The era of whole genome study analysis has introduced a profound research in the genetics of autoimmune diseases. Some of the new genetic loci that have been associated with the development or the severity of autoimmune diseases have been thoroughly studied, conferring a more detailed understanding of disease pathophysiology. Furthermore, single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) have been described not only in coding regions of the human genome but also in non-coding areas (introns), the importance of which has not been yet clarified. Over the last years, such an SNP has been associated with the development of rheumatoid arthritis, the most frequent autoimmune disease. This SNP is at the position 122730060 of chromosome 9 in the TRAF1/C5 region and consists of a substitution of the nucleotide base guanine (G)—which is considered the ancestral phenotype— by alanine (A). It has been indicated that G is the aggravating nucleotide, and that G/G is the disease predisposing phenotype, conferring >1.3× risk for RA. On this background, we performed a genome study on a Greek population of northern Greece (Macedonia) in order to identify the association of this SNP with RA in our group.
Rheumatoid Arthritis (RA) is the most frequent systemic autoimmune disease, affecting approximately 1% of global population. The 2010 EULAR/ACR (European League Against Rheumatism/American College of Rheumatology) diagnostic criteria can set the diagnosis in an early stage of RA, providing access of RA patients to available conventional synthetic or biological Disease Modifying Anti-Rheumatic Drug (DMARD) therapy. TNFα blockade application in clinical practice has imposed an immense investigation on determining biomarkers that could predict better response to treatment in Rheumatoid Arthritis patients. The whole genome scan era has permitted the identification of single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) that predispose to the development of RA but no further studies have been conducted to reveal any possible susceptibility of these genetic loci with pattern of disease. Furthermore, no therapeutic intervention has been proposed by genetic factors associated to any way with RA, indicating that the genetic findings cannot so far be directly associated with RA pathophysiology and therefore treatment. On the other hand, economic burden of anti-TNFα treatment poses persistently the identification of response predictors in order to better apply individualized treatment.
On this regard, we performed a genotype analysis of 172RA patients and 95healthy adult individuals (control group) from Northern Greece provisioned by the Clinical Immunology Unit of the 2nd Department of Internal Medicine of Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Greece. All subjects had signed an informed consent for their genotyping. The observational nature of our study did not require an ethics committee approval. Genotypic analysis was performed at the Histocompatibility and Immunogenetic Laboratory of the Department of Immunology of INSERM UMRS 945, Pitié-Salpêtrière Hospital, Paris, France. An AB (Applied Biosystems) TaqMan® SNP Genotyping Assay was used for the assessment of the investigated SNP on a AB 7900HT Fast Real- Time Polymerase Chain Reaction (RT-PCR) System.
The primary target of our study was to investigate whether findings indicating a correlation of rs3761847SNP to RA manifestation, conducted in Northern Europe and American population [
Nevertheless, when we sub grouped our patients on those receiving conventional non-biological DMARD therapy (n = 134) and those receiving anti-TNFα treatment (n = 38), we underlined a statistically important dif- ference of A/G allele rs3761847 burden between the 2 groups (A/G 61.3%/38.7% on the non-biological DMARD group vs 50.88%/49.12% on the anti-TNFα group―
| RA Patients (n = 172) | Controls (n = 95) | p value | |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | 58.85 | 59.02 | NS |
| G | 41.15 | 40.98 | NS |
| DMARDs (n = 134) | Anti-TNFα (n = 38) | p value | |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | 61.3 | 50.88 | <0.05 |
| G | 38.7 | 49.12 | <0.05 |
groups and are of special interest, since although TRAF1/C5 rs3761847 variant in Greek population does not predispose to the development of RA, on RA patients though, it is associated with reduced disease severity, as augmented proportion of allele A was observed in patients receiving conventional DMARD therapy. Further analysis of our cohort of RA patients receiving anti-TNFα agents did not point out any correlation of this SNP to anti-TNFα response parameters (seropositivity, initial disease activity).
This study is the first to identify an attenuating role of allele A of rs3761847SNP on RA pattern. On molecular basis, our findings could presume that the specific SNP in Greek patients is not potent enough to scatter a deviation of the immune response and contribute to the development of RA, but in RA patients, where the immune response is reorganized by other genetic factors in promoting the disease, only there can this SNP interfere in an unknown pattern with a deviated immune response and express a protective role against the development of RA.
The fact that this SNP is situated in a non coding area of the human genome (intron) raises the question whether these silent areas have after all a functional role in human cell homeostasis [
The clinical equivalent of the correlation observed in our study is that patients presenting the specific SNP phenotype are more likely to sustain prolonged remission with conventional synthetic DMARD therapy, sparing them from more expensive regiments, such as biologic therapies. Given the fact that biologic therapies have a high economical cost of commercial price and follow-up of RA patients receiving them, it is evident that both these costs can be avoided by designing a much cheaper synthetic DMARD combination therapy for RA patients based on their genetic profile.
This study indicates that RA patients with a specific SNP are most likely to undergo sustained remission with a combination of less expensive, synthetic DMARD therapies. In an era of long lasting economical crisis, affecting especially Greece, any genetic indicator of response to therapy is essential in designing cost-benefit patient- tailored treatment. Nevertheless, on the era of almost 10 clinical applied biologic DMARDs, targeting totally different pathophysiological RA pathways, whole genome scan analysis may still identify genomic patients’ profiles predicting a higher likelihood of response to any of these agents.
We thank Philippe Pellet who monitored the execution of the genomic analysis, and the patients and physicians who participated in this study.
None declared.
AlexandrosSarantopoulos,IoannisTheodorou,PanagiotaBoura, (2016) TRAF1/C5 rs3761847 SNP Is Associated with Severe Pattern of Rheumatoid Arthritis in Greek Patients. Open Journal of Rheumatology and Autoimmune Diseases,06,10-12. doi: 10.4236/ojra.2016.61002