Hafizuddin Mohd Salleh¹, Mohamed Saiful Firdaus Hussin^1*, Adibah Haneem Mohd Dom², Azrul Abidin Zakaria³, Jufriadi^4
1Faculty of Mechanical Technology and Engineering, Universiti Teknikal Malaysia Melaka, Durian Tunggal, Malaysia.
²Faculty of Industrial and Manufacturing Technology and Engineering, Universiti Teknikal Malaysia Melaka, Durian Tunggal, Malaysia.
³Department of Mechanical Engineering, Universiti Tenaga Nasional, Kajang, Malaysia.
⁴Department of Mechanical Engineering, Politeknik Negeri Lhokseumawe, Indonesia.
DOI: 10.4236/jpee.2026.146001   PDF    HTML   XML   7 Downloads   81 Views   Citations

Abstract

Hydroxyapatite has attracted a significant attention in biomedical applications due to its excellent biocompatibility, bioactivity, osteoconductivity, and non-toxic nature. Fish processing wastes, particularly fish bones and scales, have emerged as a sustainable and cost-effective natural source for hydroxyapatite extraction. The increasing global demand for environmentally friendly biomaterials has accelerated research into the utilization of fish-derived waste for bone tissue engineering. This review comprehensively discusses the extraction, characterization, and in vitro studies of hydroxyapatite from various fish species. Furthermore, the review highlights structural, morphological, thermal, and biological characteristics of fish-derived hydroxyapatite. Despite considerable progress, challenges associated with compositional variability, reproducibility, and large-scale commercialization remain significant barriers to clinical translation. Fish-derived hydroxyapatite demonstrates substantial potential as a sustainable biomaterial for future orthopedic and dental applications.

Keywords

Material Science, Health Science, Biomedical Engineering, Regenerative Medicine

Share and Cite:

1. Introduction

Natural bone is a hierarchically organized porous composite consisting of both organic and inorganic phases that function synergistically to achieve exceptional mechanical and biological performance. The organic matrix is predominantly composed of collagen and provides flexibility, toughness, and resistance to crack propagation. In contrast, the inorganic phase is mainly represented by hydroxyapatite (HA), Ca₅(PO₄)₃(OH), a crystalline calcium phosphate mineral that contributes stiffness and compressive strength to the skeletal structure (Figure 1) [1].

Figure 1. Hydroxyapatite [1].

While HA enhances load-bearing capacity and structural rigidity, it exhibits relatively limited resistance to torsional and shear stresses [2]. The combination of mineralized HA with the collagenous matrix therefore enables natural bone to balance strength and toughness effectively [3]. Owing to its chemical similarity to the mineral component of human hard tissue, HA has attracted considerable attention as a biomaterial for bone repair and regeneration, particularly due to its excellent biocompatibility, osteoconductivity, and ability to promote direct interactions with surrounding cells and biological tissues.

Bone tissue regeneration remains a central focus within regenerative medicine, driving extensive investigation into calcium-based biomaterials for the reconstruction, repair, and functional restoration of damaged skeletal structures. Among these materials, studies demonstrate their strong potential to support bone formation and integration with host tissue [4]-[7]. These foundational findings stimulated substantial research efforts aimed at optimizing HA synthesis, tailoring its physicochemical properties, and expanding its biomedical applications.

In recent years, increasing attention has been directed toward the extraction of hydroxyapatite from naturally derived resources. Beyond conventional synthetic sources, researchers have explored alternative biomaterials including mammalian bones, fish bones, and scales, marine shells, plant/based precursor, and mineral deposits. Natural-source HA has been reported to exhibit distinct physicochemical characteristics compared with fully synthetic counterparts, such as higher aspect ratios, increased porosity and surface area, and improved particle dispersibility. These features can enhance biological performance by promoting favorable cell-material interactions, improving osteoconductivity, and supporting cellular proliferation while reducing apoptosis rates [8]-[11]. Consequently, naturally derived HA has gained significant interest as a biomimetic material capable of more closely replicating the hierarchical structure and functionality of native bone.

Hydroxyapatite research is inherently interdisciplinary, integrating contributions from dentistry, materials science, chemistry, biochemistry, biology, and biomedical engineering. The review aims to provide a comprehensive overview of the evolution of hydroxyapatite research in fish bones and scales, with particular emphasis on its role as a biomimetic and bioactive material. The article synthesizes current advancements and critically evaluates state-of-the-art evidence, including findings from clinical investigations, in vitro and in vivo studies supporting the efficacy of hydroxyapatite.

2. Methodology

The literature was reviewed from the year 2021 within the scope of fish bones and fish scales for biomedical applications using the Scopus and Google Scholar databases. The keywords used in this review were “fish bones” or “fish scales” in “biomedical applications”. The scope of the study focused on the characterization of the physicochemical properties and the in vitro evaluation of natural hydroxyapatite from fish by-product.

3. Fish Bones and Scales for Biomedical Applications

Fish bones and scales have emerged as promising biogenic resources for biomedical applications due to structural similarity to human hard tissues. These materials are primarily. Unlike synthetic counterparts, HA derived from fish waste often exhibits superior bioactivity, osteoconductivity, and biocompatibility, attributed to its naturally occurring ionic substitutions and hierarchical microstructure. In addition to their favourable biological properties, fish bones and scales represent an abundant by-product of the global fisheries and aquaculture industries, making them cost effective and environmentally responsible alternative to sources like bovine bone, which may pose risks related to disease transmission.

A study reported by Swamiappan et al. [12] that synthesized hydroxyapatite (HA) from Cirrhinus molitorella fish scale using ultrasonic assisted method produce Ca/P molar ratio of 1.67, similar to ideal stoichiometric ratio. Rod-like HA was produced with high specific surface area of 112 m²/g and mesoporous features. Using Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) (Figure 2), the spectra show a dominant spiky surface texture, which can enhance cell interaction. The synthesized HA exhibited a compressive strength of approximately 114 MPa, suggesting adequate mechanical performance for potential bone substitute materials.

Horta et al. [13] investigated the properties of hydroxyapatite extracted from Osteoglossum bicirrhosum fish scale using the combination of alkaline treatment and thermal calcination at the temperature of 600˚C and 800˚C. The natural HA derived shows non-toxic behaviour toward dental pulp stem cells. No adverse cellular effects were observed at the tested concentrations, demonstrating that the material is biocompatible for biomedical use. In-vitro bioactivity assays showed that the fish scale-derived HA formed a bone-like apatite layer more rapidly than synthetic HA when incubated in McCoy culture medium for 3 days.

Figure 2. AFM spectra of Cirrhinus molitorella fish scale [12].

Gnanasekaran et al. [14] investigated the production of HA from bones of red big eye fish using alkaline hydrolysis and thermal calcination methods. The optimized alkaline hydrolysis treatment with sodium hydroxide produced high-purity hydroxyapatite by effectively removing organic components such as collagen from the bone matrix. Microscopic analysis through SEM showed that the synthesized HA particles possessed spherical morphology with nanoscale sizes ranging approximately 50 - 80 nm (Figure 3). In addition, in vitro biological evaluation using MG-63 osteoblast-like cells demonstrated that the extracted HA was non-cytotoxic and biocompatible with cell proliferation racing about 92 % relative to control.

Figure 3. SEM images of HA from red big eye fish bones [14].

In another research, Hussin and colleagues [15] evaluated the hydroxyapatite extracted from Fringescale sardinella bones. Bioactivity evaluation in simulated body fluid (SBF) showed the formation of a bone-like apatite layer on the HA surface which demonstrated good apatite-forming ability. This behaviour indicates that the material has osteoconductive potential which is essential for bone bonding and regeneration. Besides, cell viability studies indicate that the extracted HA exhibited low cytotoxicity and good biocompatibility in supporting cell survival and proliferation with cell viability of more than 100 % in comparison with positive control (Figure 4).

Figure 4. Cell viability of HA of Fringescale sardinella bones [15].

Figure 5. Compressive strength, porosity, and hardness of PMMA/HA scaffolds from Catla catla fish scale [16].

Deb et al. [16] in their study investigated the fabrication and performance of a composite scaffold incorporating hydroxyapatite derived from the scales of Catla catla scales. Mechanical testing demonstrated that the inclusion of HA significantly enhanced the compressive strength at 70% HA and reduced the hardness of the scaffold in comparison with the pure polymer matrix (Figure 5). The mechanical performance approached the range required for cancellous bone applications. Meanwhile, in vitro evaluation showed that the scaffold exhibited good cytocompatibility, supporting cell adhesion, proliferation, and viability.

Kodali et al. [17] found in their study that HA extracted from carpa and pink perch fish scales can be successfully incorporated into polycaprolactone (PCL) fibres using the forcespinning process. Figure 6 shows the morphology of both calcined HA powder and nanomilled HA powder that have irregular size. Structural characterization confirmed that the HA particles were uniformly distributed within the fibrous matrix. The addition of fish scale derived HA influenced the fibre morphology by producing rougher fibre surfaces and slightly reduced fibre diameters, which increased the surface area. These morphological changes enhanced the scaffold’s suitability for cell attachment and proliferation. The results also demonstrated that incorporating HA into forcespun PCL fibre scaffolds improved mechanical performance and cellular response, indicating strong potential for developing advanced biomimetic scaffolds for bone tissue engineering.

Figure 6. SEM images of (a) calcined HA powder and (b) nanomilled HA powder [17].

Parthasarathy and team [18] explored the potential of HA from Scarrus ghobban scales for wound healing. Highly crystalline hydroxyapatite with nanoscale particle size was produced, resembling the mineral composition of natural bone. The synthesized material exhibited nanoscale morphology with porous and agglomerated structures, which provide a high surface area beneficial for biological interactions. Cell migration assays revealed that HA significantly enhanced cell migration and wound closure rates, suggesting that the material can promote tissue regeneration and accelerate wound healing process. This property is particularly valuable for regenerative medicine.

Kamal et al. [19] investigated the influence of sintering temperature on the properties of HA extracted from bones and skull of Anabas testudineus. The study showed that increasing sintering temperature significantly improved crystallinity (Figure 7) and grain growth of the HA. They also found that HA exhibited higher density, reduced porosity, and improved mechanical strength. These improvements are attributed to enhanced particle bonding and microstructural densification during the calcination process.

Jaffri et al. [20] evaluated the preparation and characterization of HA derived from fish scale waste of Black Tilapia. Microscopic analysis revealed that the synthesized HA exhibited irregular and agglomerated microstructures, which are typical for biogenic HA obtained through calcination of natural sources. Analytical results also showed characteristic diffraction peaks and functional groups associated with phosphate and hydroxyl, indicating successful transformation of the fish scale mineral component into HA.

Figure 7. XRD spectrum of HA at 1200, 1250, and 1300˚C [19].

Figure 8. SEM images of nano-HA of (a) Tuna and (b) Tilapia [22].

Mashrafi et al. [21] examined the extraction and characterization of HA from scales of Tenualosa ilisha and Labeo rohita. Thermal calcination was used to remove organic components and both fish species yielded pure HA. However, HA derived from Tenualosa ilisha exhibited higher crystallinity. HA derived from both fish scales showed agglomerated particles composed of nanoscale crystallites, in which Tenualosa ilisha-derived HA showed more uniform and compact particle morphology. The Labeo rohita-derived HA displayed relatively less uniform particle distribution, indicating slight differences in mineral composition and growth behaviour.

Archana and colleagues have successfully extracted nano-HA from both tuna and tilapia bones [22]. Both species yielded pure HA with Ca/P ratio close to the stoichiometric value, indicating compositional similarity to natural bone mineral. Minor trace element inherent to fish bone were retained, which may enhance biological activity. From the electron microscopy, it was revealed that both source produced agglomerated nano-HA (Figure 8), resulting in high surface area. Both tuna and tilapia derived nano-HA exhibited low cytotoxicity and good biocompatibility while cell viability studies demonstrated that the materials supported cell adhesion and proliferation, indicating compatibility with mammalian cells.

Fatmawati et al. [23] explored the nano-calcium derived from fish waste of Clarias gariepinus (catfish) and Channa striata (snakehead fish). They found that both fish species produced calcium-rich materials dominated by HA and calcium phosphate phases. The extracted particles exhibited irregular and agglomerated structures, typical of biogenic calcium powders. The agglomeration is caused by strong interactions between nanoscale calcium phosphate particles.

Kim et al. [24] have successfully fabricated 3D-printed scaffold composed of PCL, marine collagen, and carbonated HA extracted from fish bones. The composite scaffold maintained structural stability and homogenous dispersion of HA particles within the polymer matrix. The presence of collagen enhanced the hydrophilicity and surface bioactivity of the scaffold. In addition, 3D printing method generated regular and interconnected macropores, enabling nutrient diffusion and cell migration. The incorporation of collagen and HA improved surface roughness, which favours cell attachment.

Eknapakul et al. in their study [25] investigated a cost effective approach of extracting HA from fish scale of Nile Tilapia. The synthesized HA exhibited irregular and agglomerated particle morphology and the particle size ranging of fine micro- to nanoscale crystallites (250 - 2500 nm). In terms of chemical composition, the primary elements detected were calcium, phosphorus, and oxygen.

In general, fish scale derived HA demonstrates higher crystallinity and phase purity compared to fish scale derived HA due to the mineral component in bones is more abundant and structurally organized, resulting in enhanced thermal stability. In contrast, fish bone derived HA often retains a greater amount of organic constituents and trace elements, which may contribute to improved biological performance.

Table 1 highlights considerable variability in the pre-treatment and calcination parameters in processing fish bones and scales from different species. Boiling pretreatment durations range from as short as 10 minutes to as long as 12 hours, indicating flexibility in inorganic matter removal depending on the raw material’s density. Drying conditions are relatively consistent, typically conducted between 40 and 120˚C, with durations spanning 1 to 24 hours, ensuring adequate moisture removal prior to thermal treatment. Calcination temperature exhibits a wide variation ranging from as low as 200˚C to as high as 1100˚C, with higher temperature commonly applied to tilapia-derived bones to achieve increased crystallinity and phase purity of HA. Dwell times during calcination vary between 2 and 8 hours, with longer durations typically associated with lower calcination temperatures to ensure complete decomposition of organic components.

Table 1. Pretreatment and calcination parameters in processing fish bones and scales.

Species	Pretreatment (Boiling)	Drying	Heating Rate	Temperature	Dwelling Time	References
Salmon Bone	12 h	12 h at 60˚C	-	650˚C	5 h	[26]
Nile Tilapia Bone	1 h	1 h at 50˚C	-	900˚C - 1100˚C	-	[27]
Tilapia Bone	1 h	-	5˚C/min	900˚C	8 h	[28]
Snakehead Bone	3 h	12 h at 80˚C	5˚C/min	600˚C	5 h	[29]
Spanish Mackerel Bone	10 minutes	3 h at 100˚C		400, 600, & 800˚C	3 h	[30]
Grass Carp Scale	-	24 h at 100˚C	-	-	-	[31]
Carp Scale	-	3 h at 40˚C	-	-	-	[32]
Common Carp Bone	4 h	17 h at 120˚C	5˚C/min	200 - 1000˚C	2 h	[33]

Table 2 presents the in vitro evaluations conducted on HA derived from various fish-based sources, highlighting the diversity of biological models employed to assess their biomedical potential. A broad spectrum of cell lines and biological systems has been used to evaluate the biocompatibility and bioactivity of these materials. Several studies employed osteoblast-related cell lines such as MG-63 and SaOS-2 to investigate cell viability, proliferation, and osteogenic response. For instance, HA derived from catla scales, silver carp bones, emperor bones, and snakehead fish was tested on MG-63 cells, indicating a strong emphasis on osteoblastic compatibility. Similarly, HA from sardine scales and Labeo rohita scales was evaluated using SaOS-2 human osteosarcoma cells, further confirming its suitability for bone-related applications.

In addition to osteoblast-like cells, preosteoblastic and stem cell models were also utilized to provide deeper insights into osteogenic differentiation potential. Whitemouth croaker bone-derived HA was assessed using MC3T3-E1 preosteoblast cells, while black tilapia scale and catla bone-derived HA were tested using human fetal osteoblasts and mesenchymal stem cells, respectively. Moreover, human bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells were employed in the evaluation of HA from Lates calcarifer bone. Beyond cellular studies, several investigations incorporated simulated physiological environments and microbiological assays. Simulated body fluid (SBF) testing was conducted on HA derived from black tilapia scales and catla bones to evaluate apatite-forming ability and bioactivity. Additionally, antibacterial properties were examined using pathogens such as Streptococcus mutans, particularly for HA derived from black tilapia and snakehead bones. Agar well diffusion assays were also performed for Labeo rohita scale-derived HA, indicating an interest in assessing antimicrobial performance alongside biocompatibility.

Table 2. Summary of in vitro evaluations.

Hydroxyapatite Source	Cell/Solution/Bacteria	References
Catla Scale	MG 63 Cell Line	[34]
Whitemouth Croaker Bone	Preosteoblast MC3T3-E1 Cell	[35]
Labeo rohita Scale	Saos-2 Human Osteosarcoma Cell	[36]
Silver Carp Bone	Osteoblast MG 63 Cell Line	[37]
Sardine Scale	SaOS-2, L929, and LIG Cells	[38]
Black Tilapia Scale	Simulated Body Fluid, Human Fetal Osteoblast Cell Line	[39]
Lates calcarifer Bone	Human Bone Marrow-Derived Mesenchymal Stem Cell	[40]
Emperor Bone	MG 63 Cell Line	[41]
Snakehead Fish	MG 63 Cell Line	[42]
Catla Bone	Simulated Body Fluid, Human Mesenchymal Stem Cell	[43]
Black Tilapia Bone	Streptococcus mutans	[44]
Snakehead Bone	Streptococcus mutans	[45]
Labeo rohita Scale	Agar Well Diffusion Assay	[46]

4. Conclusion

Fish bones and scales offer a promising potential for the extraction of hydroxyapatite due to their sustainability, economically-wise, and availability compared to synthetic and mammalian-derived biomaterials. The abundance of fishery waste generated worldwide provides significant opportunities for converting biological resources into high-value biomaterials for orthopedic, dental, and bone tissue engineering applications. Various extraction approaches have demonstrated the capability to produce hydroxyapatite with desirable physicochemical and biological properties. It also exhibited advantage over conventional synthetic hydroxyapatite due to presence of trace elements such as magnesium, sodium, zinc, and strontium, which contribute to enhancing osteoconductivity, bioactivity, and cellular response. Furthermore, the incorporation of fish-derived hydroxyapatite into polymeric and composite systems has shown considerable potential in improving the mechanical and biological performance of biomaterials intended for bone tissue regeneration.

Acknowledgements

The authors would like to thank Centre of Research and Innovation Management (CRIM), Universiti Teknikal Malaysia Melaka, for the financial support of this research project.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest regarding the publication of this paper.

References

[1]	National Center for Biotechnology Information (2026) PubChem Compound Summary for CID 14781, Hydroxylapatite (Ca5(OH)(PO4)3). https://pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/compound/Durapatite
[2]	Miri, Z., Haugen, H.J., Loca, D., Rossi, F., Perale, G., Moghanian, A., et al. (2024) Review on the Strategies to Improve the Mechanical Strength of Highly Porous Bone Bioceramic Scaffolds. Journal of the European Ceramic Society, 44, 23-42.[CrossRef]
[3]	Amirrah, I.N., Lokanathan, Y., Zulkiflee, I., Wee, M.F.M.R., Motta, A. and Fauzi, M.B. (2022) A Comprehensive Review on Collagen Type I Development of Biomaterials for Tissue Engineering: From Biosynthesis to Bioscaffold. Biomedicines, 10, Article 2307.[CrossRef] [PubMed]
[4]	Min, K.H., Kim, D.H., Kim, K.H., Seo, J. and Pack, S.P. (2024) Biomimetic Scaffolds of Calcium-Based Materials for Bone Regeneration. Biomimetics, 9, Article 511.[CrossRef] [PubMed]
[5]	Liang, W., Zhou, C., Bai, J., Zhang, H., Long, H., Jiang, B., et al. (2024) Prospective Applications of Bioactive Materials in Orthopedic Therapies: A Review. Heliyon, 10, e36152.[CrossRef] [PubMed]
[6]	Han, F., Liu, Z., Wei, Q., Ding, L., Yu, L., Wang, J., et al. (2025) Minimally Invasive Implantable Biomaterials for Bone Reconstruction. Engineering, 46, 23-46.[CrossRef]
[7]	Huang, X., Lou, Y., Duan, Y., Liu, H., Tian, J., Shen, Y., et al. (2024) Biomaterial Scaffolds in Maxillofacial Bone Tissue Engineering: A Review of Recent Advances. Bioactive Materials, 33, 129-156.[CrossRef] [PubMed]
[8]	Suresh, N., Sweety, V.K., Suresh, N., Suraj, A.R., Waltimo, T. and Anil, S. (2026) Natural Sources of Hydroxyapatite for Biomedical Applications. Ceramics International, 52, 1383-1391.[CrossRef]
[9]	Diez-Escudero, A., Espanol, M. and Ginebra, M. (2024) High-Aspect-Ratio Nanostructured Hydroxyapatite: Towards New Functionalities for a Classical Material. Chemical Science, 15, 55-76.[CrossRef] [PubMed]
[10]	Mocanu, A., Miculescu, F., Dascălu, C., Voicu, Ș.I., Pandele, M., Ciocoiu, R., et al. (2022) Influence of Ceramic Particles Size and Ratio on Surface—Volume Features of the Naturally Derived Ha-Reinforced Filaments for Biomedical Applications. Journal of Functional Biomaterials, 13, Article 199.[CrossRef] [PubMed]
[11]	Vijayan, A., Vishnu, J., A, R., Shankar, B. and Sambhudevan, S. (2025) A Review on Hydroxyapatite Fabrication: From Powders to Additive Manufactured Scaffolds. Biomaterials Science, 13, 913-945.[CrossRef] [PubMed]
[12]	Swamiappan, S., Xie, X., Lu, C. and Peng, X. (2025) Ultrasonic-Assisted Green Synthesis and Characterization of Nano-Hydroxyapatite from Cirrhinus molitorella Fish Scales Bio-Waste for Biomedical Applications. Ceramics International, 51, 20452-20464.[CrossRef]
[13]	Horta, M.K.d.S., Moura, F.J., Aguilar, M.S., Westin, C.B., Navarro da Rocha, D. and de Campos, J.B. (2021) In Vitro Evaluation of Natural Hydroxyapatite from Osteoglossum bicirrhosum Fish Scales for Biomedical Application. International Journal of Applied Ceramic Technology, 18, 1930-1937.[CrossRef]
[14]	Gnanasekaran, R., Yuvaraj, D., Muthu, C.M.M., Ashwin, R., Kaarthikeyan, K., Kumar, V.V., et al. (2024) Extraction and Characterization of Biocompatible Hydroxyapatite (HAp) from Red Big Eye Fish Bone: Potential for Biomedical Applications and Reducing Biowastes. Sustainable Chemistry for the Environment, 7, Article ID: 100142.[CrossRef]
[15]	Saiful Firdaus Hussin, M., Izwana Idris, M., Zuhudi Abdullah, H., Azeem, W. and Ghazali, I. (2023) Characterization and in Vitro Evaluation of Hydroxyapatite from Fringescale sardinella Bones for Biomedical Applications. Journal of Saudi Chemical Society, 27, Article ID: 101721.[CrossRef]
[16]	Deb, P., Das Lala, S., Barua, E. and Deoghare, A.B. (2024) Physico-Mechanical and Biological Analysis of Composite Bone Scaffold Developed from Catla catla Fish Scale Derived Hydroxyapatite for Bone Tissue Engineering. Arabian Journal for Science and Engineering, 49, 27-41.[CrossRef]
[17]	Kodali, D., Hembrick-Holloman, V., Gunturu, D.R., Samuel, T., Jeelani, S. and Rangari, V.K. (2022) Influence of Fish Scale-Based Hydroxyapatite on Forcespun Polycaprolactone Fiber Scaffolds. ACS Omega, 7, 8323-8335.[CrossRef] [PubMed]
[18]	Parthasarathy, S., Arulselvan, P., Gosala, R. and Subramanian, B. (2025) Exploring the Wound Healing Potential of Biocompatible Nano-Hydroxyapatite Derived from Parrotfish Scale (Scarrus ghobban) Waste for Bone Tissue Engineering. Biocatalysis and Agricultural Biotechnology, 64, Article ID: 103493.[CrossRef]
[19]	Kamal, M.M., Mahmud, S., Plabon, I.A., Kader, M.A. and Islam, M.N. (2024) Effects of Sintering Temperature on the Physical, Structural, Mechanical and Antimicrobial Properties of Extracted Hydroxyapatite Ceramics from Anabas testudineus Bone and Head Scull for Biomedical Applications. Results in Materials, 22, Article ID: 100590.[CrossRef]
[20]	Jaffri, M.Z., Mohd Ismail, Z.M., Dermawan, S.K. and Abdullah, H.Z. (2022) Sample Preparation of the Natural Source Hydroxyapatite (HAp) Derived from Black Tilapia Fish Scales. Journal of Physics: Conference Series, 2169, Article ID: 012033.[CrossRef]
[21]	Bin Mobarak, M., Chowdhury, F. and Ahmed, S. (2024) Preparation and Characterization of Highly Crystalline Hydroxyapatite (HAp) from the Scales of an Anadromous Fish (Tenualosa ilisha): A Comparative Study with the Freshwater Fish Scale (Labeo rohita) Derived Hap. RSC Advances, 14, 39874-39889.[CrossRef] [PubMed]
[22]	Archana, S., Thool, O.K., Sowmya, S., Sabu, S., Navaf, M., Sunooj, K.V., et al. (2026) Extraction, Characterization and Biocompatibility Evaluation of Nano-Hydroxyapatite (n-HAP) from Tuna and Tilapia Bone Side Streams. Next Materials, 11, Article ID: 101826.[CrossRef]
[23]	Fatmawati, S., Istiqomah, S.M., Hasanah, N., Ina Kewa Helan, M.E., Santoso, M., Nugraheni, Z.V., et al. (2025) Physico-Chemical Characterization of Natural Nano Calcium Extracted from Different Fish Bones in Catfish (Clarias gariepinus) and Snakehead Fish (Channa striata). Case Studies in Chemical and Environmental Engineering, 11, Article ID: 101080. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
[24]	Kim, S., Heo, S., Oh, G., Yi, M. and Jung, W. (2022) A 3D-Printed Polycaprolactone/Marine Collagen Scaffold Reinforced with Carbonated Hydroxyapatite from Fish Bones for Bone Regeneration. Marine Drugs, 20, Article 344.[CrossRef] [PubMed]
[25]	Eknapakul, T., Kuimalee, S., Sailuam, W., Daengsakul, S., Tanapongsipit, N., Laohana, P., Saenrang, W., Bootchanont, A., Khamkongkaeo, A. and Yimnirun, R. (2024) Impacts of Pre-Treatment Methods on the Morphology, Crystal Structure, and Defects Formation of Hydroxyapatite Extracted from Nile Tilapia Scales. RSC Advances, 14, 4614-4622.[CrossRef] [PubMed]
[26]	Muñoz, F., Haidar, Z.S., Puigdollers, A., Guerra, I., Padilla, M.C., Ortega, N., et al. (2024) Efficient Hydroxyapatite Extraction from Salmon Bone Waste: An Improved Lab-Scaled Physico-Chemico-Biological Process. Molecules, 29, Article 4002.[CrossRef] [PubMed]
[27]	Arkanit, K., Senphan, T., Issapap, N., Mungmueang, N., Sriket, P., Benjakul, S., et al. (2025) Physicochemical Properties and Bioavailability of Bio-Calcium Products from Tilapia Bone: A Comparative Study with Synthetic Hydroxyapatite. Journal of Agriculture and Food Research, 19, Article ID: 101708.[CrossRef]
[28]	da Cruz, J.A., Pezarini, R.R., Sales, A.J.M., Benjamin, S.R., de Oliveira Silva, P.M. and Graça, M.P.F. (2024) Study of Biphasic Calcium Phosphate (BCP) Ceramics of Tilapia Fish Bones by Age. Spectrochimica Acta Part A: Molecular and Biomolecular Spectroscopy, 316, Article ID: 124289.[CrossRef] [PubMed]
[29]	Herpandi, Hanif, I., Widiastuti, I. and Sudirman, S. (2024) Hydroxyapatite Characteristics from Snakehead Fish (Channa striata) Bone via Alkali Treatment Followed by Calcination Method. Tropical Journal of Natural Product Research, 8, 6147-6151.
[30]	Anggraini, R.M., Restianingsih, T., Deswardani, F., Fendriani, Y. and Ananda Putri Purba, R. (2023) Characterization of Hydroxyapatite from Channa Striata and Scomberomorus Commerson Fish Bone by Heat Treatment. Journal Online of Physics, 9, 49-54.[CrossRef]
[31]	Swamiappan, S., Zheng, Z., Lin, R., Xie, X., Wang, J., Lu, C., et al. (2026) Preparation of Biocompatible Nano-Hydroxyapatite with Osteogenic Potential from Ctenopharyngodon idella Fish Scales for Bone Regeneration. Ceramics International, 52, 19315-19327.[CrossRef]
[32]	Meenakshi, S.V., Muthupriya, P., Kanchana, G., Kishorkumar, S., Yogeshkanna, M., Shakinkathu, N., et al. (2024) Fish Scale and Eggshell Conversion into Hydroxyapatite: A Route to Dentistry Treatment. Applied Physics A, 130, Article No. 434.[CrossRef]
[33]	Challoob, D.A. (2023) Characterisation and in Vitro Bioactivity of Hydroxyapatite Extracted from Carp Fish Bones for Biomedical Applications. Ceramics—Silikaty, 67, 81-86.[CrossRef]
[34]	Ayyanar, C.B., Marimuthu, K., Gayathri, B. and Sankarrajan, (2021) Characterization and in Vitro Cytotoxicity Evaluation of Fish Scale and Seashell Derived Nano-Hydroxyapatite High-Density Polyethylene Composite. Polymers and Polymer Composites, 29, 1534-1542.[CrossRef]
[35]	Prado, J.P.D.S., Yamamura, H., Magri, A.M.P., Ruiz, P.L.M., Prado, J.L.D.S., Rennó, A.C.M., et al. (2021) In Vitro and in Vivo Biological Performance of Hydroxyapatite from Fish Waste. Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine, 32, Article No. 109.[CrossRef] [PubMed]
[36]	Prathibha, P.M., Thomas, N.G., Dalvi, Y.B., Varghese, K.G., Binsi, P.K., Zynudheen, A.A., et al. (2024) Fish Scale-Derived Hydroxyapatite for Alveolar Ridge Preservation. Biotechnology and Applied Biochemistry, 71, 1272-1280.[CrossRef] [PubMed]
[37]	Acharya, P., Kupendra, M., Fasim, A., Anantharaju, K.S., Kottam, N., Murthy, V.K., et al. (2022) Synthesis of Nano Hydroxyapatite from Hypopthalmichthys molitrix (Silver Carp) Bone Waste by Two Different Methods: A Comparative Biophysical and in Vitro Evaluation on Osteoblast MG63 Cell Lines. Biotechnology Letters, 44, 1175-1188.[CrossRef] [PubMed]
[38]	Hamrouni, N., Oudadesse, H., Lefeuvre, B., Bouvret, E. and Le Penven, S. (2025) Development and Characterization of a Sardine Scale‐chitosan Biomaterial: In Vivo Evaluation for Bone Regeneration in a Rat Osteoporosis Model. Journal of Biomedical Materials Research Part B: Applied Biomaterials, 113, e35620.[CrossRef]
[39]	Rafai, N.H., Jaffri, M.Z., Abdullah, H.Z. and Idris, M.I. (2025) Effect of Calcination on the Bioactivity of Hydroxyapatite (HAp) from Black Tilapia Fish Scale. International Journal of Integrated Engineering, 17, 26-33.[CrossRef]
[40]	Le Ho, K.H., Dao, V.H., Pham, X.K., Nguyen, P.A., Phan, B.V., Doan, T.T., et al. (2025) Characterization, Cytotoxicity and Cell Proliferation of Two Hydroxyapatite Products from Lates Calcarifer Fish Bones via Thermal Calcination. Materials Research Express, 12, Article ID: 025402.[CrossRef]
[41]	Salian, A., Prakash, A.K., Gulladi, G., Andiappan, S., Surasani, V.K.R. and Varadaraju, R.C. (2025) Valorization of Emperor Fish (Lethrinus fraenatus) Filleting Waste in to Fishbone Hydroxyapatite by Thermal Calcination Method. Biomass Conversion and Biorefinery, 15, 27671-27678.[CrossRef]
[42]	Dewi, N., Rahmah, R.A., Wardhana, A.S., Puspitasari, D., Wasiaturrahmah, Y. and Gustiono, D. (2025) Remineralizing Potential of Natural Hydroxyapatite from Snakehead (Channa striata) Fish Bone on Remineralization of Primary Teeth Enamel: An in Vitro Study. European Journal of General Dentistry, 14, 11-19.[CrossRef]
[43]	Deb, P., Das Lala, S., Sarkar, P., Nath, A. and Barua, E. (2025) Unlocking Treasure from Fish Bones: Bioinspired Hydroxyapatite Synthesis from Catla catla Fish for Sustainable Waste-To-Wealth. International Journal of Materials Research, 116, 173-182.[CrossRef]
[44]	Hasan, M.R., Ghazali, M.S.M. and Mohtar, N.F. (2024) Antibacterial Activity of Natural-Based Toothpaste Incorporated with Nanohydroxyapatite from Fish Bone against Dental Caries Bacteria. Food Research, 8, 192-200.[CrossRef]
[45]	Dewi, N., Rahmadella, A., Hatta, I., Apriasari, M.L. and Putri, D.K.T. (2024) Antibacterial Activity of Nano-Hydroxyapatite Paste of Snakehead Fish Bone against S. mutans: An in Vitro Study. Padjadjaran Journal of Dentistry, 36, Article 9.[CrossRef]
[46]	Mohammed-Salih, H.S., Mahmood, R.I., Ghazi, A., AlQrimli, A.F., Rashid, T.M., Al-Obaidi, J.R., et al. (2025) Antibacterial Effect of Novel Orthodontic PEEK Beads Coated with a Conjugate of Fish Scale Hydroxy-Apatite Nanoparticles and GL13K Peptide. BioNanoScience, 15, Article No. 557.[CrossRef]