattice theory [6]. Despite these, Cd-Tl melts at 750 K still requires further investigation.
In present work, MIVM model is utilized for the analysis of
,
, activity coefficients,
, activity,
, short-range order parameter,
(SRO), excess stability function,
and transport property like diffusivity ratio,
of Cd-Tl melts at 650 K, 750 K, 850 K, 950 K and 1050 K. The MIVM model [7] is a fluid-based model based on the statistical thermodynamics. It is necessary to point out that MIVM model is successfully employed for the analysis of the thermodynamic properties of several binary alloys (Zn-Bi, Al-Ga, Ni-Pd, Al-In, Zn-Cd, etc.) and multi-component alloys (Au-Sn-Bi, Au-Sn-Zn, Zn-In-Sn, Al-Sn-Zn, Zn-Cu-Sn-In, etc.) [8]-[15].
2. Formalism
2.1. Thermodynamic Properties Like Excess Free Energy of Mixing,
, Free Energy of Mixing,
, Activity Coefficient,
and Activity,
of Binary Molten Alloys
MIVM model is established by Tao [7] which is a fluid-based model and deduced from statistical thermodynamics, the fundamental notion of non-random interchange of liquid molecules and fluid-phase equilibria. For a binary melt
, the molecular excess free energy of mixing is expressed as [7]
(1)
where, the compositions of the element
and
represented by
and
,
and
refer to pair-potential energy interaction parameters, respectively and the first coordination numbers of the constituents
and
are respectively
and
. The pair potential energy interaction parameters may be expressed as [7]
and
(2)
where,
,
and
stand for potential energies for the pairs
,
and
respectively, temperature is represented by T and k represents Boltzmann constant. It is noted that
.
The partial molar energy and excess molar free energy are related as
(3)
where,
represents the activity coefficient of binary melts.
It is noted that Equation (3) follows the condition that for
,
; and
,
. Again, the variables
and
determined from
with
. Hence, the activity coefficients of components
and
of a binary melt are respectively, represented by
(4)
and
(5)
For the component
, the first co-ordination number is determined by the following relation [7]
(6)
where,
represents the melting temperature in kelvin,
, the enthalpy at melting temperature,
represents the molecular number density,
and
are initial value and first peak value for radial distribution function of metal
in molten state near
,
stands for molar gas constant and
represents the co-ordination number for closed packed structure which is usually taken to be 12. The radial distances may be represented by
and
(7)
where,
represents atomic covalent diameter and
the atomic diameter.
In infinite dilute solution region, such as
or
, the activity coefficients of the constituents
and
may be represented by
(8)
and
(9)
The activity and activity coefficients for the constituents of the binary melts may be expressed as [4]
(10a)
(10b)
2.2. Microscopic Functions Like Concentration Fluctuations,
and SRO,
of a Binary Molten Alloy
The
and
are found to be very important microscopic parameters to explore the interatomic interactions in a liquid system. If
then the system is ordered i.e. dissimilar (
) atoms or molecules coupled together as the closest neighbors. Similarly,
describes the segregating character of the binary melt and like (i.e.
or
) atoms or molecules link together as the closest neighbors [4].
The
and
are related as [4] [16]
(11)
where,
(12)
(13)
Using Equations (1) and (13) in (11), one can obtain
(14)
where,
(15)
For an ideal mixing,
hence Equations (14) and (15) yield
(16)
Again, the activity and
are related as
(17)
The
determined from Equation (17) on utilizing the experimental data of activity is considered as the experimental data [4] [16] [17].
The SRO,
initiated by Warren-Cowley [18] [19] is related to
as [4] [20]
with
(18)
where,
refers to the coordination number in first neighbor shell.
Equation (18) exhibits that
= positive for segregating system,
= negative for ordered system and
for ideal mixture.
2.3. Excess Stability Function,
and Diffusivity,
of a
Binary Molten Alloy
The excess stability function,
initiated by Darken [21] [22] may be expressed as
(19)
Obviously,
= positive for ordering alloy,
= negative for segregating alloy and
for ideal alloy depending upon the conditions that
,
, and
respectively.
The transport property, such as diffusivity is very useful to describe the mixing behavior of a binary solution at the microscopic level. For a binary liquid system, the diffusivity ratio is expressed as [4] [23]
(20)
where,
and
represent the mutual diffusion coefficient of the system and intrinsic diffusion coefficient of ideal system respectively. Now,
is represented by
(21)
where,
and
are self-diffusion coefficients of pure elements
and
respectively.
Equation (20) illustrates that
for ordered system,
for segregating system and
for ideal system.
3. Results and Discussions
3.1. Excess Free Energy of Mixing,
, Free Energy of Mixing,
, Activity Coefficient,
and Activity,
of Cd-Tl Melts at 750 K
The analytical equations for
,
,
and
are employed to assess the thermodynamic properties of Cd-Tl melts at 750 K. The necessary parameters of pure Cd and Tl are presented in Table 1 [24]. The coordination numbers
and
of the constituents of the alloy are determined from Equation (6) which are presented in Table 2. The parameters
and
are evaluated on solving Equations (8) and (9) simultaneously by Newton-Rapson method using the values of infinite dilute activity coefficients i.e.
(1.932) and
(3.826) [3]. The evaluated values of
and
are 0.7107 and 0.8815 respectively. The approximated values of
and
are slightly altered in order to achieve a good harmony between the theory and experiment [3] for
of Cd-Tl melts at 750 K. The reasonable values of
and
i.e. 0.7120 and 1.0990 respectively, are also incorporated in Table 2.
Table 1. Input parameters for the pure metals [24].
Metal, i |
(KJ/mole) |
(×10−8 cm) |
(×10−8 cm) |
(cm3/mole) |
Cd |
6.40 |
3.00 |
2.54 |
14.0 [1 + 1.6 × 10−4 (T-594)] |
Tl |
4.31 |
3.22 |
2.74 |
18.0 [1 + 1.15 × 10−4 (T-575.65)] |
Table 2. Values of
,
,
and
for the constituents of Cd-Tl melts at required temperature.
|
T (K) |
|
|
|
|
|
650 |
0.6757 |
1.1151 |
9.86 |
9.53 |
|
750 |
0.7120 |
1.0990 |
9.71 |
9.42 |
Cd-Tl |
850 |
0.7410 |
1.0869 |
9.56 |
9.32 |
|
950 |
0.7648 |
1.0774 |
9.41 |
9.22 |
|
1050 |
0.7846 |
1.0698 |
9.27 |
9.12 |
The values of
calculated from Equation (1) as a function of Cd for Cd-Tl alloys at 750 K show excellent agreement with the corresponding experimental values [3] as presented in Figure 1. In composition region,
to 0.9, the value of
is positive at each concentration. The computed and experimental [3] values of
are in excellent harmony with maximum values at
i.e. 0.2478 (Theory) and 0.2504 (Experiment). The RMS error is found to be 0.00533% on employing Equation (22). Hence, the present theoretical investigation successfully reveals the symmetry in
and segregating nature of Cd-Tl melts at 750 K.
(22)
where,
= theoretical (calculated) values;
= experimental values;
= no. of data points.
Figure 1.
vs
for Cd-Tl melts at 750 K.
Equation (13) is used to compute the values of
for Cd-Tl melts at 750 K which are illustrated in Figure 2 along with experimental values [3]. A well agreement is seen. In the whole composition region,
to 0.9,
is negative with minimum values at
= 0.4 i.e.
(Theory) and −0.4518 (Experiment). The RMS error computed from Equation (22) is found to be 0.00542%. Thus, the symmetry in
is successfully described by MIVM model.
Figure 2.
vs
for Cd-Tl melts at 750 K.
The activity coefficients
and
are evaluated from Equations (4) and (5) respectively in terms of the concentration of Cd. The theoretical and experimental [3] data of
and
are in excellent agreement as shown in Figure 3. The RMS errors for
and
computed from Equation (22) are found to be 0.029441% and 0.022264% respectively.
Figure 3. (
&
) vs
for Cd-Tl melts at 750 K.
The theoretical data of
and
are used to calculate the concentration dependence of
and
respectively from Equations (10a) and (10b) for Cd-Tl melts at 750 K, which are presented in Figure 4.
Figure 4. (
&
) vs
for Cd-Tl melts at 750 K.
A well concord is noticed between theory and experiment [3] with RMS errors for
and
computed from Equation (22) are found to be 0.008040% and 0.008330% respectively. The positive departures of
and
from ideal behavior refer to the segregating character of Cd-Tl melts at 750 K. It should be pointed out that the activity is a fortunate thermodynamic function which can be directly measured from the experiment. Therefore, the well harmony between theoretical and experimental data for
and
validates the reasonable values of
and
.
3.2. Microscopic Properties Like
,
,
and
of Cd-Tl Molten Melts at 750 K
Equations (14) and (15) are employed to compute the concentration dependence of
for Cd-Tl melts at 750 K. The theoretical data of
are incorporated in Figure 5 along with
and experimental values [3].
Figure 5.
vs
for Cd-Tl melts at 750 K.
A well uniformity is noticed between the theory and experiment having the RMS error of 0.0118705% which is computed from Equation (22). It is observed that
in the composition region,
and
exhibits ideal behavior of Cd-Tl melts at 750 K in the regions
and
. The maximum values of
are at
i.e.
(Theory) and 0.518 (Experiment). Hence, the present investigation reveals that Cd-Tl melt at 750 K possesses segregating character in the region
.
Equation (18) is employed to achieve the concentration dependent values of
for Cd-Tl melts at 750 K on using Z = 10. The theoretical data of
in terms of the concentration of Cd are presented in Figure 6. In the full range of composition i.e.
to 0.9,
is positive at each composition and having maximum value of 0.0576 at
, which reveals the segregating behavior of Cd-Tl melts at 750 K [25].
The concentration dependence of
for Cd-Tl alloys at 750 K computed from Equation (19) is illustrated in Figure 7. Obviously,
is negative at each composition of Cd in the concentration region
to 0.90 for Cd-Tl melts at 750 K. This exhibits the segregating nature of Cd-Tl melts at 750 K [22] [26].
Figure 6.
vs
for Cd-Tl melts at 750 K.
Figure 7.
vs
for Cd-Tl melts at 750 K.
The diffusivity ratio,
as a function of the composition of Cd for Cd-Tl melts at 750 K is calculated from Equation (20) and the theoretical data of
are depicted in Figure 8. It is noticed that the diffusivity ratio,
has minimum value of 0.4554 at 750 K at
. This confirms the segregation in Cd-Tl melts at 750 K [4].
Figure 8.
vs
for Cd-Tl melts at 750 K.
3.3.
,
,
,
,
,
,
and
of Cd-Tl Melts at Different Temperatures
For the theoretical analysis of the mixing behavior of Cd-Tl melts at different temperatures, the needed input parameters are presented in Table 1 and Table 2. The values of
and
at desired temperature, T K are determined via the following equations [7].
(22)
and
(23)
where, T0 = 750 K.
The computed data of
and
for Cd-Tl melts assessed via Equations (1) and (13) at 650 K, 750 K, 850 K, 950 K and 1050 K are presented in Figure 9 and Figure 10 respectively. Figure 9 illustrates that the segregating nature of Cd-Tl melts degrades when temperature is upgraded from 650 K to 1050 K. The maximum values of
are 0.2767 (at 650 K), 0.2478 (at 750 K), 0.2234 (at 850 K) all
while
(at 950 K) and 0.1863 (at 1050 K) both at
. Thus, Cd-Tl melts exhibit asymmetric behavior at 650 K, 750 K and 850 K, and symmetric character at 950 K and 1050 K relative to the composition of Cd. Again, it is noticeable from Figure 10 that the negative values of
for Cd-Tl melts increase due to rise in temperature from 650 K to 1050 K. The values of
are minimum at
for temperatures 650 K and 750 K i.e. −0.4256 and −0.4481, respectively while
shows minima at
for temperatures 850 K, 950 K and 1050 K i.e. −0.4703, −0.4899 and −0.5068 respectively in terms of
. Thus, Cd-Tl melts indicate asymmetry at 650 K and 750 K and symmetry at 850 K, 950 K and 1050 K with respect to
.
![]()
Figure 9.
vs
for Cd-Tl melts at 650 K, 750 K, 850 K, 950 K & 1050 K.
Figure 10.
vs
for Cd-Tl melts at 650 K, 750 K, 850 K, 950 K & 1050 K.
The thermodynamic activities of Cd and Tl i.e.
and
are computed from Equations (10a) and (10b) respectively on applying the theoretical data of
and
determined from Equations (4) and (5) for Cd-Tl melts at 650 K, 750 K, 850 K, 950 K and 1050 K relative to
. The theoretical results for
and
at the temperatures ranging from 650 K to 1050 K are shown in Figure 11. The results reveal the decrease in segregation for rise in temperature from 650 K to 1050 K for Cd-Tl melts. However, the decrease in the segregation is weak in the temperature region 650 - 1050 K.
Figure 11. (
&
) vs
for Cd-Tl melts at 650 K, 750 K, 850 K, 950 K & 1050 K.
The temperature dependence of
for Cd-Tl melts at 650 K, 750 K, 850 K, 950 K and 1050 K relative to composition Cd is presented in Figure 12. For the calculation of
, Equations (14) and (15) are applied. The
-
isotherms indicate the degradation in segregating character of Cd-Tl melts for the rise in temperature from 650 K to 1050 K. The peak value of
is noticed at
i.e. 0.618, 0.520, 0.466 and 0.427 respectively at 650 K, 750 K, 850 K, 950 K while a minor shift in peak value of
is observed at 1050 K i.e.
at
.
Figure 12.
vs
for Cd-Tl melts at 650 K, 750 K, 850 K, 950 K & 1050 K.
The
-
isotherms for Cd-Tl melts are depicted in Figure 13. For this, the theoretical data of
are computed with the help of Equation (18) at temperatures 650 - 1050 K. Obviously, the segregation in Cd-Tl melts goes on decreasing for the rise in temperature from 650 K to 1050 K. Again, the magnitude of
is small which illustrates that Cd-Tl melts is a weakly segregating system [4] [26] in the temperature range 650 - 1050 K.
Figure 13.
vs
for Cd-Tl melts at 650 K, 750 K, 850 K, 950 K & 1050 K.
The excess stability function of several binary alloys at a certain temperature has been discussed earlier [27] [28]. Nonetheless, the limited data is available regarding the theoretical exploration of
at different temperatures [22] [26], [29] on employing the optimization procedure. In present study, MIVM model is applied to explore the stability of Cd-Tl melts at various temperatures.
The variation of
with respect to composition of Cd at 650 K, 750 K, 850 K, 950 K and 1050 K for Cd-Tl melts determined via Equation (19) is presented in Figure 14. Obviously,
exhibits negative value at each composition in the region
to 0.90 at each temperature under consideration. Again, the negative values of
declines with the upgradation in temperature from 650 K to 1050 K. This is a sign of decrease in the segregation of Cd-Tl melts [22] [26] from 650 K to 1050 K.
The
relative to the concentration of Cd for Cd-Tl melts at 650 K, 750 K, 850 K, 950 K and 1050 K are computed using Equation (20) and the theoretical data are depicted in Figure 15. It is noticed that
at the temperatures under consideration which confirms the segregating character of Cd-Tl melts. Again,
has minimum values at
i.e. 0.3679 and 0.4554 respectively for 650 K and 750 K and again, has minimum values at
i.e. 0.5145, 0.5621 and 0.6022 for 850 K, 950 K and 1050 K respectively. This indicates lowering of segregating character of Cd-Tl melts at the undertaken temperatures.
Figure 14.
vs
for Cd-Tl melts at 650 K, 750 K, 850 K, 950 K & 1050 K.
Figure 15.
vs
for Cd-Tl melts at 650 K, 750 K, 850 K, 950 K & 1050 K.
4. Conclusions
In present work, the concentration dependent properties such as
,
activity coefficient, activity,
,
,
and
for Cd-Tl melts at 750 K have been successfully explored. The results exhibit the segregating nature of Cd-Tl melts at 750 K. The asymmetries in
,
and
for Cd-Tl melts at 750 K are successfully explained. Again, MIVM model is employed for the theoretical predictions of
,
activity,
,
,
and
for Cd-Tl melts at 650 K, 750 K, 850 K, 950 K and 1050 K. The results indicate that the segregating character of Cd-Tl melts degrades when temperature rises from 650 K to 1050 K. Further, Cd-Tl melt is a feebly segregating alloy in the temperature range 650 - 1050 K.
Therefore, MIVM model is a relevant and reliable model to explore the thermodynamic behavior of segregating alloys at different temperatures.
Author Contributions
Conceptualization, I. S. Jha and J. Mandal; methodology, N. K. Roy; validation, I. S. Jha, J. Mandal and R. P. Chaudhary; formal analysis; R. P. Chaudhary; investigation, A. P. Singh; writing original draft preparation, A. P. Singh; writing-review and editing, N. K. Roy; visualization, I. S. Jha; supervision, J. Mandal. All authors have read and agreed to published version of the manuscript.