A field trial was conducted to study the impact of various potato germplasm against aphids, Myzus persicae (Sulzer) and Aphis gossypii Glover (Aphididae: Hemiptera) during rabi season from November to March in 2012-2013 and 2013-2014, respectively at Adisaptagram Block Seed Farm, Hooghly, West Bengal. The population of aphids was started on potato crop in between third week of December and first week of January irrespective of various germplasms, except K. Chipsona-2, where its infestation was initiated during second and third week of January. Then, their population was gradually increased to reach its critical level (ETL) during first and second week of January in most of the potato germplasm, except in K. Anand, K. Chipsona-1, K. Chipsona-2 and Sailaja, where it was crossed in between fourth week of January and first week of February. The peak population of aphids was observed during third and fourth week of February in most of the potato germplasm. It was observed that K. Ashoka, K. Badshah, K. Chandramukhi, K. Jawahar, K. Jyoti and K. Pukhraj were highly susceptible to the pests, while K. Anand and K. Sutlez were moderately susceptible but K. Chipsona-1 , K. Chipsona-2 and K. Sailaja were less susceptible or tolerant to the pests. Maximum tuber yield (t/ha) of potato was recorded in K. Badshah (36.58 - 43.92) while it was lowest in K. Chandramukhi (22.08 - 22.12).
Potato, Solanum tuberosum L. is generally grown in all most all states in India. More than 90% of potatoes are grown in the vast Indo-Gangetic plains of North India during short winter days from October to March. Among the various states of the country, Uttar Pradesh, West Bengal and Bihar accounted for nearly 71% area and 76% production of the country (Chadha, 2002) [
A field study on the performance of different potato germplasms against aphids was carried out during rabi season from November to March of 2012-13 and 2013-14 at Adisaptagram Block Seed Farm, Hooghly, West Bengal. The experiment was laid in a Randomized Block Design (RBD) with eleven potato germplasms viz., K. Anand (K. An), K. Ashoka (K. As), K. Badshah ( K. B), K. Chandramukhi (K. Cm), K. Chipsona-1 (K. Cs 1), K. Chipsona-2 (K. Cs 2), K. Jawahar (K. Jh), K. Jyoti (K. J), K. Pukhraj (K. P), K. Sutlez (K. Su) and K. Sailaja (K. Sl), each replicating for thrice. Plot size was kept at 6 m × 2 m with 60 cm inter-row and 20 cm intra-row spacing. The crop was planted by the end of November in every year. All standard agronomic practices in this region were strictly followed for raising the crop, except any insecticide application. Irrespective of the germplasms, the crop was dehaulmed at an age of 85 days i.e. during first week of March and finally ten days after haulm cutting the crop was harvested.
The population of aphids on potato was recorded at 7 days interval throughout the period of study. The count on the population of aphid was made from one upper, one middle and one lower compound leaf of 33 plants in zigzag manner at random and one leaf from 34th plant i.e., aphid population per 100 compound leaves (Simpson, 1940) [
All the data were analyzed by different statistical analysis (Zar, 1999).
In the first year of study during 2012-13, infestation of aphid was started in the third week of December in K. As, K. B, K. Cm, K. Jh, K. J and K. P. While it was by the end of December in K. Su only and it was during first week of January in K. An and K. Cs-1 (
But in K. Cs-2 and K. Sl, the pest was observed on the crop since second week of January. Then the population of the pest was gradually increased. The pest crossed the critical level in between first and second week of January in most of the potato germplasms. In K. An and K. Cs 1, the aphid crossed the threshold limit during end January. The aphid population reached the critical level first in K. Jh during end December and last in K. Cs-2 and K. Sl during first week of February. The pest population reached the peak during third and fourth week of February in all the germplasms and then downward trend of pest population was observed. The maximum
| Different germplasms | Tuber yield (t/ha) | December, 2012 | January, 2013 | February, 2013 | March, 2013 | Mean population | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| III WK | IV WK | I WK | II WK | III WK | IV WK | I WK | II WK | III WK | IV WK | I WK | |||
| K. Anand | 34.25 | 0.0 (0.0) | 0.0 (0.0) | 2.66 (0.44) | 7.66 (0.91) | 19.33 (1.28) | 54.00 (1.72) | 87.33 (1.93) | 124.66 (2.07) | 153.66 (2.15) | 207.00 (2.30) | 167.33 (2.20) | 63.36 |
| K. Ashoka | 36.21 | 7.33 (0.87) | 18.66 (1.25) | 31.33 (1.59) | 53.66 (1.72) | 76.66 (1.85) | 115.33 (2.04) | 168.33 (2.21) | 207.00 (2.30) | 283.33 (2.43) | 342.66 (2.52) | 275.33 (2.42) | 121.28 |
| K. Badshah | 36.58 | 3.66 (0.64) | 10.33 (1.00) | 32.33 (1.51) | 49.66 (1.67) | 82.66 (1.91) | 133.66 (2.10) | 179.33 (2.25) | 234.00 (2.36) | 303.33 (2.47) | 350.66 (2.53) | 281.33 (2.44) | 127.76 |
| K. Chandramukhi | 26.46 | 5.00 (0.74) | 11.66 (1.07) | 24.66 (1.39) | 38.00 (1.57) | 69.33 (1.82) | 129.66 (2.09) | 181.33 (2.24) | 228.33 (2.35) | 286.33 (2.44) | 324.33 (2.49) | 249.00 (2.38) | 119.05 |
| K. Chipsona-I | 22.17 | 0.0 (0.0) | 0.0 (0.0) | 2.66 (0.46) | 6.66 (0.81) | 11.33 (1.05) | 27.33 (1.42) | 68.66 (1.82) | 97.66 (1.95) | 131.66 (2.09) | 169.33 (2.20) | 112.33 (2.02) | 48.28 |
| K. Chipsona-II | 26.92 | 0.0 (0.0) | 0.0 (0.0) | 0.0 (0.0) | 3.00 (0.49) | 6.66 (0.84) | 12.33 (1.07) | 29.33 (1.43) | 56.33 (1.70) | 79.66 (1.84) | 126.66 (2.08) | 76.33 (1.85) | 30.02 |
| K. Jawahar | 27.87 | 6.00 (0.79) | 21.66 (1.33) | 56.66 (1.74) | 87.33 (1.93) | 127.33 (2.09) | 169.33 (2.22) | 227.00 (2.35) | 276.66 (2.43) | 341.33 (2.52) | 393.33 (2.58) | 286.33 (2.44) | 153.30 |
| K. Jyoti | 26.50 | 3.66 (0.53) | 8.66 (0.94) | 17.33 (1.24) | 30.33 (1.47) | 56.66 (1.71) | 97.33 (1.97) | 143.33 (2.14) | 212.66 (2.31) | 269.66 (2.42) | 244.33 (2.37) | 164.33 (2.19) | 96.02 |
| K. Pukhraj | 22.12 | 4.33 (0.65) | 9.33 (0.97) | 20.33 (1.31) | 38.33 (1.58) | 61.66 (1.76) | 94.66 (1.96) | 147.33 (2.16) | 192.33 (2.27) | 244.00 (2.37) | 172.66 (2.21) | 107.33 (1.99) | 84.02 |
| K. Sutlez | 25.79 | 0.0 (0.0) | 2.66 (0.44) | 10.66 (1.02) | 31.33 (1.49) | 48.33 (1.66) | 72.33 (1.85) | 114.33 (2.04) | 169.00 (2.22) | 234.33 (2. 35) | 196.66 (2.27) | 147.66 (2.14) | 79.02 |
| K. Sailaja | 33.25 | 0.0 (0.0) | 0.0 (0.0) | 0.0 (0.01) | 2.33 (0.43) | 8.66 (0.95) | 15.33 (1.17) | 31.66 (1.46) | 57.66 (1.73) | 83.33 (1.87) | 152.33 (2.16) | 104.66 (1.99) | 35.07 |
| Date of observation | Variety | Date of observation × variety | |
|---|---|---|---|
| SEM (±) | 0.03 | 0.03 | 0.11 |
| C.D. −0.05% | 0.07 | 0.07 | 0.25 |
*Figures in parenthesis are logarithmic transformed values.
population of aphid was found in K. Jh (393.33 per 100 compound leaves), followed by K. B (350.66), K. As (342.66), K. Cm (324.33), K. J (269.66), K. P (244.0), K. Su (234.33), K. An (207.0), K. Cs-1 (169.33), K. Sl (152.33) and K. Cs 2 (126.66), respectively. The mean population of the pest was recorded highest in K. Jh (153.30 per 100 compound leaves) and then K. B (127.76), K. As (121.28), K. Cm (107.87), K. J (96.02), K. P (84.02), K. Su (79.02), K. An (63.36), K. Cs 1 (48.28), K. Sl (35.07) and K. Cs 2 (30.02), respectively. Yield of healthy tubers of potato (t/ha) was found maximum in K. B (36.58) while it was recorded minimum in K. P (22.12).
In the second year of study during 2013-14, the initial infestation of aphid was recorded during end of December in most of the germplasms (
The pest was observed slightly earlier in K. B, K. Jh and K. Su in third week of December, while it was found quite later in K. An and K. Cs 1 during first week of January. But in case of K. Cs 2 and K. Sl, aphid was recorded from second week of January. Aphid population crossed the critical level in between first and second week of January in most of the potato germplasms, except K. An, K. Cs 1, K. Cs 2 and K. Sl. In K. Cs 2, the threshold limit of the pest of was reached in third week of February, which was quite late in respect to others. The peak period of the pest was not only found in between third and fourth week of February, but it was also
| Different germplasms | Tuber yield (t/ha) | December, 2013 | January, 2014 | February, 2014 | March, 2014 | Mean population | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| III WK | IV WK | I WK | II WK | III WK | IV WK | I WK | II WK | III WK | IV WK | I WK | |||
| K. Anand | 40.25 | 0.0 (0.0) | 0.0 (0.0) | 3.66 (0.53) | 8.66 (0.95) | 15.66 (1.18) | 37.66 (1.57) | 62.00 (1.79) | 91.33 (1.95) | 133.33 (2.12) | 167.33 (2.21) | 192.66 (2.28) | 54.79 |
| K. Ashoka | 39.83 | 0.0 (0.0) | 5.66 (0.76) | 16.33 (1.21) | 30.33 (1.48) | 64.66 (1.81) | 96.66 (1.98) | 137.33 (2.13) | 192.00 (2.28) | 276.66 (2.44) | 337.33 (2.52) | 281.33 (2.45) | 110.64 |
| K. Badshah | 43.92 | 2.33 (0.49) | 9.66 (1.00) | 29.33 (1.45) | 62.33 (1.79) | 93.00 (1.97) | 159.66 (2.20) | 214.66 (2.33) | 271.66 (2.43) | 316.33 (2.50) | 377.33 (2.58) | 294.66 (2.47) | 140.84 |
| K. Chandramukhi | 27.37 | 0.0 (0.0) | 4.33 (0.68) | 13.66 (1.14) | 31.66 (1.50) | 72.33 (1.86) | 108.33 (2.02) | 153.33 (2.18) | 209.33 (2.32) | 287.66 (2.46) | 217.33 (2.33) | 162.66 (2.20) | 96.97 |
| K. Chipsona-I | 29.67 | 0.0 (0.0) | 0.0 (0.0) | 2.66 (0.44) | 8.33 (0.91) | 13.33 (1.11) | 19.66 (1.28) | 32.66 (1.50) | 69.66 (1.83) | 102.33 (2.00) | 146.33 (2.16) | 212.00 (2.06) | 39.69 |
| K. Chipsona-II | 30.00 | 0.0 (0.0) | 0.0 (0.0) | 0.0 (0.0) | 3.33 (0.50) | 7.33 (0.87) | 12.66 (1.10) | 18.66 (1.26) | 27.66 (1.43) | 51.33 (1.67) | 78.33 (1.87) | 109.33 (2.02) | 23.74 |
| K. Jawahar | 37.54 | 5.66 (0.76) | 9.33 (0.98) | 17.33 (1.24) | 33.33 (1.51) | 68.33 (1.83) | 89.00 (1.95) | 137.00 (2.13) | 192.66 (2.28) | 263.33 (2.41) | 312.33 (2.49) | 247.33 (2.39) | 105.82 |
| K. Joti | 30.17 | 0.0 (0.0) | 3.33 (0.58) | 10.66 (1.03) | 23.33 (1.37) | 51.33 (1.71) | 83.33 (1.92) | 122.33 (2.08) | 187.66 (2.27) | 249.66 (2.39) | 193.66 (2.28) | 136.66 (2.13) | 81.69 |
| K. Pukhraj | 22.08 | 0.0 (0.0) | 6.33 (0.83) | 18.66 (1.27) | 24.33 (1.39) | 42.33 (1.62) | 68.33 (1.83) | 93.33 (1.97) | 127.66 (2.10) | 168.66 (2.21) | 217.33 (2.32) | 172.66 (2.27) | 72.28 |
| K. Sutlez | 32.17 | 3.00 (0.56) | 7.00 (0.86) | 16.66 (1.22) | 29.33 (1.46) | 57.33 (1.76) | 89.66 (1.95) | 124.33 (2.09) | 163.66 (2.21) | 209.33 (2.32) | 253.66 (2.40) | 187.33 (2.26) | 87.79 |
| K. Sailaja | 38.50 | 0.0 (0.0) | 0.0 (0.0) | 0.0 (0.0) | 3.66 (0.64) | 7.66 (0.88) | 16.33 (1.19) | 43.33 (1.63) | 75.66 (1.88) | 109.33 (2.03) | 129.33 (2.10) | 163.33 (2.21) | 42.20 |
| Date of observation | Variety | Date of observation × variety | |
|---|---|---|---|
| SEM (±) | 0.02 | 0.02 | 0.08 |
| C.D. 0.05% | 0.05 | 0.05 | 0.19 |
*Figures in parenthesis are logarithmic transformed values.
*Corresponding author.
It is revealed from the present field study that the aphids were appeared on potato crop in between third week of December and first week of January irrespective of different germplasms, except K. Cs 2, where its infestation was initiated during second and third week of January. After appearance on the crop pest population was gradually increased and continued up to dehaulming of the crop. In all germplasms the economic threshold limit of the pest was observed during first and second week of January in most of the potato germplasms, when temperature ranged from 7.90˚C - 27.20˚C, relative humidity (RH) 48.70% - 100.0%, bright sunshine (BSS) duration 4.70 - 8.40 h and wind speed from 0.40 - 1.3 km/h. But in K. An, K. Cs 1, K. Cs 2 and K. Sl, it was crossed in between fourth week of January and first week of February. The peak population of the pest was recorded during third and fourth week of February under climatic condition of 15.50˚C - 33.10˚C temperature, 39.90% - 99.30% RH, 7.60 - 10.10 h BSS and 1.00 - 1.40 km/h wind speed.
The low aphid population in K. Cs 2 was may be due to its morphological characters, since the leaves of the plant were rough, coarse narrower as well as smaller than other germplasms. The taller habit of the plant, perhaps, also made an unfavourable microclimatic condition within the crop canopy as the pest population was positively correlated with relative humidity and negatively with minimum temperature during rabi season (Sontakke et al. 1989) [
It may be concluded from the present field investigation that K. As, K. B, K. Cm, K. Jh, K. J and K. P were highly susceptible; K. An & K. Su were moderately susceptible and K. Cs 1, K. Cs 2 and K. Sl were less susceptible or tolerant to pest.
The authors are thankful to the Farm Manager of Adisaptagram Block Seed Farm, Hooghly, West Bengal for providing various facilities including a piece of land to undertaken the present field study.
Biplab Kahar,Amitava Konar,1 1, (2016) Screening for Aphid Incidence on Some Potato Germplasm in Plains of West Bengal. Agricultural Sciences,07,352-356. doi: 10.4236/as.2016.76036