We gratefully thank Dr. Warunee Pluemsakunthai and Dr. Lin Zayar for their help on applying daily LIPUS treatment.
Purpose: Low intensity pulsed ultrasound stimulation (LIPUS) has been clinically applied to promote bone fracture healing in the orthopedic field. Thus, it is likely that LIPUS also stimulates bone regeneration in bone defects in the cranial-maxillofacial area. However, this has not been clearly proved. Furthermore, optimal time point and period of the application after the surgery has not been reported. The purpose of the present study was to evaluate the effect of LIPUS on bone regeneration in the rat parietal bone defects especially focusing on time and period of the application. Materials and Methods: Eighteen Wistar rats (14 weeks old) were divided into 6 groups: 5 experimental groups and a control group. Bone defect of 5 mm diameter was prepared on each side of the parietal bone and customized gelatin membranes were placed over the bone defects. LIPUS (160 mW/cm 2, 15 min/day) was applied to the defect area with an active transducer externally in the experimental groups according to the schedules of the applications: Group 1 (day 6 - 12), group 2 (day 13 - 19), group 3 (day 20 - 26), group 4 (day 6 - 19) and group 5 (day 6 - 26). All the animals were sacrificed at 28 days. The defects were analyzed with micro CT and then histologically. Results: In Group 1, new bone formation was significantly promoted and the newly-formed bone was thick and matured compared to the one of the control group. In other experimental groups there were tendencies of stimulation of new bone formation; however, they were not statistically significant. Discussion and Conclusion: The present study demonstrated that amount of new bone formation in the bone defect depended on the time and period of LIPUS application. It has been suggested that application of LIPUS at an early healing period, the second week after the surgery, effectively accelerated new bone formation.
Prosthetic treatment with dental implants has already been recognized as an effective modality for substituting lacking teeth and its long term prognosis is predictable. Notably, this modality needs bone to stabilize the implants; therefore, bone augmentation is often required in bone reduction cases [
It has been reported that application of low-intensity pulsed ultrasound stimulation (LIPUS) promotes fracture healing and LIPUS has been clinically applied in the orthopaedic field [2,3], where positive effects of LIPUS on fracture healing of long bone were clearly concluded to reduce the time frame of clinical and radiographic healing by 38% [
The purpose of the present study was to evaluate effects of LIPUS on bone regeneration in a parietal bone defect, especially focusing on time points and periods of the LIPUS application.
Thirty six defects on the parietal bone of eighteen 14-week-old male Wistar rats weighing 330 - 350 g were assigned into 6 groups. One control group and five LIPUS application groups were divided based on the different treatment periods of LIPUS and 6 defects in each group were taken into account respectively. The animal experiment protocol was approved by the institutional committee for animal experiments of Tokyo Medical and Dental University.
Anesthesia was achieved with a combination of Ketamine and Xylazine (40 and 5 mg/kg, respectively). The scalps of rats were shaved and disinfected using iodine and 70% alcohol. A bowed incision was made coronally between the ears, and the skin and the connective tissue were exfoliated forward to the posterior end of the frontal bone. Subsequently, the periosteum was incised along the suture between the occipital and the parietal bones and elevated to expose the parietal bone surface. One full-thickness bone defect was created in each parietal bone by removing cranial disks with 5 mm in diameter carefully to avoid damage to the dura mater using a trephine bur constantly cooled with sterile saline (
given period for each analysis.
A commercial ultrasound device (BR-Sonic, Ito Physiotherapy & Rehabilitation Co., Ltd., Tokyo, Japan) was used to generate an intensity of 160 mW/cm2 ultrasound (5 MHz, 100-Hz pulse repetition frequency, 30% duty cycle).
Five different combinations of timing and repetition of LIPUS was scheduled for 5 groups, respectively, which was based on a unit of daily 15-minunte stimulation for six consecutive days followed by a no-LIPUS day. The rats in LIPUS application groups were wrapped with towel and fixed into a plastic slot which was used to restrict their excessive movements shown in
All the animals were sacrificed at 28 days under excessive chloroform anesthesia. The defects with the surrounding cranial bone and soft tissue were removed and scanned by micro-CT (InspeXio; Shimadzu Science East Corporation, Tokyo, Japan) to obtain 3D microstructural information with a voxel size of 50 µm/pixel. Threedimensional volume of the whole thickness radiopacity in 4.5 mm diameter at the center of each defect was rendered and calculated as new bone using Tri/3D-Bon software (RATOC System Engineering Co., Tokyo, Japan).
The specimens were fixed in 10% neutralized formalin for two weeks, decalcified in formic acid for one month, dehydrated and finally embedded in paraffin. Approximate 5-µm-thickness coronal sections were prepared through the center of defects, stained with hematoxylin -eosin and observed under an optical microscope (Biozero, Keyence, Tokyo, Japan). The histological images were captured and stored in the computer. The newly formed bone area was measured with an image analyzer (Image J, National Institute of Health, USA) and expressed in percentage to the total defect area.
Statistical analysis was performed by the statistic software PASW Statistics 18 for Windows. Data were first analyzed by one-way ANOVA. When this analysis suggested a significant difference between groups (p > 0.05), the data were further analyzed by Sheffe post hoc multiple comparison tests. P values of less than 0.05 were considered to be statistically significant.
All the animals recovered well after surgery, and they were obedient, getting used to the daily treatment. And the soft tissue wounds healed uneventfully without infection except for general post-op inflammation over the experimental period. During the treatment, we observed small bubbles inside the ultrasound gel between the transducer and the skin. These bubbles expanded and contracted into a visible size and then stabilized. Only one rat in the application group 4 showed a little relaxing symptom after the last-two-day treatment; however, it recovered soon. The body weight between the control and the application groups didn’t show significant difference at the sacrifice.
Radiopacity in the defect was observed in both the untreated control group and the LIPUS intervention groups (
In the control group, a thin layer of new bone was formed; however, the defect closure with new bone was not completed because of invasion of fibrous tissue into the healing site.
In group 1, the whole defect was fulfilled with newly formed bone, which connected with the peripheral original bone so that the interface between the newly formed bone and the original bone was difficult to be identified as well as seen in the radiological assessment. Osteoid but irregular structure of immature bone rimmed by osteoblasts was observed in the central part of the defect. Numerous blood vessels existed inside the osteoid tissue. Active osteoblasts aligned along the edge of newly formed bone or on the periosteal side.
Percentage of the regenerated bone in the defect area of the control group was only 34.55% ± 16.26%, whereas those of groups 1 and 2 reached 77.53% ± 16.17% and 69.89% ± 14.42% respectively which exceeded signifycantly new bone regeneration in the untreated control group (Figures 6 and 7).
LIPUS began to be widely used clinically to treat fresh fractures in the early 1990s and non-unions or delayed unions in the late 1990s, although experimental studies have demonstrated that LIPUS enhances bone regenera-
tion during fracture healing and callus distraction quite recently [8-10]. Thus, it has been established that LIPUS stimulates bone regeneration in orthopedic field. However, it was not clear that LIPUS stimulates bone regeneration in the maxillofacial area because regenerative process of a bone commonly generally follows its embryological process. Bones in the maxillofacial area are flat and formed by intramembranous ossification whereas most bones in other parts of the body are long bones and produced by endochondral ossification [
The present study demonstrated that amount of new bone formation in the bone defect depended on the time and period of LIPUS application. The intensity and frequency of LIPUS used in this study should be also taken into account as the factors influencing the results. However, in the present experimental conditions, it was sug gested that application of LIPUS at an early healing period, the second week after the surgery, effectively accelerated new bone formation.
In the previous animal experiment LIPUS was applied from 24 hours after the surgery (Hasuike et al.). We considered that putting ultrasound gel and the transducer directly on unhealed surgical site was neither proper nor clinically practical although LIPUS application at this stage might stimulate bone regeneration [
The defect was obviously filled with blood after surgical preparation, and then, coagulation process was activated producing fibrin and signal molecules, such as PDGF and TGF-beta from platelets [
After vascularized primitive connective tissue is formed, bone spicules fuse with adjacent spicules to become trabeculae and woven bone, as a crucial step in the process of intramembranous ossification of the parietal bones. Ultrasound stimulation is considered to favor this stage, but afterwards, when the osteogenic differentiation occurs, ultrasound would induce potential negative effects due to temperature rise in previous studies [17,18]. That also might explain the bone volume decrease in group 4 of our present study. The slight positive effect in group 5 was probably related to effects of mechanical stimuli on the period of bone remodeling.
The general clinical formula of LIPUS application is 20 min per day, 1 MHz sine waves repeating at 1 kHz, average intensity 30 mW/cm2 and pulse width 200 μs. However, there is no consensus about the therapeutic LIPUS intensity. Lavandier and his collaborators have reported that LIPUS at 300 mW/cm2 shows more bone regenerative effect than at 100 mW/cm2 in a 3 mm noncritical size bone defects of the rat calvarium [
According to the literature, Utrasound therapy is reported to have two main relative effects, thermal and non-thermal, which are thought to be optimized through dosage modification. The intensity at which ultrasound is applied in regular clinical applications ranges from 0.1 to 1.0 W/cm2. Some references stated that it required precaution when heating the skull if intensity of the ultrasound was more than 94 mW/cm2 transcranially. Although the settings of the parameters in this present study effectively stimulated bone regeneration, the safety of each parameter should be clarified with more extensive studies.
In the present study we found that the application of LIPUS at the second week after surgery effectively stimulated bone regeneration. Although results in animal experiments do not always reflect the clinical situations in patients, it is likely that application of LIPUS at this particular stage after the surgery could also promote bone regeneration in patients. This LIPUS application protocol would be beneficial to patients because it reduces treatments and hospital visits. However, effectiveness and safety of this LIPUS application protocol should be clinically proven in the near future.
The effects of mechanical stress on cells including osteoblasts have been extensively studied in cell cultures. Possible signal molecules, which involved in the promoting effects of LIPUS in the present study, might be the followings: Prostaglandin E2, nitric oxide, vascular endothelial growth factors (VEGF) because enhancement of the production of these signal molecules by mechanical stress has been reported [22-24]. Although the precise mechanism of the present enhancement of bone regeneration is not clear, it is likely that LIPUS stimulated cellular migration, proliferation and differentiation which were controlled by these signal molecules [25,26]. It has been reported that LIPUS stimulated angiogenesis and the most effective time point of LIPUS application was at the second week when extensive angiogenesis generally occurs after the surgery [27,28]. Thus, promotion of angiogenesis by LIPUS seemed to contribute to the present enhancement of bone regeneration.
Conclusively, the present study demonstrated the beneficial effect of LIPUS application on bone regeneration in a rat parietal defect depending on time and period of the application and that the application of LIPUS at the second week for one week after the surgery was the most effective. These results indicated that time and period of LIPUS application should be considered clinically for promoting bone regeneration in the patient effectively, and the safety of LIPUS parameters should be further established.
We gratefully thank Dr. Warunee Pluemsakunthai and Dr. Lin Zayar for their help on applying daily LIPUS treatment.