Epidemiology and Clinical Presentation of Cleft Lip and Palate in Brazzaville ()
1. Introduction
Cleft lip and palate (CLP) is the most common congenital malformation of the cephalic extremity, manifesting as a break in the continuity of the lip and/or palate [1]-[3]. They constitute a major health problem due to the social disability associated with the disfigurement they cause. They can be unilateral or bilateral, isolated or part of a multiple malformation syndrome [2]. In Africa, delayed consultation and difficulties in accessing care worsen their functional prognosis [4].
In Brazzaville, in a context marked by delayed consultation, socio-economic constraints and partial dependence on solidarity programmes [4]-[6], an updated epidemiological and clinical analysis appears essential to guide the organisation of care and improve treatment.
This paper aims to describe the epidemiological and clinical aspects of cleft lip and palate at the Brazzaville University Hospital.
2. Materials and Methods
This was a descriptive cross-sectional study with retrospective data collection, conducted in the Stomatology and Maxillofacial Surgery Department of the Brazzaville University Hospital over a period of six (6) years, from 1 January 2020 to 31 December 2025.
This department provides free treatment for cleft lip and palate.
Our study population consisted of facial malformations treated in the department during the study period. Only cleft lip and palate facial malformations treated in the department with usable medical records were included. Other facial malformations and clefts with unusable records were excluded. This resulted in a total of 175 facial malformations, 164 of which were cleft lip and palate.
Data were collected from the hospitalization register, patient medical records completed after questioning and physical examination, and prenatal consultation records during pregnancy.
Two levels of analysis were used:
Analysis of all facial malformations: each patient with a facial malformation was counted. This analysis enabled the proportion of cleft lip and palate within facial malformations to be studied.
Analysis of patients with cleft lip and palate: for epidemiological and clinical aspects.
The study variables were:
Age at first consultation, sex, place of birth, time of first public outing;
Age of parents, socioeconomic status, mother’s level of education, consanguinity, exposure to domestic smoke, alcohol consumption, exposure to tobacco;
Origin, time of diagnosis, admission procedures, type of lesion, laterality;
Associated clinical manifestations: presence of eating disorders (aspiration), malnutrition, phonation disorders, recurrent ear infections. These were recorded in medical records after clinical confirmation during admissions.
The data were entered and analyzed using SPSS 2.0 software. Qualitative variables were expressed as numbers and percentages. Quantitative variables were expressed as means ± standard deviation. A descriptive approach was favored, without seeking causal correlations.
Anonymity, data confidentiality and ethical considerations were respected.
3. Results
175 malformations were admitted, including 164 cleft lips and palates, representing 93.7% of facial malformations. The number of patients was increasing every year.
The median age at the first consultation was 1 month, with extremes ranging from 1 day to 24 years. 95.1% of the population were paediatric patients. There were 90 boys (54.9%) and 74 girls (45.1%). The children were kept away from the public in 64 cases (39%) for more than three (3) months.
The diagnosis was made postnatally in 161 cases (98.2%) and antenatally in 3 cases (1.8%). The patients came from both urban (58%) and rural areas, with a significant proportion from regions far from Brazzaville. 59.1% of cleft cases were the first or second child in the family.
Admission was direct in 61% of cases and by referral in 39%. The median age of mothers was 28 years [24 years; 30 years] with ages ranging from 13 to 40 years. In contrast, the median age of the fathers was 35 years [30 years; 40 years], with extremes ranging from 15 to 55 years. 61% of parents were from a disadvantaged socioeconomic background. 52% of mothers had a primary school education.
Certain factors were frequently reported during these pregnancies, including lack of folic acid supplementation (30.5%), regular alcohol consumption (36.6%), smoking (6%), continuous exposure to smoke during cooking (69.5%), and attempted chemical abortion before the eighth week of amenorrhoea (5.5%). A family history of cleft palate was found in 6% of cases, as well as consanguinity in 18% of cases (Figure 1).
The clinical aspects were varied, with labial-velar involvement in 50.6%, labial-palatal involvement in 41.4% and velo-palatal involvement (Figure 2) in 8%. Disfiguring forms were apparent in 93.3% of cases. Left-sided clefts were found in 52.4% of cases, and 9.7% of clefts were bilateral (Figure 3).
9.8% of clefts were associated with musculoskeletal, cardiac, ocular (Figure 4), nasal, and urogenital abnormalities. 3.7% of clefts were syndromic, including four (4) cases of Von der Woude and two (2) cases of Pierre Robin.
Cleft palates were found predominantly in girls, at a ratio of two girls to one boy. Cleft lip and palate and cleft lip were found more frequently in males, with a male/female ratio of 1.16 and 1.38, respectively.
Several clinical consequences were found, including feeding disorders (90.9%), malnutrition (61%), phonation disorders (49.4%) and recurrent ear infections (27.4%).
Figure 1. Illustration of unilateral cleft lip.
Figure 2. Illustration of a velopalatina cleft.
Figure 3. illustration of a bilateral cleft lip.
Figure 4. Illustration of a cleft lip associated with right anophthalmia.
4. Discussion
Cleft lip and palate was the most common malformation, with a relative frequency of 93.7%.
This trend is the norm in maxillofacial surgery departments, but with varying frequencies in African literature [6] [7].
The median age at the first consultation was 1 month, compared with 11.8 years in the eastern part of the Republic of the Congo [8]. This can be explained by improved access to cleft lip and palate care following the solidarity offer [9].
A male predominance was found in the majority of studies, as well as a distribution of cleft types according to gender [10]-[13]. This can be explained mainly by biological and embryological factors.
In fact, facial structures develop at specific stages of embryonic life, and in boys, the closure of facial buds occurs slightly later, which increases the period of vulnerability to disturbances (genetic, environmental, nutritional or toxic). In addition, certain sex-related genetic factors and the influence of foetal sex hormones can modulate craniofacial growth differently, making boys more prone to cleft lip and cleft palate, while isolated cleft palate is more common in girls [14] [15].
Children were kept away from the public in 39% of cases for more than three (3) months, reflecting the stigma and sense of shame felt by parents [7] [16].
The diagnosis was made in 98.2% of cases postnatally, compared with 1.8% antenatally [17]. This observation is consistent with that of Oulai S. et al. in Côte d’Ivoire, where only six (6) cases were diagnosed before birth, compared with 50 to 80% of antenatal diagnoses in Europe [18] [19]. This difference can be explained by the fact that 3D and 4D ultrasound technology and the advanced expertise of operators are not yet available everywhere in Africa, but are available in Europe [17] [19].
Patients came from both urban and rural areas, with a significant proportion from regions far from Brazzaville, demonstrating parents’ commitment to care and improved availability of care for all [9]. 59.8% of clefts were the first or second in the sibling group, a result similar to that reported in the literature [3].
Mothers came on their own in 61% of cases, reflecting a weakness in the referral system. The mothers were relatively young, with a median age of 28 years, had a low level of education, and 61% were from a disadvantaged socioeconomic background, as highlighted in the African literature [10] [20].
Several factors likely to promote the occurrence of clefts were found during pregnancy, including lack of folic acid supplementation, regular alcohol consumption, smoking, continuous exposure to smoke during cooking, attempted chemical abortion before the eighth week of amenorrhoea, a family history of cleft palate, and consanguinity. These factors were found to varying degrees without proof of causality, as in certain studies [21]-[24]. However, some studies have found that certain factors are involved, notably smoking, obesity and high blood pressure [13] [25].
Furthermore, some studies have noted the role of exposure to smoke and air pollution in the occurrence of cleft lip and palate [26] [27].
The clinical aspects varied, with labioalveolar involvement being the most common. Cleft lip and palate and cleft lip were predominant in boys, while cleft palate was predominant in girls. Left-sided clefts were found in 52.4% of unilateral clefts [2] [24]. 9.7% of clefts were bilateral.
The profile of these characteristics was identical to that in the Democratic Republic of the Congo [8], whereas in other studies cleft lip and palate were predominant [10]-[12] [24].
Furthermore, these lesions were associated with other malformations in 9.8% of cases, including musculoskeletal abnormalities of the extremities, cardiac, ocular, nasal and urogenital abnormalities. This proportion varies in the literature, ranging from 5% in the east of the Republic of the Congo [3] to 11% in Sudan [10] and 20% in Port Harcourt, mainly cardiac and auditory [12]. This difference can be explained by the varying importance of genetic factors in different regions, as well as by underdiagnosis in contexts with limited resources [11] [14]. 3.7% of cases were syndromic, including four (4) cases of Von der Woude syndrome and two (2) cases of Pierre Robin syndrome, a lower proportion than that reported in the literature [14].
Several clinical consequences were found, including eating disorders (90.9%), malnutrition (61%), phonation disorders (49.4%) and recurrent ear infections (27.4%), clefts, proportions that are underestimated in our context compared to certain literature [11] [24].
This study provides a local baseline and paves the way for future analytical and multicentre studies. The limitations of our study include its retrospective nature, dependence on the quality of medical records, and the fact that it was conducted in a single centre, which may limit the generalisation of the results to other settings.
5. Conclusion
The epidemiological and clinical profile of cleft lip and palate is characterised by a predominance of male children born to parents with low socioeconomic status, both in urban and rural areas, with cleft lip being the most common condition. These clefts resulted from pregnancies exposed to cooking smoke, with early consultation, highlighting the positive impact of solidarity-based care policies. Analytical studies are needed to better identify risk factors and strengthen prevention and early care strategies.
Authors’ Contributions
All authors contributed to this work. All have read and approved the final version of this manuscript.