<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<!DOCTYPE article PUBLIC "-//NLM//DTD JATS (Z39.96) Journal Publishing DTD v1.4 20241031//EN" "JATS-journalpublishing1-4.dtd">
<article xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" article-type="research-article" dtd-version="1.4" xml:lang="en">
  <front>
    <journal-meta>
      <journal-id journal-id-type="publisher-id">msce</journal-id>
      <journal-title-group>
        <journal-title>Journal of Materials Science and Chemical Engineering</journal-title>
      </journal-title-group>
      <issn pub-type="epub">2327-6053</issn>
      <issn pub-type="ppub">2327-6045</issn>
      <publisher>
        <publisher-name>Scientific Research Publishing</publisher-name>
      </publisher>
    </journal-meta>
    <article-meta>
      <article-id pub-id-type="doi">10.4236/msce.2026.1411002</article-id>
      <article-id pub-id-type="publisher-id">msce-155321</article-id>
      <article-categories>
        <subj-group>
          <subject>Article</subject>
        </subj-group>
        <subj-group>
          <subject>Chemistry</subject>
          <subject>Materials Science</subject>
        </subj-group>
      </article-categories>
      <title-group>
        <article-title>Meta-Analysis of Bio-Char, Bio-Oil, and Gas Yields of Different Types of Straw under Different Carbonization Conditions</article-title>
      </title-group>
      <contrib-group>
        <contrib contrib-type="author" corresp="yes">
          <name name-style="western">
            <surname>Li</surname>
            <given-names>Lianfa</given-names>
          </name>
          <xref ref-type="aff" rid="aff1">1</xref>
        </contrib>
        <contrib contrib-type="author">
          <name name-style="western">
            <surname>Li</surname>
            <given-names>Yaxin</given-names>
          </name>
          <xref ref-type="aff" rid="aff2">2</xref>
        </contrib>
      </contrib-group>
      <aff id="aff1"><label>1</label> Taigang Technology Center, Taiyuan, China </aff>
      <aff id="aff2"><label>2</label> School of Chemical Engineering, Dalian University of Technology, Dalian, China </aff>
      <author-notes>
        <fn fn-type="conflict" id="fn-conflict">
          <p>All authors declare that they do not have any known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this research, nor do they have competing interests.</p>
        </fn>
      </author-notes>
      <pub-date pub-type="epub">
        <day>05</day>
        <month>11</month>
        <year>2026</year>
      </pub-date>
      <pub-date pub-type="collection">
        <month>11</month>
        <year>2026</year>
      </pub-date>
      <volume>14</volume>
      <issue>11</issue>
      <fpage>20</fpage>
      <lpage>41</lpage>
      <history>
        <date date-type="received">
          <day>21</day>
          <month>09</month>
          <year>2026</year>
        </date>
        <date date-type="accepted">
          <day>13</day>
          <month>11</month>
          <year>2026</year>
        </date>
        <date date-type="published">
          <day>16</day>
          <month>11</month>
          <year>2026</year>
        </date>
      </history>
      <permissions>
        <copyright-statement>© 2026 by the authors and Scientific Research Publishing Inc.</copyright-statement>
        <copyright-year>2026</copyright-year>
        <license license-type="open-access">
          <license-p> This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license ( <ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/">https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/</ext-link> ). </license-p>
        </license>
      </permissions>
      <self-uri content-type="doi" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.4236/msce.2026.1411002">https://doi.org/10.4236/msce.2026.1411002</self-uri>
      <abstract>
        <p>Straw is a large-scale and widely distributed agricultural biomass. On the one hand, its disposal poses challenges to local governments. On the other hand, its resource utilization is crucial for achieving agricultural carbon neutrality and the circular economy. Though some individual studies have paid attention to the carbonization mechanism of single or several types of straw, a meta-analysis study or systematic literature review on this aspect has not been reported yet. Therefore, this research aims to explore the bio-char, bio-oil, and gas yields of different types of straw under different carbonization conditions using meta-analysis. It extracts data from 11 studies, published between 2015 and 2026. Though the meta-analysis has issues with heterogeneity and publication bias due to the small sample size, it addresses a meaningful and practical topic and draws several conclusions: 1) there is a significant statistical difference in the average bio-char, bio-oil, and gas yields of the selected types of straw; 2) carbonization conditions (types of straw, temperature, heating rate, retention, and atmosphere) have impacts on the bio-char, bio-oil, and gas yields; 3) bio-char, bio-oil, and gas yields are the result of the combined effect of multiple factors representing the overall outcome. Thus, this research generates the hypothesis that it provides a practice guide for industry and research institutions to formulate targeted carbonization plans based on different types of straw, in particular by making good use of the traditional tile kiln and charcoal kiln.</p>
      </abstract>
      <kwd-group kwd-group-type="author-generated" xml:lang="en">
        <kwd>Meta-Analysis</kwd>
        <kwd>Bio-Char</kwd>
        <kwd>Bio-Oil</kwd>
        <kwd>And Gas Yields</kwd>
        <kwd>Carbonization Conditions</kwd>
        <kwd>Pyrolysis</kwd>
        <kwd>Forest Plot</kwd>
      </kwd-group>
    </article-meta>
  </front>
  <body>
    <sec id="sec1">
      <title>1. Introduction</title>
      <p>Straw is a large-scale and widely distributed agricultural biomass, and its resource utilization is crucial for achieving agricultural carbon neutrality and the circular economy. As we all know, China is an agricultural country that generates approximately 1 billion tons of various agricultural waste materials annually, such as crop stalks and weed stalks. Among these, the waste materials from major crops like rice, wheat, corn, sorghum, rapeseed, cotton, and beans account for over 85% of the total, while weed stalks make up about 10% [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B1">1</xref>]. They are a rich and renewable biomass resource, containing large amounts of cellulose, hemicellulose, and lignin. They can be carbonized to produce biochar, pyrolysis gas, and wood vinegar (containing wood tar). </p>
      <p>Currently, the main methods of handling straw in China are open-air burning, crushing and returning to the field, and random stacking. Both open-air burning and crushing and returning to the field have caused issues. On the one hand, open-air burning and random stacking lead not only to a significant waste of biomass resources, but also to a series of environmental problems such as air pollution [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B2">2</xref>]. On the other hand, crushing and returning to the field affects crop growth and increases pest risks, which results in increased farming costs [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B3">3</xref>]. These methods restrict the sustainable development of agriculture. To address them, China has developed strategies for straw utilization, including carbonization. Bio-char, bio-oil, and gases, as core indicators for measuring the efficiency of straw carbonization, directly reflect the degree to which straw is converted into these products. Their yields are not only closely related to the composition of the straw itself (such as the contents of cellulose, hemicellulose, and lignin), but also are influenced by various process conditions such as carbonization temperature, insulation time, heating rate, and carbonization atmosphere. </p>
      <p>Pyrolysis is a feasible technology, with a carbonization temperature range of 250˚C - 750˚C, which transforms organic material into a value-added product (such as bio-char, bio-oil, and pyrolysis gas), minimizing the problems in the combustion process of agricultural straw. It is considered one of the most interesting processes for biomass thermochemical conversion, as it is a sustainable and Earth-friendly approach. It is usually divided into flash, fast, and slow pyrolysis, and fast and slow pyrolysis have been widely applied in industry. While fast pyrolysis increases the amount of generated bio-oil and gases and produces less bio-char, slow pyrolysis produces larger portions of bio-char and gases at longer retention [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B4">4</xref>].</p>
      <p>Meta-analysis is a statistical method that systematically integrates the results of multiple independent studies. By combining the data from multiple studies with a similar research objective or research topic, it can effectively reduce the sampling error and random error of a single study, thereby enhancing the reliability and generalizability of the research conclusions [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B5">5</xref>]. A meta-analysis study on the bio-char, bio-oil, and gas yields (“Bio-char,” “Bio-oil,” and “Gases” are their measurements, which will be used as variables in quantitative data analysis) of different types of straw under different carbonization conditions has not been reported yet. This research narrows the research gap. It uses a meta-analysis method to systematically integrate relevant research data from both domestic and international sources, mainly from international sources, quantifying the effects of different types of straw (rice straw, wheat straw, corn straw, sorghum straw, rape straw, cotton straw, and soybean straw) and carbonization conditions (carbonization process, carbonization temperature, insulation time, heating rate, and carbonization atmosphere) on Bio-char, Bio-oil, and Gases. It provides a scientific basis and theoretical support for optimizing the straw carbonization process, the efficient preparation of bio-char bio-oil, and gases, and the utilization of straw resources.</p>
    </sec>
    <sec id="sec2">
      <title>2. Materials and Methods</title>
      <sec id="sec2dot1">
        <title>2.1. Data Collection</title>
        <p>The related studies were searched using the search engine or open databases, <ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://cn.bing.com/">https://cn.bing.com/</ext-link>, <ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://xueshu.baidu.com/">https://xueshu.baidu.com/</ext-link>, <ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/">https://www.sciencedirect.com/</ext-link>, and <ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://kns.cnki.net/">https://kns.cnki.net/</ext-link>. The English search keywords, including straw, carbonization rate/Bio-char, Bio-oil and Gases, pyrolysis, rice straw, wheat straw, corn straw, sorghum straw, rape straw, cotton straw, bean straw, and soybean straw were used. By using the “keyword combination search” method, different types of straw and keywords related to Bio-char, Bio-oil, and Gases/bio-char, bio-oil, and gases yields were combined to ensure that all relevant research literature was retrieved and to ensure the comprehensiveness and representativeness of the retrieved data. The first step was to conduct a preliminary search using the aforementioned databases and keywords and collect all relevant literature. The second step was to read the titles, abstracts, and full texts of the literature based on the inclusion criteria and exclusion criteria (<bold>Table 1</bold>) and select the relevant literature that are related to the research topic of this study (at least one type of straw with data on carbonization conditions and bio-char, bio-oil, and gas yields), following the PRISMA flow chart [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B6">6</xref>] in <xref ref-type="fig" rid="fig1">Figure 1</xref>. The final step was to extract the data on carbonization conditions and bio-char, bio-oil, and gas yields as well as the arguments on the carbonization mechanisms.</p>
        <p><bold>Table 1</bold><bold>.</bold>The inclusion criteria and exclusion criteria.</p>
        <table-wrap id="tbl1">
          <label>Table 1</label>
          <table>
            <tbody>
              <tr>
                <td>
                  <bold>Items</bold>
                </td>
                <td>
                  <bold>Inclusion criteria</bold>
                </td>
                <td>
                  <bold>Exclusion criteria</bold>
                </td>
              </tr>
              <tr>
                <td>Publication date</td>
                <td>Within 2015-2026</td>
                <td>Published before 2015</td>
              </tr>
              <tr>
                <td>Language</td>
                <td>In English</td>
                <td>In non-English</td>
              </tr>
              <tr>
                <td>Type</td>
                <td>Journals and research papers</td>
                <td>Other types (such as review, news)</td>
              </tr>
              <tr>
                <td>Full-text</td>
                <td>Full-text accessible</td>
                <td>Full-text inaccessible</td>
              </tr>
              <tr>
                <td>Topics</td>
                <td>Rice straw, wheat straw, corn straw, sorghum straw, rape straw, cotton straw, bean straw, or soybean straw used as material</td>
                <td>Other material is used, without rice straw, wheat straw, corn straw, sorghum straw, rape straw, cotton straw, bean straw, or soybean straw as material</td>
              </tr>
              <tr>
                <td>Key content</td>
                <td>Including the straw carbonization experiment, clearly reporting the carbonization conditions (such as carbonization temperature, holding time, heating rate, and carbonization atmosphere, at least one of which) and the corresponding Bio-char, Bio-oil, and Gases/bio-char, bio-oil, and gases yield data.</td>
                <td>No reports of the carbonization conditions (such as carbonization temperature, holding time, heating rate, and carbonization atmosphere, at least one of which) and the corresponding Bio-char, Bio-oil, and Gases/bio-char, bio-oil, and gases yield data. The carbonization process adopted is very complex (such as the addition of catalysts and modification treatments)</td>
              </tr>
            </tbody>
          </table>
        </table-wrap>
        <fig id="fig1">
          <label>Figure 1</label>
          <caption>
            <p>The PRISMA flow chart of the literature.</p>
          </caption>
          <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId17.jpeg?20261116014515" />
        </fig>
      </sec>
      <sec id="sec2dot2">
        <title>2.2. Data Processing and Data Analysis</title>
        <p>A random-effects model was applied to assess the impacts of carbonization conditions (such as carbonization temperature, holding time, heating rate, and carbonization atmosphere on the yields of bio-char, bio-oil, and gases. Bio-char, Bio-oil, and Gases of straws (in percentage) with standard errors or 95% confidence interval (95% CI) were chosen as the effect size. However, some studies had reported them with standard errors, some reported them with 95% CI, and some reported them with variances. Thus, some studies lacked standard errors. To conduct the meta-analysis, 95% CI and variances were transformed into standard errors and the lacking values were filled with an imputation approach, such as Expectation-Maximization resampling and linear regression. The meta-analysis was conducted using Stata 18 software, including the forest plot, heterogeneity, and publication bias. When making the forest plots, bio-char, bio-oil, and gas yields were used as the effect-size, respectively. For per effect-size, a sensitivity analysis was conducted.</p>
      </sec>
    </sec>
    <sec id="sec3">
      <title>3. Results</title>
      <sec id="sec3dot1">
        <title>3.1. Data Overview</title>
        <p>In total, 11 studies were selected, covering corn straw [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B7">7</xref>] [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B8">8</xref>], sorghum straw [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B9">9</xref>] [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B10">10</xref>], wheat straw (including mixed wheat straw) [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B11">11</xref>] [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B12">12</xref>], castor straw [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B13">13</xref>], cotton straw [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B14">14</xref>], rice straw (including dry rice straw and wet basis rice straw) [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B15">15</xref>] [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B16">16</xref>], soybean straw [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B17">17</xref>]. In total, there are 113 lines of records in the original extracted dataset, covering different temperatures, holding times, heating rates, and carbonization atmospheres. A prespecified rule was applied that retains all eligible conditions, ensuring that various temperatures, holding times, heating rates, and carbonization atmospheres were covered as much as possible while accounting for within-study dependence. However, it should be noted that selecting one of 113 extracted records from each study can materially bias the pooled yields.</p>
      </sec>
      <sec id="sec3dot2">
        <title>3.2. Forest Plot and Combined Effect Size Analysis</title>
        <p>The forest plots in <xref ref-type="fig" rid="fig2">Figures 2-4</xref> show Bio-char of different types of straw (as for the forest plots of Bio-oil, and Gases of different types of straw, please refer to Supplementary <bold>Figures S1-6</bold>). There was a significant difference in their averages for corn straw, sorghum straw, wheat straw, castor straw, cotton straw, rice straw, and rape straw (<italic>p</italic> &lt; 0.01), and the overall Bio-char was 33.68% with 95% CI = (24.29%, 43.08%). In terms of Bio-char, the following are the combined effect sizes: corn straw, 28.82, 95% CI = (26.24%, 31.41%), sorghum straw, 25.99%, 95% CI = (17.78%, 34.19%), wheat straw, 26.33%, 95% CI = (25.02%, 27.64%), castor straw, 50.56%, 95% CI = (48.01%, 53.11%), cotton straw, 48.89%, 95% CI = (45.77%, 52.01%), rice straw, 22.14%, 95% CI = (−4.68%, 48.97%), and soybean straw, 68.87%, 95% CI = (57.89%, 79.85%), which were obtained from the sub-group analysis. There were no reports on barley straw, rape stalk, and millet straw after re-sampling. It can be concluded that bio-char yield of soybean straw ranks the top, followed by that of castor straw, with the yields of rice straw and sorghum straw located at the bottom. It should be noted that the studies on soybean straw have a relatively small sample size (n = 1). The results might be questionable and need further exploration or simulation using ASPEN. When it comes to Bio-oil, the yield of sorghum straw ranks the top and that of cotton straw ranks at the bottom, whereas castor straw ranks the top and rice straw ranks at the bottom with respect to Gases. As with Bio-char, the results on Bio-oil and Gases might be questionable and need further exploration or simulation using ASPEN.</p>
        <fig id="fig2">
          <label>Figure 2</label>
          <caption>
            <p>Overall analysis of studies on Bio-char.</p>
          </caption>
          <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId18.jpeg?20261116014518" />
        </fig>
        <fig id="fig3">
          <label>Figure 3</label>
          <caption>
            <p>Sensitive analysis of studies on Bio-char.</p>
          </caption>
          <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId19.jpeg?20261116014518" />
        </fig>
      </sec>
      <sec id="sec3dot3">
        <title>3.3. Heterogeneity and Publication Bias</title>
        <p>The Galbraith plots in <xref ref-type="fig" rid="fig5">Figure 5</xref> show that the selected studies have some heterogeneity. The overall heterogeneity of literature on Bio-char: <italic>τ</italic><sup>2</sup> = 238.73, I<sup>2</sup> = 99.47%, H<sup>2</sup> =188.51; Test of <italic>θ</italic><italic><sub>i</sub></italic> = <italic>θ</italic><italic><sub>j</sub></italic>: Q (11) =1665.52, <italic>p</italic> = 0.00. The overall heterogeneity of literature on Bio-oil: <italic>τ</italic><sup>2</sup> = 286.86, I<sup>2</sup> = 99.86%, H<sup>2</sup> = 691.08; Test of <italic>θ</italic><italic><sub>i</sub></italic> = <italic>θ</italic><italic><sub>j</sub></italic>: Q (6) = 5324.44, <italic>p</italic> = 0.00. The overall heterogeneity of literature on Gases: <italic>τ</italic><sup>2</sup> = 124.70, I<sup>2</sup> = 99.52%, H<sup>2</sup> = 207.292; Test of <italic>θ</italic><italic><sub>i</sub></italic> = <italic>θ</italic><italic><sub>j</sub></italic>: Q (6) = 1733.18, <italic>p</italic> = 0.00. These parameters indicate that there is substantial heterogeneity (I<sup>2</sup> &gt; 50%) [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B18">18</xref>]. The key to solving it lies in identifying the source of heterogeneity. Sensitivity analysis (by the elimination method) indicates that several studies have the abnormal values. Additionally, the subgroup analysis shows that some subgroups have no heterogeneity (I<sup>2</sup> = 0%) (such as corn straw in the forest plot of studies on Bio-char), some subgroups have low heterogeneity (I<sup>2</sup> &lt; 50%) (such as wheat straw in the forest plot of studies on Bio-char), while other subgroups still have substantial heterogeneity (I<sup>2</sup> &gt; 50%) (such as rice straw in the forest plot of studies on Bio-char). Both Sensitivity analysis (by the elimination method) and the subgroup analysis show that heterogeneity mainly results from the differences in the type of straw and the carbonization process parameters, as well as from the randomly resampling. </p>
        <fig id="fig4">
          <label>Figure 4</label>
          <caption>
            <p>Sub-group analysis of studies on Bio-char.</p>
          </caption>
          <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId20.jpeg?20261116014518" />
        </fig>
        <p>Funnel plots and Egger’s tests are often used to evaluate publication bias [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B18">18</xref>]. Funnel plots in <xref ref-type="fig" rid="fig6">Figure 6</xref> show that the selected studies have some publication bias. On the other hand, the Egger tests in <bold>Table 2</bold> suggest rejecting the null hypothesis of “funnel plot symmetry” (the funnel-plot asymmetry) and suggest the presence of a small-study effect in the data distribution (most <italic>p</italic> &lt; 0.05 [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B18">18</xref>]). The publication biases in the funnel plots are affected by the small resample size. Small sample-size studies are more prone to the exaggeration of effect sizes. Such a systematic difference is not equivalent to publication bias. To address the issue, future research needs to enlarge the resample size.</p>
        <fig id="fig5">
          <label>Figure 5</label>
          <caption>
            <p>Galbraith plots: (a) Bio-char, (b) Bio-oil, and (c) Gases.</p>
          </caption>
          <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId21.jpeg?20261116014518" />
          <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId22.jpeg?20261116014518" />
          <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId23.jpeg?20261116014518" />
          <p>(a) (b) (c)</p>
        </fig>
        <fig id="fig6">
          <label>Figure 6</label>
          <caption>
            <p>Funnel plots: (a) Bio-char, (b) Bio-oil, and (c) Gases.</p>
          </caption>
          <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId24.jpeg?20261116014518" />
          <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId25.jpeg?20261116014518" />
          <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId26.jpeg?20261116014518" />
          <p>(a) (b) (c)</p>
        </fig>
        <p><bold>Table 2</bold><bold>.</bold>Egger test.</p>
        <table-wrap id="tbl2">
          <label>Table 2</label>
          <table>
            <tbody>
              <tr>
                <td>
                  <bold>Effect size</bold>
                </td>
                <td>
                  <italic>
                    <bold>z</bold>
                  </italic>
                </td>
                <td>
                  <italic>
                    <bold>p</bold>
                  </italic>
                  <bold>&gt; |</bold>
                  <italic>
                    <bold>z</bold>
                  </italic>
                  <bold>|</bold>
                </td>
              </tr>
              <tr>
                <td>Bio-char</td>
                <td>3.17</td>
                <td>0.015</td>
              </tr>
              <tr>
                <td>Bio-oil</td>
                <td>1.14</td>
                <td>0.2525</td>
              </tr>
              <tr>
                <td>Gases</td>
                <td>3.25</td>
                <td>0.001</td>
              </tr>
            </tbody>
          </table>
        </table-wrap>
      </sec>
      <sec id="sec3dot4">
        <title>3.4. The Influence of Carbonization Conditions on Bio-Char, Bio-Oil, and Gases</title>
        <p>Several studies have proved that carbonization conditions (types of straw, temperature, heating rate, retention, and atmosphere) have impacts on yields of Bio-char, Bio-oil, and Gases. This meta-analysis systematically confirmed the impacts (visualized in <xref ref-type="fig" rid="fig7">Figures 7-12</xref>). </p>
        <p>Supplementary <bold>Table S1</bold> indicates that fixed carbon (FC) has a positive relationship with Bio-char and Bio-oil. However, the relationship between FC and Gases is negative, and volatile matter in all types of straws has a positive relationship with Bio-char, while a negative relationship with Bio-oil and Gases. The relationships are not significant because of the small sample size in the resampling (volatile matter → Bio-char: <italic>p</italic> = 0.735 &gt; 0.05, volatile matter → Bio-oil: <italic>p</italic> = 0.699 &gt; 0.05 and volatile matter → Gases: <italic>p</italic> = 0.784 &gt; 0.05). The finding here is supported by several existing studies. According to Hassan &amp; Strezov (2025) [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B19">19</xref>], FC and volatile matter in all types of straws, hemicellulose, cellulose, and lignin also have impacts on bio-char formation mechanism. The relationship between hemicellulose (or, cellulose and lignin) and Bio-char, Bio-oil, and Gases needs more exploration. Additionally, Liu <italic>et</italic><italic>al.</italic> (2018) [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B20">20</xref>] state that the carbon yields of cotton straw rice, wheat, corn, and rapeseed are approximately 37.87%, 37.38%, 34.42%, 34.39%, and 32.74%, respectively. The FC of cotton straw rice, wheat, corn, rapeseed, and Bio-char are approximately 10.17%, 10.06%, 9.93%, 8.93%, and 7.49%, respectively (see Supplementary <bold>Table S2</bold>). This means that the carbon yields (Bio-char) of cotton of the tested straws are positively related to FC.</p>
        <p>Supplementary <bold>Table S3</bold> indicates that heating rate has a positive relationship with Gases and Bio-oil while a negative relationship with Bio-char. The relationships are not significant (<italic>p</italic> &gt; 0.05), and the sample size needs to be enlarged to explore whether there is a significant relationship between the variables. Heating rate is often related to the types of pyrolysis (mainly including slow pyrolysis, fast pyrolysis, and flash pyrolysis) [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B21">21</xref>]. Several scholars, such as Loc <italic>et</italic><italic>al.</italic> [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B4">4</xref>], Nath <italic>et</italic><italic>al.</italic> [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B11">11</xref>], and Elshareef <italic>et</italic><italic>al.</italic> [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B22">22</xref>], have summarized their findings, as shown in Supplementary <bold>Table S4</bold>. It can be derived that heating rate has a positive relationship with Bio-oil. Normally, the high heating rate, the more Gases and the less Bio-char; however, in flash pyrolysis, the yield of gases decreases. </p>
        <p>Supplementary <bold>Table S5</bold> indicates that retention has a positive relationship with Gases and Bio-oil while a negative relationship with Bio-char. The longer retention, the more Gases and Bio-oil, and the less Bio-char. The relationships are not significant (<italic>p</italic> &gt; 0.05). Similar to heating rate, retention is associated with the types of pyrolysis. The slow pyrolysis has relatively longer retention. Thus, the findings here are supported by Loc <italic>et</italic><italic>al.</italic> [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B4">4</xref>], Nath <italic>et</italic><italic>al.</italic> [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B11">11</xref>], and Elshareef <italic>et</italic><italic>al.</italic> [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B22">22</xref>]. A longer pyrolysis time (retention) increases the system’s reaction rate, promoting biomass carbonization and influencing the yield of bio-char, bio-oil, and gases [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B23">23</xref>]. Depending on the pyrolysis method, either fast pyrolysis or slow pyrolysis, retention (either seconds in fast pyrolysis or hours in slow pyrolysis) has impacts on biomass carbonization and influences bio-char yield and properties. This study observes the relationship between the yields of bio-char, bio-oil, and gas, either positive or negative, however, not significant. It should be noted that to maximize bio-char yield, a longer retention and slower heating rate are needed, as well as a suitable temperature (300˚C - 500˚C), according to Loc <italic>et</italic><italic>al.</italic> [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B4">4</xref>].</p>
        <p>Supplementary <bold>Table S6</bold> indicates that temperature has a positive relationship (but not significant) with Bio-oil (<italic>r</italic> = 0.03, <italic>p</italic> = 0.414 &gt; 0.05) and a significant negative relationship with Bio-char (<italic>r</italic> = −0.07, <italic>p</italic> = 0.001 &lt; 0.05) and Gases (<italic>r</italic> = −0.05, <italic>p</italic> = 0.031 &lt; 0.05). The higher the temperature, the more Bio-oil and the less Bio-char and Gases. These findings here are consistent with those in previous studies. According to Sakhiya <italic>et</italic><italic>al.</italic> [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B15">15</xref>], the yields of pyrolysis products are influenced by temperature, heating rate, retention, flow rate of inert gas, biomass type, and particle size. Pyrolysis temperature plays an important role in the pyrolysis process. Higher temperature, together with longer retention, increases the pyrolysis process [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B7">7</xref>] [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B24">24</xref>]. The bio-oil yield is proved to be maximized by several studies, such as Tagade <italic>et</italic><italic>al.</italic> [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B25">25</xref>], with a relatively higher heating rate (&gt;200˚C/s), relatively higher temperature (T &gt; 500˚C), and shorter retention, which is often referred to as fast pyrolysis. In contrast, slow pyrolysis maximizes bio-char yield at a lower heating rate (5 - 15˚C/min), in the temperature range of 300˚C - 600˚C, and with longer retention (60 - 180 min) [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B26">26</xref>].</p>
        <p>Supplementary <bold>Table S7</bold> indicates that an inert atmosphere has a positive relationship with Bio-oil (<italic>r</italic> = 6.97) while a negative relationship with Bio-char (<italic>r</italic> =-0.88) and Gases (<italic>r</italic> = −5.59). The relationships are not significant (three <italic>p</italic> &gt; 0.05); whether they are significant or not needs further exploration with a larger the sample size. The effect of the inert atmosphere is He &gt; N<sub>2</sub> &gt; CO<sub>2</sub>. Atmosphere and temperature are thought to be the predominant factors influencing bio-char properties [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B27">27</xref>]. A CO<sub>2</sub> atmosphere plays a role in producing high-quality bio-char with nutritional elements(N/P/K), compared with an N<sub>2</sub> atmosphere [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B28">28</xref>]. However, the effect of atmosphere on bio-char production is mostly neglected [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B29">29</xref>].</p>
        <fig id="fig7">
          <label>Figure 7</label>
          <caption>
            <p>Relationship between FC and the yields of (a) Bio-char, (b) Bio-oil, and (c) Gases.</p>
          </caption>
          <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId27.jpeg?20261116014519" />
          <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId28.jpeg?20261116014519" />
          <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId29.jpeg?20261116014519" />
          <p>(a) (b) (c)</p>
        </fig>
        <fig id="fig8">
          <label>Figure 8</label>
          <caption>
            <p>Relationship between volatile matter and the yields of (a) Bio-char, (b) Bio-oil, and (c) Gases.</p>
          </caption>
          <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId30.jpeg?20261116014520" />
          <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId31.jpeg?20261116014520" />
          <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId32.jpeg?20261116014520" />
          <p>(a) (b) (c)</p>
        </fig>
        <fig id="fig9">
          <label>Figure 9</label>
          <caption>
            <p>Relationship between heating rate and the yields of (a) Bio-char, (b) Bio-oil, and (c) Gases.</p>
          </caption>
          <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId33.jpeg?20261116014520" />
          <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId34.jpeg?20261116014520" />
          <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId35.jpeg?20261116014520" />
          <p>(a) (b) (c)</p>
        </fig>
        <fig id="fig10">
          <label>Figure 10</label>
          <caption>
            <p>Relationship between retention and the yields of (a)Bio-char, (b) Bio-oil, and (c) Gases.</p>
          </caption>
          <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId36.jpeg?20261116014520" />
          <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId37.jpeg?20261116014520" />
          <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId38.jpeg?20261116014519" />
          <p>(a) (b) (c)</p>
        </fig>
        <fig id="fig11">
          <label>Figure 11</label>
          <caption>
            <p>Relationship between temperature and the yields of (a) Bio-char, (b) Bio-oil, and (c) Gases.</p>
          </caption>
          <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId39.jpeg?20261116014519" />
          <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId40.jpeg?20261116014519" />
          <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId41.jpeg?20261116014519" />
          <p>(a) (b) (c)</p>
        </fig>
        <fig id="fig12">
          <label>Figure 12</label>
          <caption>
            <p>Relationship between atmosphere and the yields of a) Bio-char, b) Bio-oil, and c) Gases.</p>
          </caption>
          <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId42.jpeg?20261116014519" />
          <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId43.jpeg?20261116014519" />
          <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId44.jpeg?20261116014519" />
          <p>(a) (b) (c)</p>
        </fig>
      </sec>
      <sec id="sec3dot5">
        <title>3.5. Sensitivity Analyses with Trim-and-Fill</title>
        <p>The nonparametric trim-and-fill sensitivity analysis presented in <bold>Table 3</bold> indicated no evidence of publication bias. The key publication bias was caused by the small sample size. In future research, a relatively larger sample size of studies will be included, covering various types of straw and various carbonization process conditions.</p>
        <p><bold>Table 3</bold><bold>.</bold>Sensitivity analyses with trim-and-fill.</p>
        <table-wrap id="tbl3">
          <label>Table 3</label>
          <table>
            <tbody>
              <tr>
                <td>
                  <bold>Items</bold>
                </td>
                <td>
                  <bold>Studies</bold>
                </td>
                <td>
                  <bold>Effect size</bold>
                </td>
                <td>
                  <bold>[95% conf.</bold>
                </td>
                <td>
                  <bold>interval]</bold>
                </td>
              </tr>
              <tr>
                <td rowspan="2">Bio-char</td>
                <td>Observed</td>
                <td>32.543</td>
                <td>23.724</td>
                <td>41.363</td>
              </tr>
              <tr>
                <td>Observed + Imputed</td>
                <td>32.543</td>
                <td>23.724</td>
                <td>41.363</td>
              </tr>
              <tr>
                <td rowspan="2">Bio-oil</td>
                <td>Observed</td>
                <td>16.733</td>
                <td>16.346</td>
                <td>17.12</td>
              </tr>
              <tr>
                <td>Observed + Imputed</td>
                <td>16.733</td>
                <td>16.346</td>
                <td>17.12</td>
              </tr>
              <tr>
                <td rowspan="2">Gases</td>
                <td>Observed</td>
                <td>15.264</td>
                <td>14.766</td>
                <td>15.763</td>
              </tr>
              <tr>
                <td>Observed + Imputed</td>
                <td>15.264</td>
                <td>14.766</td>
                <td>15.763</td>
              </tr>
            </tbody>
          </table>
        </table-wrap>
      </sec>
    </sec>
    <sec id="sec4">
      <title>4. Discussion and Conclusion</title>
      <p>This research employs a meta-analysis method to systematically analyze the relevant studies published in English language from 2015 to 2026, focusing on the effects of crop straw types (rice, wheat, corn, sorghum, rapeseed, cotton, and soybean) and carbonization conditions (FC, volatile matter, temperature, heating rate, retention time, and atmosphere) on the yields of Bio-char, Bio-oil, and Gases. It is found that there is a significant statistical difference in their average yields for the selected types of straw. Their values can be partly explained by the components, such as FC, volatile matter, hemicellulose, cellulose, and lignin in the selected types of straw, as well as the carbonization conditions. Due to the impacts of the sampling size, the precise yields of Bio-char, Bio-oil, and Gases of the selected types of straw need further exploration or simulation by ASPEN. In terms of the influence of carbonization conditions on Bio-char, Bio-oil, and Gases, FC, volatile matter, temperature, heating rate, retention time, and atmosphere have different impacts on them. FC in the selected types of straw generally has a positive relationship with Bio-char and Bio-oil, but a negative relationship with Gases. Volatile matter in the selected types of straw generally has a positive relationship with the yield of bio-char, but a negative relationship with Bio-oil and Gases. Multiple components in crop straws, such as cellulose, lignin, and hemicellulose, can be used to generate Bio-char, Bio-oil, and Gases [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B14">14</xref>]. Several studies have paid attention to the relationship between components (FC and volatile matter) of crop straws and the product yields. FC and volatile matter are the key components in crop straws, with a total concentration over 68%. Volatile matter is positively related to Bio-char; however, as the pyrolysis temperature increases, the yield of bio-char and gases decreases while the yield of bio-oil increases. The relationship between volatile matter and Bio-char, Bio-oil, and Gases changes [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B30">30</xref>]. Heating rate typically has a positive relationship with Bio-oil and Gases while a negative relationship with Bio-char. A high heating rate contributed to more Bio-oil compared with a low heating rate [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B21">21</xref>]. A low heating rate favors bio-char formation as the main product [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B30">30</xref>]. Retention has a positive relationship with Gases and Bio-oil while a negative relationship with Bio-char. Usually, retention has a diverse or opposite effect to heating rate; in this research, the relation between heating rate and Bio-char, Bio-oil, and Gases is not opposite to that between retention and them. The inconsistency might be caused by the small sample size or might be caused by the combined effect of the various carbonization conditions. Pyrolysis temperature has a positive relationship with Bio-oil while a negative relationship with Bio-char and Gases. This is not consistent with several existing studies that conclude that 300˚C - 700˚C is the recommended pyrolysis temperature range. Pyrolysis temperature and the type of substrates used, usually measured by FC and volatile matter, are the two main parameters that affect them [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B31">31</xref>]. Generally, higher pyrolysis temperatures increase the yield of carbon (Bio-char) [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B14">14</xref>]; however, after a certain pyrolysis temperature, Bio-char decreases whereas the yield of bio-oil increases. According to Li <italic>et</italic><italic>al.</italic> [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B30">30</xref>], as pyrolysis temperature increases, the yield of bio-char decreases and the effects of pyrolysis temperature on bio-char yields are similar for different types of straw. Furthermore, Cheng <italic>et</italic><italic>al.</italic> [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B32">32</xref>] argue that pyrolysis temperature has a more obvious effect compared with retention. An inert atmosphere has a positive relationship with bio-oil yields, while a negative relationship with bio-char and gas yields. Atmosphere is one of the key factors that affect the pyrolysis process and bio-char, bio-oil, and gas yields. However, the findings in existing studies are controversial. Some studies [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B33">33</xref>] conclude that CO<sub>2</sub> atmosphere significantly increases bio-oil yield while decreasing gas yield; other studies [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B34">34</xref>] report CO<sub>2</sub> atmosphere reduces bio-oil yield. In fact, the yields of Bio-char, Bio-oil, and Gases are the result of the combined effect of multiple factors. It needs an optimization program using ASPEN before carrying out the pyrolysis process of various types of straw [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B35">35</xref>], along with the traditional tile kiln and charcoal kiln. Maximum yields of bio-char, bio-oil, and gas can be achieved at suitable temperatures (300˚C to 700˚C), suitable retention times (0.1 - 2 h), and suitable heating rates (0.1˚C/s to 1˚C/s), with an inert atmosphere (N<sub>2</sub>), which is proven by several studies [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B30">30</xref>] [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B36">36</xref>]. Thus, this research generates the hypothesis that it provides a practice guide for industry and research institutions to formulate targeted carbonization plans based on different types of straw, and enhance the efficiency of straw resource utilization, especially by making good use of the traditional tile kiln and charcoal kiln.</p>
      <p>In all, it is found that there is a significant statistical difference in the average bio-char, bio-oil, and gas yields of the selected types of straw, such as crop straw, mainly including rice, wheat, corn, sorghum, rapeseed, cotton, and soybean straws. The carbonization conditions (FC, volatile matter, temperature, heating rate, retention time, and atmosphere) have different effects on the yields of bio-char, bio-oil, and gases. These yields are the result of the combined effect of multiple factors. Thus, optimal conditions—a suitable temperature (300˚C to 700˚C), a suitable retention time (0.1 - 2 h), a suitable heating rate (0.1˚C/s to 1˚C/s), and an inert atmosphere (N<sub>2</sub>)—are recommended for straw carbonization.</p>
      <p>However, this research has its limitations. Firstly, a limited number of studies was chosen. Secondly, it does not investigate deep into the sources of heterogeneity. Particle size, drying degree, and carbonization equipment are also the affecting factors, which are not taken into consideration. Thirdly, the selected studies mainly are based on short-term indoor experiments, lacking long-term carbonization test data. Fourthly, this research may introduce language bias due to the exclusion of non-English literature, especially in a field where many straw pyrolysis studies may be published in Chinese, which had been confirmed in the studies using CiteSpace. The future study will address these limitations, expand the scope of the research, increase the geographical coverage, incorporate more relevant studies from developing countries, and further enhance the universality of the research conclusions. Additionally, it will take more factors into consideration. Furthermore, it will supplement long-term experimental data to explore the changes in the components of the straw during the long-term carbonization process and the dynamic changes in bio-char, bio-oil, and gas yields. Before carrying out the carbonization process of straw using traditional tile kiln and charcoal kiln, ASPEN simulations should be conducted to find suitable carbonization conditions. Alternatively, the meta-analysis should be conducted using the network visualizations or network meta-analysis reporting so as to improve transparency in pooled condition-ranking interpretation and deal with the meta-analysis with substantial heterogeneity [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B6">6</xref>] [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B7">7</xref>] [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B37">37</xref>] [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B38">38</xref>].</p>
    </sec>
    <sec id="sec5">
      <title>Highlights</title>
      <p>There is a significant statistical difference in the average bio-char, bio-oil, and gas yields of the selected types of straw. Carbonization conditions (types of straw, temperature, heating rate, retention, and atmosphere) have impacts on bio-char, bio-oil, and gas yields.Bio-char, bio-oil, and gas yields are the result of the combined effect of multiple factors, representing the overall outcome.Suitable temperature (300˚C to 700˚C), suitable retention (0.1 - 2 h) and suitable heating rate (0.1˚C/s to 1˚C/s) with an inert atmosphere (N<sub>2</sub>) are recommended while carrying out the carbonization process of straw, which should be confirmed through ASPEN simulations.</p>
    </sec>
    <sec id="sec6">
      <title>Acknowledgements</title>
      <p>The authors would like to acknowledge the previous researchers and the comments from the reviewers and editors. All data supporting this study are provided in full in the paper.</p>
    </sec>
    <sec id="sec7">
      <title>Author Contributions</title>
      <p>Li Lianfa is responsible for the following: study conception and design, data collection, data analysis and interpretation of results, and manuscript preparation. Li Yaxin is responsible for the following: data collection, data analysis and interpretation of results, and proofreading. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.</p>
    </sec>
    <sec id="sec8">
      <title>Supplementary Information</title>
      <p><bold>Table S1.</bold>Meta-regression analysis of key components of types of straw and Bio-char, Bio-oil, and Gases.</p>
      <table-wrap id="tbl4">
        <label>Table 4</label>
        <table>
          <tbody>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <bold>Effect size</bold>
              </td>
              <td>
                <bold>_meta_es</bold>
              </td>
              <td>
                <bold>Coefficient</bold>
              </td>
              <td>
                <bold>Std. err.</bold>
              </td>
              <td>
                <italic>
                  <bold>z</bold>
                </italic>
              </td>
              <td>
                <italic>
                  <bold>p</bold>
                </italic>
                <bold>&gt;</bold>
                <italic>
                  <bold>z</bold>
                </italic>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>Bio-char</td>
              <td>FC</td>
              <td>1.68</td>
              <td>1.40</td>
              <td>1.20</td>
              <td>0.229</td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>Bio-oil</td>
              <td>FC</td>
              <td>1.52</td>
              <td>2.29</td>
              <td>0.67</td>
              <td>0.505</td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>Gases</td>
              <td>FC</td>
              <td>−0.83</td>
              <td>0.33</td>
              <td>−0.97</td>
              <td>0.332</td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>Bio-char</td>
              <td>Volatile matter</td>
              <td>2.49</td>
              <td>2.44</td>
              <td>−0.34</td>
              <td>0.735</td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>Bio-oil</td>
              <td>Volatile matter</td>
              <td>−0.83</td>
              <td>2.15</td>
              <td>−0.39</td>
              <td>0.699</td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>Gases</td>
              <td>Volatile matter</td>
              <td>−0.63</td>
              <td>2.29</td>
              <td>−0.27</td>
              <td>0.784</td>
            </tr>
          </tbody>
        </table>
      </table-wrap>
      <p><bold>Table S2.</bold> Key components of types of straws [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B14">14</xref>].</p>
      <table-wrap id="tbl5">
        <label>Table 5</label>
        <table>
          <tbody>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <bold>Component</bold>
              </td>
              <td>
                <bold>Cotton stalk</bold>
              </td>
              <td>
                <bold>Rice straw</bold>
              </td>
              <td>
                <bold>Wheat straw</bold>
              </td>
              <td>
                <bold>Corn stover</bold>
              </td>
              <td>
                <bold>Rape stalk</bold>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>Cellulose/%</td>
              <td>40.14 ± 0.87</td>
              <td>41.75 ± 0.04</td>
              <td>38.68 ± 0.01</td>
              <td>35.96 ± 0.67</td>
              <td>40.46 ± 0.45</td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>Hemicellulose/%</td>
              <td>1.73 ± 0.23</td>
              <td>14.20 ± 0.23</td>
              <td>17.90 ± 0.29</td>
              <td>13.68 ± 0.35</td>
              <td>13.40 ± 0.42</td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>Lignin/%</td>
              <td>27.45 ± 0.12</td>
              <td>20.46 ± 0.60</td>
              <td>22.47 ± 0.35</td>
              <td>22.50 ± 0.06</td>
              <td>18.54 ± 0.52</td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>Volatile matter/%</td>
              <td>82.38 ± 1.16</td>
              <td>76.87 ± 1.39</td>
              <td>80.70 ± 1.04</td>
              <td>82.21 ± 1.15</td>
              <td>86.09 ± 1.08</td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>Ash/%</td>
              <td>7.45 ± 0.21</td>
              <td>13.07 ± 0.16</td>
              <td>9.37 ± 0.32</td>
              <td>8.86 ± 0.18</td>
              <td>6.42 ± 0.19</td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>Fixed carbon/%</td>
              <td>10.17 ± 0.25</td>
              <td>10.06 ± 0.18</td>
              <td>9.93 ± 0.28</td>
              <td>8.93 ± 0.17</td>
              <td>7.49 ± 0.21</td>
            </tr>
          </tbody>
        </table>
      </table-wrap>
      <p><bold>Table S3.</bold> Meta-regression analysis of heating rate and Bio-char, Bio-oil, and Gases.</p>
      <table-wrap id="tbl6">
        <label>Table 6</label>
        <table>
          <tbody>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <bold>Effect size</bold>
              </td>
              <td>
                <bold>_meta_es</bold>
              </td>
              <td>
                <bold>Coefficient</bold>
              </td>
              <td>
                <bold>Std. err.</bold>
              </td>
              <td>
                <italic>
                  <bold>z</bold>
                </italic>
              </td>
              <td>
                <italic>
                  <bold>p</bold>
                </italic>
                <bold>&gt;</bold>
                <italic>
                  <bold>z</bold>
                </italic>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>Bio-char</td>
              <td>Heating rate</td>
              <td>−0.70</td>
              <td>0.79</td>
              <td>−0.89</td>
              <td>0.374</td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>Bio-oil</td>
              <td>Heating rate</td>
              <td>0.99</td>
              <td>1.00</td>
              <td>1</td>
              <td>0.318</td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>Gases</td>
              <td>Heating rate</td>
              <td>1.22</td>
              <td>0.94</td>
              <td>1.3</td>
              <td>0.194</td>
            </tr>
          </tbody>
        </table>
      </table-wrap>
      <p><bold>Table S4.</bold>Bio-char, Bio-oil, and Gases of various types of pyrolysis.</p>
      <table-wrap id="tbl7">
        <label>Table 7</label>
        <table>
          <tbody>
            <tr>
              <td>Types of pyrolysis</td>
              <td>Heating rate ˚C/min</td>
              <td>Retention</td>
              <td>Bio-char</td>
              <td>Bio-oil</td>
              <td>Gases</td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>slow</td>
              <td>0.1 - 1.0</td>
              <td>10 - 100 min</td>
              <td>35</td>
              <td>30%</td>
              <td>35</td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>fast</td>
              <td>10 - 200</td>
              <td>0.5 - 5.0 s</td>
              <td>20</td>
              <td>50%</td>
              <td>30%</td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>flash</td>
              <td>&gt;1000</td>
              <td>&lt;0.5 s</td>
              <td>12%</td>
              <td>75%</td>
              <td>13%</td>
            </tr>
          </tbody>
        </table>
      </table-wrap>
      <p>Source: Elshareef <italic>et</italic><italic>al.</italic> (2025) [<xref ref-type="bibr" rid="B22">22</xref>].</p>
      <p><bold>Table S5.</bold> Meta-regression analysis of retention and Bio-char, Bio-oil, and Gases.</p>
      <table-wrap id="tbl8">
        <label>Table 8</label>
        <table>
          <tbody>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <bold>Effect size</bold>
              </td>
              <td>
                <bold>_meta_es</bold>
              </td>
              <td>
                <bold>Coefficient</bold>
              </td>
              <td>
                <bold>Std. err.</bold>
              </td>
              <td>
                <italic>
                  <bold>z</bold>
                </italic>
              </td>
              <td>
                <italic>
                  <bold>p</bold>
                </italic>
                <bold>&gt;</bold>
                <italic>
                  <bold>z</bold>
                </italic>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>Bio-char</td>
              <td>Retention</td>
              <td>−0.09</td>
              <td>0.11</td>
              <td>−0.86</td>
              <td>0.388</td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>Bio-oil</td>
              <td>Retention</td>
              <td>0.15</td>
              <td>0.16</td>
              <td>0.94</td>
              <td>0.347</td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>Gases</td>
              <td>Retention</td>
              <td>0.09</td>
              <td>0.11</td>
              <td>0.81</td>
              <td>0.42</td>
            </tr>
          </tbody>
        </table>
      </table-wrap>
      <p><bold>Table S6.</bold>Meta-regression analysis of temperature and Bio-char, Bio-oil, and Gases.</p>
      <table-wrap id="tbl9">
        <label>Table 9</label>
        <table>
          <tbody>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <bold>Effect size</bold>
              </td>
              <td>
                <bold>_meta_es</bold>
              </td>
              <td>
                <bold>Coefficient</bold>
              </td>
              <td>
                <bold>Std. err.</bold>
              </td>
              <td>
                <italic>
                  <bold>z</bold>
                </italic>
              </td>
              <td>
                <italic>
                  <bold>p</bold>
                </italic>
                <bold>&gt;</bold>
                <italic>
                  <bold>z</bold>
                </italic>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>Bio-char</td>
              <td>Temperature</td>
              <td>−0.07</td>
              <td>0.02</td>
              <td>−3.14</td>
              <td>0.001</td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>Bio-oil</td>
              <td>Temperature</td>
              <td>0.03</td>
              <td>0.04</td>
              <td>0.82</td>
              <td>0.414</td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>Gases</td>
              <td>Temperature</td>
              <td>−0.05</td>
              <td>0.02</td>
              <td>−2.15</td>
              <td>0.031</td>
            </tr>
          </tbody>
        </table>
      </table-wrap>
      <p><bold>Table S7.</bold> Meta-regression analysis of inert atmosphere and Bio-char, Bio-oil, and Gases.</p>
      <table-wrap id="tbl10">
        <label>Table 10</label>
        <table>
          <tbody>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <bold>Effect size</bold>
              </td>
              <td>
                <bold>_meta_es</bold>
              </td>
              <td>
                <bold>Coefficient</bold>
              </td>
              <td>
                <bold>Std. err.</bold>
              </td>
              <td>
                <italic>
                  <bold>z</bold>
                </italic>
              </td>
              <td>
                <italic>
                  <bold>p</bold>
                </italic>
                <bold>&gt;</bold>
                <italic>
                  <bold>z</bold>
                </italic>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>Bio-char</td>
              <td>code_atm</td>
              <td>−0.88</td>
              <td>8.19</td>
              <td>−0.11</td>
              <td>0.915</td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>Bio-oil</td>
              <td>code_atm</td>
              <td>6.97</td>
              <td>10.54</td>
              <td>0.66</td>
              <td>0.508</td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>Gases</td>
              <td>code_atm</td>
              <td>−5.59</td>
              <td>6.82</td>
              <td>−0.82</td>
              <td>0.413</td>
            </tr>
          </tbody>
        </table>
      </table-wrap>
    </sec>
    <sec id="sec9">
      <title>Forest Plots of Studies on Bio-Oil</title>
      <fig id="fig13">
        <label>Figure 13</label>
        <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId81.jpeg?20261116014528" />
      </fig>
      <p><bold>Figure S1.</bold> Overall analysis of studies on Bio-oil.</p>
      <fig id="fig14">
        <label>Figure 14</label>
        <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId82.jpeg?20261116014528" />
      </fig>
      <p><bold>Figure S2</bold><bold>.</bold>Sensitive analysis of studies on Bio-oil.</p>
      <fig id="fig15">
        <label>Figure 15</label>
        <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId83.jpeg?20261116014528" />
      </fig>
      <p><bold>Figure S3</bold><bold>.</bold>Sub-group analysis of studies on Bio-oil.</p>
    </sec>
    <sec id="sec10">
      <title>Forest Plots of Studies on Gases</title>
      <fig id="fig16">
        <label>Figure 16</label>
        <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId84.jpeg?20261116014529" />
      </fig>
      <p><bold>Figure S4</bold><bold>.</bold>Overall analysis of studies on Gases.</p>
      <fig id="fig17">
        <label>Figure 17</label>
        <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId85.jpeg?20261116014529" />
      </fig>
      <p><bold>Figure S5</bold><bold>.</bold>Sensitive analysis of studies on Gases.</p>
      <fig id="fig18">
        <label>Figure 18</label>
        <graphic xlink:href="https://html.scirp.org/file/1741596-rId86.jpeg?20261116014529" />
      </fig>
      <p><bold>Figure S6</bold><bold>.</bold>Sub-group analysis of studies on Gases.</p>
    </sec>
  </body>
  <back>
    <ref-list>
      <title>References</title>
      <ref id="B1">
        <label>1.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="other">Li, H., Dai, M., Dai, S. and Dong, X. (2018) Current Status and Environment Impact of Direct Straw Return in China’s Cropland—A Review. <italic>Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety</italic>, 159, 293-300. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoenv.2018.05.014 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1016/j.ecoenv.2018.05.014</pub-id><pub-id pub-id-type="pmid">29763811</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoenv.2018.05.014">https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoenv.2018.05.014</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="other">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Li, H.</string-name>
              <string-name>Dai, M.</string-name>
              <string-name>Dai, S.</string-name>
              <string-name>Dong, X.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2018</year>
            <article-title>Current Status and Environment Impact of Direct Straw Return in China’s Cropland—A Review</article-title>
            <source>Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety</source>
            <volume>159</volume>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1016/j.ecoenv.2018.05.014</pub-id>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="pmid">29763811</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B2">
        <label>2.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="journal">Chen, B., Mohrmann, S., Li, H., Gaff, M., Lorenzo, R., Corbi, I., <italic>et al</italic>. (2023) Research and Application Progress of Straw. <italic>Journal of Renewable Materials</italic>, 11, 599-623. https://doi.org/10.32604/jrm.2022.022452 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.32604/jrm.2022.022452</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.32604/jrm.2022.022452">https://doi.org/10.32604/jrm.2022.022452</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="journal">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Chen, B.</string-name>
              <string-name>Mohrmann, S.</string-name>
              <string-name>Li, H.</string-name>
              <string-name>Gaff, M.</string-name>
              <string-name>Lorenzo, R.</string-name>
              <string-name>Corbi, I.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2023</year>
            <article-title>Research and Application Progress of Straw</article-title>
            <source>Journal of Renewable Materials</source>
            <volume>11</volume>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.32604/jrm.2022.022452</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B3">
        <label>3.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="other">Ninkuu, V., Liu, Z., Qin, A., Xie, Y., Song, X. and Sun, X. (2025) Impact of Straw Returning on Soil Ecology and Crop Yield: A Review. <italic>Heliyon</italic>, 11, e41651. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2025.e41651 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1016/j.heliyon.2025.e41651</pub-id><pub-id pub-id-type="pmid">39882467</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2025.e41651">https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2025.e41651</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="other">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Ninkuu, V.</string-name>
              <string-name>Liu, Z.</string-name>
              <string-name>Qin, A.</string-name>
              <string-name>Xie, Y.</string-name>
              <string-name>Song, X.</string-name>
              <string-name>Sun, X.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2025</year>
            <article-title>Impact of Straw Returning on Soil Ecology and Crop Yield: A Review</article-title>
            <source>Heliyon</source>
            <volume>11</volume>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1016/j.heliyon.2025.e41651</pub-id>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="pmid">39882467</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B4">
        <label>4.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="other">Loc, N.X. and Phuong, D.T.M. (2025) Optimizing Biochar Production: A Review of Recent Progress in Lignocellulosic Biomass Pyrolysis. <italic>Engineering Agriculture</italic>, 12, 148-172.</mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="other">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Loc, N.X.</string-name>
              <string-name>Phuong, D.T.M.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2025</year>
            <article-title>Optimizing Biochar Production: A Review of Recent Progress in Lignocellulosic Biomass Pyrolysis</article-title>
            <source>Engineering Agriculture</source>
            <volume>12</volume>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B5">
        <label>5.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="journal">Ma, C., He, Z., Xiang, J., Ding, K., Zhang, Z., Ye, C., <italic>et al</italic>. (2025) A Meta-Analysis to Explore the Impact of Straw Decomposing Microorganism Inoculant-Amended Straw on Soil Organic Carbon Stocks. <italic>Journal of Integrative Agriculture</italic>, 24, 1577-1587. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jia.2025.02.002 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1016/j.jia.2025.02.002</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jia.2025.02.002">https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jia.2025.02.002</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="journal">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Ma, C.</string-name>
              <string-name>He, Z.</string-name>
              <string-name>Xiang, J.</string-name>
              <string-name>Ding, K.</string-name>
              <string-name>Zhang, Z.</string-name>
              <string-name>Ye, C.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2025</year>
            <article-title>A Meta-Analysis to Explore the Impact of Straw Decomposing Microorganism Inoculant-Amended Straw on Soil Organic Carbon Stocks</article-title>
            <source>Journal of Integrative Agriculture</source>
            <volume>24</volume>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1016/j.jia.2025.02.002</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B6">
        <label>6.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="journal">Page, M.J., McKenzie, J.E., Bossuyt, P.M., Boutron, I., Hoffmann, T.C., Mulrow, C.D., <italic>et al</italic>. (2021) The PRISMA 2020 Statement: An Updated Guideline for Reporting Systematic Reviews. <italic>PLOS Medicine</italic>, 18, e1003583. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmed.1003583 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1371/journal.pmed.1003583</pub-id><pub-id pub-id-type="pmid">33780438</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmed.1003583">https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmed.1003583</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="journal">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Page, M.J.</string-name>
              <string-name>McKenzie, J.E.</string-name>
              <string-name>Bossuyt, P.M.</string-name>
              <string-name>Boutron, I.</string-name>
              <string-name>Hoffmann, T.C.</string-name>
              <string-name>Mulrow, C.D.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2021</year>
            <article-title>The PRISMA 2020 Statement: An Updated Guideline for Reporting Systematic Reviews</article-title>
            <source>PLOS Medicine</source>
            <volume>18</volume>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1371/journal.pmed.1003583</pub-id>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="pmid">33780438</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B7">
        <label>7.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="other">Xing, X., Fan, F. and Jiang, W. (2018) Characteristics of Biochar Pellets from Corn Straw under Different Pyrolysis Temperatures. <italic>Royal Society Open Science</italic>, 5, Article 172346. https://doi.org/10.1098/rsos.172346 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1098/rsos.172346</pub-id><pub-id pub-id-type="pmid">30224998</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1098/rsos.172346">https://doi.org/10.1098/rsos.172346</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="other">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Xing, X.</string-name>
              <string-name>Fan, F.</string-name>
              <string-name>Jiang, W.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2018</year>
            <article-title>Characteristics of Biochar Pellets from Corn Straw under Different Pyrolysis Temperatures</article-title>
            <source>Royal Society Open Science</source>
            <volume>5</volume>
            <elocation-id>172346</elocation-id>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1098/rsos.172346</pub-id>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="pmid">30224998</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B8">
        <label>8.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="journal">Rafiq, M.K., Bachmann, R.T., Rafiq, M.T., Shang, Z., Joseph, S. and Long, R. (2016) Influence of Pyrolysis Temperature on Physico-Chemical Properties of Corn Stover ( <italic>Zea mays</italic> L.) Biochar and Feasibility for Carbon Capture and Energy Balance. <italic>PLOS ONE</italic>, 11, e0156894. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0156894 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1371/journal.pone.0156894</pub-id><pub-id pub-id-type="pmid">27327870</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0156894">https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0156894</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="journal">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Rafiq, M.K.</string-name>
              <string-name>Bachmann, R.T.</string-name>
              <string-name>Rafiq, M.T.</string-name>
              <string-name>Shang, Z.</string-name>
              <string-name>Joseph, S.</string-name>
              <string-name>Long, R.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2016</year>
            <article-title>Influence of Pyrolysis Temperature on Physico-Chemical Properties of Corn Stover (Zea mays L</article-title>
            <source>) Biochar and Feasibility for Carbon Capture and Energy Balance. PLOS ONE</source>
            <volume>11</volume>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1371/journal.pone.0156894</pub-id>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="pmid">27327870</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B9">
        <label>9.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="other">Ajikashile, J.O., Alhnidi, M., Parku, G.K., Funke, A. and Kruse, A. (2023) A Study on the Fast Pyrolysis of Millet and Sorghum Straws Sourced from Arid and Semi-Arid Regions of Nigeria in a Twin-Screw Mixing Reactor. <italic>Materials Science for Energy Technologies</italic>, 6, 388-398. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mset.2023.03.007 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1016/j.mset.2023.03.007</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mset.2023.03.007">https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mset.2023.03.007</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="other">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Ajikashile, J.O.</string-name>
              <string-name>Alhnidi, M.</string-name>
              <string-name>Parku, G.K.</string-name>
              <string-name>Funke, A.</string-name>
              <string-name>Kruse, A.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2023</year>
            <article-title>A Study on the Fast Pyrolysis of Millet and Sorghum Straws Sourced from Arid and Semi-Arid Regions of Nigeria in a Twin-Screw Mixing Reactor</article-title>
            <source>Materials Science for Energy Technologies</source>
            <volume>6</volume>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1016/j.mset.2023.03.007</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B10">
        <label>10.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="journal">Dhyani, V., Awasthi, A., Kumar, J. and Bhaskar, T. (2017) Pyrolysis of Sorghum Straw: Effect of Temperature and Reaction Environment on the Product Behavior. <italic>Journal of Energy and Environmental Sustainability</italic>, 4, 64-69. https://doi.org/10.47469/jees.2017.v04.100049 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.47469/jees.2017.v04.100049</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.47469/jees.2017.v04.100049">https://doi.org/10.47469/jees.2017.v04.100049</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="journal">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Dhyani, V.</string-name>
              <string-name>Awasthi, A.</string-name>
              <string-name>Kumar, J.</string-name>
              <string-name>Bhaskar, T.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2017</year>
            <article-title>Pyrolysis of Sorghum Straw: Effect of Temperature and Reaction Environment on the Product Behavior</article-title>
            <source>Journal of Energy and Environmental Sustainability</source>
            <volume>4</volume>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.47469/jees.2017.v04.100049</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B11">
        <label>11.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="other">Nath, B., Chen, G., Bowtell, L. and Nguyen‐Huy, T. (2024) Pyrolysis of Wheat Straw Pellets in a Pilot‐Scale Reactor: Effect of Temperature and Residence Time. <italic>Energy Science &amp; Engineering</italic>, 12, 3524-3539. https://doi.org/10.1002/ese3.1833 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1002/ese3.1833</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1002/ese3.1833">https://doi.org/10.1002/ese3.1833</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="other">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Nath, B.</string-name>
              <string-name>Chen, G.</string-name>
              <string-name>Bowtell, L.</string-name>
              <string-name>Huy, T.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2024</year>
            <article-title>Pyrolysis of Wheat Straw Pellets in a Pilot‐Scale Reactor: Effect of Temperature and Residence Time</article-title>
            <source>Energy Science &amp; Engineering</source>
            <volume>12</volume>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1002/ese3.1833</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B12">
        <label>12.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="other">Sedmihradská, A., Pohořelý, M., Jevič, P., Skoblia, S., Beňo, Z., Farták, J., <italic>et al</italic>. (2020) Pyrolysis of Wheat and Barley Straw. <italic>Research in Agricultural Engineering</italic>, 66, 8-17. https://doi.org/10.17221/26/2019-rae <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.17221/26/2019-rae</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.17221/26/2019-rae">https://doi.org/10.17221/26/2019-rae</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="other">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Skoblia, S.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2020</year>
            <article-title>Pyrolysis of Wheat and Barley Straw</article-title>
            <source>Research in Agricultural Engineering</source>
            <volume>66</volume>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.17221/26/2019-rae</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B13">
        <label>13.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="other">Dobariya, U.D., Gojiya, D.K., Makavana, J.M., Kelaiya, S.V., Gadhiya, G.A., Dulawat, M.S., <italic>et al</italic>. (2022) Influence of Temperature on the Production of Biochar from Cotton and Castor Feed Stalk in a Pyrolysis Process. <italic>Current World Environment</italic>, 17, 634-642. https://doi.org/10.12944/cwe.17.3.12 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.12944/cwe.17.3.12</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.12944/cwe.17.3.12">https://doi.org/10.12944/cwe.17.3.12</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="other">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Dobariya, U.D.</string-name>
              <string-name>Gojiya, D.K.</string-name>
              <string-name>Makavana, J.M.</string-name>
              <string-name>Kelaiya, S.V.</string-name>
              <string-name>Gadhiya, G.A.</string-name>
              <string-name>Dulawat, M.S.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2022</year>
            <article-title>Influence of Temperature on the Production of Biochar from Cotton and Castor Feed Stalk in a Pyrolysis Process</article-title>
            <source>Current World Environment</source>
            <volume>17</volume>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.12944/cwe.17.3.12</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B14">
        <label>14.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="other">Liu, Z., Niu, W., Chu, H., Zhou, T. and Niu, Z. (2018) Effect of the Carbonization Temperature on the Properties of Biochar Produced from the Pyrolysis of Crop Residues. <italic>BioResources</italic>, 13, 3429-3446. https://doi.org/10.15376/biores.13.2.3429-3446 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.15376/biores.13.2.3429-3446</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.15376/biores.13.2.3429-3446">https://doi.org/10.15376/biores.13.2.3429-3446</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="other">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Liu, Z.</string-name>
              <string-name>Niu, W.</string-name>
              <string-name>Chu, H.</string-name>
              <string-name>Zhou, T.</string-name>
              <string-name>Niu, Z.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2018</year>
            <article-title>Effect of the Carbonization Temperature on the Properties of Biochar Produced from the Pyrolysis of Crop Residues</article-title>
            <source>BioResources</source>
            <volume>13</volume>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.15376/biores.13.2.3429-3446</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B15">
        <label>15.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="confproc">Sakhiya, A.K., Baghel, P., Pathak, S., Vijay, V.K. and Kaushal, P. (2020) Effect of Process Parameters on Slow Pyrolysis of Rice Straw: Product Yield and Energy Analysis. 2020 <italic>International Conference and Utility Exhibition on Energy</italic>, <italic>Environment and Climate Change</italic> ( <italic>ICUE</italic>), Pattaya, 20-22 October 2020, 1-9. https://doi.org/10.1109/icue49301.2020.9306945 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1109/icue49301.2020.9306945</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1109/icue49301.2020.9306945">https://doi.org/10.1109/icue49301.2020.9306945</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="confproc">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Sakhiya, A.K.</string-name>
              <string-name>Baghel, P.</string-name>
              <string-name>Pathak, S.</string-name>
              <string-name>Vijay, V.K.</string-name>
              <string-name>Kaushal, P.</string-name>
              <string-name>Energy, E</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2020</year>
            <article-title>Effect of Process Parameters on Slow Pyrolysis of Rice Straw: Product Yield and Energy Analysis</article-title>
            <source>2020 International Conference and Utility Exhibition on Energy</source>
            <volume>20</volume>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1109/icue49301.2020.9306945</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B16">
        <label>16.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="journal">Klunk, M.A., Dasgupta, S. and Das, M. (2018) Slow Pyrolysis of Rice Straw: Analysis of Biochar, Bio-Oil and Gas. <italic>Southern Brazilian Journal of Chemistry</italic>, 26, 17-25. https://doi.org/10.48141/sbjchem.v26.n26.2018.22_2018.pdf <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.48141/sbjchem.v26.n26.2018.22_2018.pdf</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.48141/sbjchem.v26.n26.2018.22_2018.pdf">https://doi.org/10.48141/sbjchem.v26.n26.2018.22_2018.pdf</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="journal">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Klunk, M.A.</string-name>
              <string-name>Dasgupta, S.</string-name>
              <string-name>Das, M.</string-name>
              <string-name>Biochar, B</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2018</year>
            <article-title>Slow Pyrolysis of Rice Straw: Analysis of Biochar, Bio-Oil and Gas</article-title>
            <source>Southern Brazilian Journal of Chemistry</source>
            <volume>26</volume>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.48141/sbjchem.v26.n26.2018.22_2018.pdf</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B17">
        <label>17.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="journal">Zhang, L., Li, K. and Zhu, X. (2017) Study on Two-Step Pyrolysis of Soybean Stalk by TG-FTIR and Py-Gc/Ms. <italic>Journal of Analytical and Applied Pyrolysis</italic>, 127, 91-98. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jaap.2017.08.019 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1016/j.jaap.2017.08.019</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jaap.2017.08.019">https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jaap.2017.08.019</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="journal">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Zhang, L.</string-name>
              <string-name>Li, K.</string-name>
              <string-name>Zhu, X.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2017</year>
            <article-title>Study on Two-Step Pyrolysis of Soybean Stalk by TG-FTIR and Py-Gc/Ms</article-title>
            <source>Journal of Analytical and Applied Pyrolysis</source>
            <volume>127</volume>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1016/j.jaap.2017.08.019</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B18">
        <label>18.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="other">Yang, K., Lin, E., Xu, W., Zhu, L. and Tong, T. (2025) An Alternative Measure for Quantifying the Heterogeneity in Meta‐Analysis. <italic>Statistics in Medicine</italic>, 44, 10-12. https://doi.org/10.1002/sim.70089 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1002/sim.70089</pub-id><pub-id pub-id-type="pmid">40405379</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1002/sim.70089">https://doi.org/10.1002/sim.70089</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="other">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Yang, K.</string-name>
              <string-name>Lin, E.</string-name>
              <string-name>Xu, W.</string-name>
              <string-name>Zhu, L.</string-name>
              <string-name>Tong, T.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2025</year>
            <article-title>An Alternative Measure for Quantifying the Heterogeneity in Meta‐Analysis</article-title>
            <source>Statistics in Medicine</source>
            <volume>44</volume>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1002/sim.70089</pub-id>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="pmid">40405379</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B19">
        <label>19.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="journal">Hassan, M. and Strezov, V. (2025) Wheat Straw Pyrolysis Fundamentals during Production of Biochar. <italic>Journal of Thermal Analysis and Calorimetry</italic>, 150, 14903-14914. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10973-025-14766-9 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1007/s10973-025-14766-9</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1007/s10973-025-14766-9">https://doi.org/10.1007/s10973-025-14766-9</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="journal">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Hassan, M.</string-name>
              <string-name>Strezov, V.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2025</year>
            <article-title>Wheat Straw Pyrolysis Fundamentals during Production of Biochar</article-title>
            <source>Journal of Thermal Analysis and Calorimetry</source>
            <volume>150</volume>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1007/s10973-025-14766-9</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B20">
        <label>20.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="other">Liu, Z., Niu, W., Chu, H. and Niu, Z. (2018) Process Optimization for Straws Pyrolysis and Analysis of Biochar Physiochemical Properties. <italic>Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering</italic>, 34, 196-203. (In Chinese)</mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="other">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Liu, Z.</string-name>
              <string-name>Niu, W.</string-name>
              <string-name>Chu, H.</string-name>
              <string-name>Niu, Z.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2018</year>
            <article-title>Process Optimization for Straws Pyrolysis and Analysis of Biochar Physiochemical Properties</article-title>
            <source>Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering</source>
            <volume>34</volume>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B21">
        <label>21.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="journal">Sahoo, K., Kumar, A. and Chakraborty, J.P. (2020) A Comparative Study on Valuable Products: Bio-Oil, Biochar, Non-Condensable Gases from Pyrolysis of Agricultural Residues. <italic>Journal of Material Cycles and Waste Management</italic>, 23, 186-204. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10163-020-01114-2 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1007/s10163-020-01114-2</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1007/s10163-020-01114-2">https://doi.org/10.1007/s10163-020-01114-2</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="journal">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Sahoo, K.</string-name>
              <string-name>Kumar, A.</string-name>
              <string-name>Chakraborty, J.P.</string-name>
              <string-name>Bio-Oil, B</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2020</year>
            <article-title>A Comparative Study on Valuable Products: Bio-Oil, Biochar, Non-Condensable Gases from Pyrolysis of Agricultural Residues</article-title>
            <source>Journal of Material Cycles and Waste Management</source>
            <volume>23</volume>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1007/s10163-020-01114-2</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B22">
        <label>22.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="journal">Elshareef, H., Yu, Y., Fu, Y., Ren, S., Tursunov, O., Li, Y., <italic>et al</italic>. (2025) Bio-Energy Potential of Cotton Stalks via Thermal Technologies: A Review. <italic>Journal of Cotton Research</italic>, 8, Article No. 36. https://doi.org/10.1186/s42397-025-00241-1 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1186/s42397-025-00241-1</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1186/s42397-025-00241-1">https://doi.org/10.1186/s42397-025-00241-1</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="journal">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Elshareef, H.</string-name>
              <string-name>Yu, Y.</string-name>
              <string-name>Fu, Y.</string-name>
              <string-name>Ren, S.</string-name>
              <string-name>Tursunov, O.</string-name>
              <string-name>Li, Y.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2025</year>
            <article-title>Bio-Energy Potential of Cotton Stalks via Thermal Technologies: A Review</article-title>
            <source>Journal of Cotton Research</source>
            <volume>8</volume>
            <elocation-id>No</elocation-id>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1186/s42397-025-00241-1</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B23">
        <label>23.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="other">Wang, S., Li, P., Bao, Y., Pei, Z., Liang, S., Yang, X., <italic>et al</italic>. (2026) Effects of Pyrolysis Carbonization Time of Corn Stalks on Microbial Communities in Biogas Production with Livestock and Poultry Manure as Fermentation Substrate. <italic>Energies</italic>, 19, Article 1614. https://doi.org/10.3390/en19071614 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.3390/en19071614</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.3390/en19071614">https://doi.org/10.3390/en19071614</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="other">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Wang, S.</string-name>
              <string-name>Li, P.</string-name>
              <string-name>Bao, Y.</string-name>
              <string-name>Pei, Z.</string-name>
              <string-name>Liang, S.</string-name>
              <string-name>Yang, X.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2026</year>
            <article-title>Effects of Pyrolysis Carbonization Time of Corn Stalks on Microbial Communities in Biogas Production with Livestock and Poultry Manure as Fermentation Substrate</article-title>
            <source>Energies</source>
            <volume>19</volume>
            <elocation-id>1614</elocation-id>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.3390/en19071614</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B24">
        <label>24.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="other">Wang, Y., Mu, J., Zhang, X., Ding, X., Zheng, M. and Guo, T. (2025) Optimized Torrefaction of Corn Straw in a Screw Reactor: Energy Balance Analysis and Biochar Production Enhancement. <italic>Processes</italic>, 13, Article 1302. https://doi.org/10.3390/pr13051302 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.3390/pr13051302</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.3390/pr13051302">https://doi.org/10.3390/pr13051302</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="other">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Wang, Y.</string-name>
              <string-name>Mu, J.</string-name>
              <string-name>Zhang, X.</string-name>
              <string-name>Ding, X.</string-name>
              <string-name>Zheng, M.</string-name>
              <string-name>Guo, T.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2025</year>
            <article-title>Optimized Torrefaction of Corn Straw in a Screw Reactor: Energy Balance Analysis and Biochar Production Enhancement</article-title>
            <source>Processes</source>
            <volume>13</volume>
            <elocation-id>1302</elocation-id>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.3390/pr13051302</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B25">
        <label>25.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="other">Tagade, A., Kirti, N. and Sawarkar, A.N. (2021) Pyrolysis of Agricultural Crop Residues: An Overview of Researches by Indian Scientific Community. <italic>Bioresource Technology Reports</italic>, 15, Article 100761. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biteb.2021.100761 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1016/j.biteb.2021.100761</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biteb.2021.100761">https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biteb.2021.100761</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="other">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Tagade, A.</string-name>
              <string-name>Kirti, N.</string-name>
              <string-name>Sawarkar, A.N.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2021</year>
            <article-title>Pyrolysis of Agricultural Crop Residues: An Overview of Researches by Indian Scientific Community</article-title>
            <source>Bioresource Technology Reports</source>
            <volume>15</volume>
            <elocation-id>100761</elocation-id>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1016/j.biteb.2021.100761</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B26">
        <label>26.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="other">Sakhiya, A.K., Anand, A., Aier, I., Vijay, V.K. and Kaushal, P. (2021) Suitability of Rice Straw for Biochar Production through Slow Pyrolysis: Product Characterization and Thermodynamic Analysis. <italic>Bioresource Technology Reports</italic>, 15, Article 100818. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biteb.2021.100818 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1016/j.biteb.2021.100818</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biteb.2021.100818">https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biteb.2021.100818</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="other">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Sakhiya, A.K.</string-name>
              <string-name>Anand, A.</string-name>
              <string-name>Aier, I.</string-name>
              <string-name>Vijay, V.K.</string-name>
              <string-name>Kaushal, P.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2021</year>
            <article-title>Suitability of Rice Straw for Biochar Production through Slow Pyrolysis: Product Characterization and Thermodynamic Analysis</article-title>
            <source>Bioresource Technology Reports</source>
            <volume>15</volume>
            <elocation-id>100818</elocation-id>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1016/j.biteb.2021.100818</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B27">
        <label>27.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="other">Awad, M.I., Makkawi, Y. and Hassan, N.M. (2024) Yield and Energy Modeling for Biochar and Bio-Oil Using Pyrolysis Temperature and Biomass Constituents. <italic>ACS Omega</italic>, 9, 18654-18667. https://doi.org/10.1021/acsomega.4c01646 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1021/acsomega.4c01646</pub-id><pub-id pub-id-type="pmid">38680335</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1021/acsomega.4c01646">https://doi.org/10.1021/acsomega.4c01646</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="other">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Awad, M.I.</string-name>
              <string-name>Makkawi, Y.</string-name>
              <string-name>Hassan, N.M.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2024</year>
            <article-title>Yield and Energy Modeling for Biochar and Bio-Oil Using Pyrolysis Temperature and Biomass Constituents</article-title>
            <source>ACS Omega</source>
            <volume>9</volume>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1021/acsomega.4c01646</pub-id>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="pmid">38680335</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B28">
        <label>28.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="other">Chen, Z., Lei, C., Yao, L., Mo, Y., Li, J., Qu, H., <italic>et al</italic>. (2025) Synergistic Pyrolysis of Rice and Chili Straw under N <sub>2</sub>/CO <sub>2</sub> Atmosphere: Nutritional Elements (N/P/K) Migration and Transformation from Straw to Pyrolysis Products. <italic>Energy</italic>, 316, Article 134636. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.energy.2025.134636 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1016/j.energy.2025.134636</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1016/j.energy.2025.134636">https://doi.org/10.1016/j.energy.2025.134636</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="other">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Chen, Z.</string-name>
              <string-name>Lei, C.</string-name>
              <string-name>Yao, L.</string-name>
              <string-name>Mo, Y.</string-name>
              <string-name>Li, J.</string-name>
              <string-name>Qu, H.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2025</year>
            <article-title>Synergistic Pyrolysis of Rice and Chili Straw under N2/CO2 Atmosphere: Nutritional Elements (N/P/K) Migration and Transformation from Straw to Pyrolysis Products</article-title>
            <source>Energy</source>
            <volume>316</volume>
            <elocation-id>134636</elocation-id>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1016/j.energy.2025.134636</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B29">
        <label>29.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="other">Luo, L., Xu, C., Chen, Z. and Zhang, S. (2015) Properties of Biomass-Derived Biochars: Combined Effects of Operating Conditions and Biomass Types. <italic>Bioresource Technology</italic>, 192, 83-89. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biortech.2015.05.054 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1016/j.biortech.2015.05.054</pub-id><pub-id pub-id-type="pmid">26022969</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biortech.2015.05.054">https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biortech.2015.05.054</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="other">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Luo, L.</string-name>
              <string-name>Xu, C.</string-name>
              <string-name>Chen, Z.</string-name>
              <string-name>Zhang, S.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2015</year>
            <article-title>Properties of Biomass-Derived Biochars: Combined Effects of Operating Conditions and Biomass Types</article-title>
            <source>Bioresource Technology</source>
            <volume>192</volume>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1016/j.biortech.2015.05.054</pub-id>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="pmid">26022969</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B30">
        <label>30.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="other">Li, Y., Gupta, R., Zhang, Q. and You, S. (2023) Review of Biochar Production via Crop Residue Pyrolysis: Development and Perspectives. <italic>Bioresource Technology</italic>, 369, Article 128423. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biortech.2022.128423 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1016/j.biortech.2022.128423</pub-id><pub-id pub-id-type="pmid">36462767</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biortech.2022.128423">https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biortech.2022.128423</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="other">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Li, Y.</string-name>
              <string-name>Gupta, R.</string-name>
              <string-name>Zhang, Q.</string-name>
              <string-name>You, S.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2023</year>
            <article-title>Review of Biochar Production via Crop Residue Pyrolysis: Development and Perspectives</article-title>
            <source>Bioresource Technology</source>
            <volume>369</volume>
            <elocation-id>128423</elocation-id>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1016/j.biortech.2022.128423</pub-id>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="pmid">36462767</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B31">
        <label>31.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="other">Shen, X., Zhang, Y., Han, Z., Zhang, Z., Yu, L. and Zhang, C. (2025) Carbonization Technology and Application of Biomass Straw in Metallurgy: Recent Progress and Future Challenges. <italic>Process Safety and Environmental Protection</italic>, 201, Article 107608. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.psep.2025.107608 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1016/j.psep.2025.107608</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1016/j.psep.2025.107608">https://doi.org/10.1016/j.psep.2025.107608</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="other">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Shen, X.</string-name>
              <string-name>Zhang, Y.</string-name>
              <string-name>Han, Z.</string-name>
              <string-name>Zhang, Z.</string-name>
              <string-name>Yu, L.</string-name>
              <string-name>Zhang, C.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2025</year>
            <article-title>Carbonization Technology and Application of Biomass Straw in Metallurgy: Recent Progress and Future Challenges</article-title>
            <source>Process Safety and Environmental Protection</source>
            <volume>201</volume>
            <elocation-id>107608</elocation-id>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1016/j.psep.2025.107608</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B32">
        <label>32.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="other">Cheng, C., He, Q., Ismail, T.M., Mosqueda, A., Ding, L., Yu, J., <italic>et al</italic>. (2022) Hydrothermal Carbonization of Rape Straw: Effect of Reaction Parameters on Hydrochar and Migration of Aaems. <italic>Chemosphere</italic>, 291, Article 132785. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2021.132785 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1016/j.chemosphere.2021.132785</pub-id><pub-id pub-id-type="pmid">34742758</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2021.132785">https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2021.132785</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="other">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Cheng, C.</string-name>
              <string-name>He, Q.</string-name>
              <string-name>Ismail, T.M.</string-name>
              <string-name>Mosqueda, A.</string-name>
              <string-name>Ding, L.</string-name>
              <string-name>Yu, J.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2022</year>
            <article-title>Hydrothermal Carbonization of Rape Straw: Effect of Reaction Parameters on Hydrochar and Migration of Aaems</article-title>
            <source>Chemosphere</source>
            <volume>291</volume>
            <elocation-id>132785</elocation-id>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1016/j.chemosphere.2021.132785</pub-id>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="pmid">34742758</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B33">
        <label>33.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="journal">Liu, Y., Zhou, C., Siyal, A.A., Liu, C., Zhang, Y., Fu, J., <italic>et al</italic>. (2024) Comparative Microwave Catalytic Pyrolysis of Cellulose and Lignin in Nitrogen and Carbon Dioxide Atmospheres. <italic>Journal of Cleaner Production</italic>, 437, Article 140750. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2024.140750 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1016/j.jclepro.2024.140750</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2024.140750">https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2024.140750</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="journal">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Liu, Y.</string-name>
              <string-name>Zhou, C.</string-name>
              <string-name>Siyal, A.A.</string-name>
              <string-name>Liu, C.</string-name>
              <string-name>Zhang, Y.</string-name>
              <string-name>Fu, J.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2024</year>
            <article-title>Comparative Microwave Catalytic Pyrolysis of Cellulose and Lignin in Nitrogen and Carbon Dioxide Atmospheres</article-title>
            <source>Journal of Cleaner Production</source>
            <volume>437</volume>
            <elocation-id>140750</elocation-id>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1016/j.jclepro.2024.140750</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B34">
        <label>34.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="other">Zhao, W., Liu, S., Li, N., Zhang, J., Zhang, G. and Xu, S. (2024) Nitrogen-Rich Pyrolysis to Nitrogen-Containing Compounds in CO <sub>2</sub>/N <sub>2</sub> Atmosphere: Nitrogen Configuration and Transformation Path. <italic>Industrial Crops and Products</italic>, 211, Article 118212. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.indcrop.2024.118212 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1016/j.indcrop.2024.118212</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1016/j.indcrop.2024.118212">https://doi.org/10.1016/j.indcrop.2024.118212</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="other">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Zhao, W.</string-name>
              <string-name>Liu, S.</string-name>
              <string-name>Li, N.</string-name>
              <string-name>Zhang, J.</string-name>
              <string-name>Zhang, G.</string-name>
              <string-name>Xu, S.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2024</year>
            <article-title>Nitrogen-Rich Pyrolysis to Nitrogen-Containing Compounds in CO2/N2 Atmosphere: Nitrogen Configuration and Transformation Path</article-title>
            <source>Industrial Crops and Products</source>
            <volume>211</volume>
            <elocation-id>118212</elocation-id>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1016/j.indcrop.2024.118212</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B35">
        <label>35.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="other">Salam, A., Bashir, S., Khan, I. and Hu, H. (2020) Biochar Production and Characterization as a Measure for Effective Rapeseed Residue and Rice Straw Management: An Integrated Spectroscopic Examination. <italic>Biomass Conversion and Biorefinery</italic>, 12, 2687-2696. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13399-020-00820-z <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1007/s13399-020-00820-z</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1007/s13399-020-00820-z">https://doi.org/10.1007/s13399-020-00820-z</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="other">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Salam, A.</string-name>
              <string-name>Bashir, S.</string-name>
              <string-name>Khan, I.</string-name>
              <string-name>Hu, H.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2020</year>
            <article-title>Biochar Production and Characterization as a Measure for Effective Rapeseed Residue and Rice Straw Management: An Integrated Spectroscopic Examination</article-title>
            <source>Biomass Conversion and Biorefinery</source>
            <volume>12</volume>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1007/s13399-020-00820-z</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B36">
        <label>36.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="other">Shao, S., Ma, L., Li, X., Zhang, H. and Xiao, R. (2023) Preparation of Activated Carbon with Heavy Fraction of Bio-Oil from Rape Straw Pyrolysis as Carbon Source and Its Performance in the Aldol Condensation for Aviation Fuel as Carrier. <italic>Industrial Crops and Products</italic>, 192, Article 115912. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.indcrop.2022.115912 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1016/j.indcrop.2022.115912</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1016/j.indcrop.2022.115912">https://doi.org/10.1016/j.indcrop.2022.115912</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="other">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Shao, S.</string-name>
              <string-name>Ma, L.</string-name>
              <string-name>Li, X.</string-name>
              <string-name>Zhang, H.</string-name>
              <string-name>Xiao, R.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2023</year>
            <article-title>Preparation of Activated Carbon with Heavy Fraction of Bio-Oil from Rape Straw Pyrolysis as Carbon Source and Its Performance in the Aldol Condensation for Aviation Fuel as Carrier</article-title>
            <source>Industrial Crops and Products</source>
            <volume>192</volume>
            <elocation-id>115912</elocation-id>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1016/j.indcrop.2022.115912</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B37">
        <label>37.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="other">Bai, J., Qin, Y., Zhao, J. and Song, Y. (2025) Investigation of Agricultural Nutrient Removal by Ecological Ditches Using Meta-Analysis. <italic>Agriculture</italic>, <italic>Ecosystems &amp; Environment</italic>, 380, Article 109401. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.agee.2024.109401 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1016/j.agee.2024.109401</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1016/j.agee.2024.109401">https://doi.org/10.1016/j.agee.2024.109401</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="other">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Bai, J.</string-name>
              <string-name>Qin, Y.</string-name>
              <string-name>Zhao, J.</string-name>
              <string-name>Song, Y.</string-name>
              <string-name>Agriculture, E</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2025</year>
            <article-title>Investigation of Agricultural Nutrient Removal by Ecological Ditches Using Meta-Analysis</article-title>
            <source>Agriculture</source>
            <volume>380</volume>
            <elocation-id>109401</elocation-id>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1016/j.agee.2024.109401</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B38">
        <label>38.</label>
        <citation-alternatives>
          <mixed-citation publication-type="other">Ding, W., Li, J., Ma, H., Wu, Y. and He, H. (2023) Science Mapping of Meta-Analysis in Agricultural Science. <italic>Information</italic>, 14, Article 611. https://doi.org/10.3390/info14110611 <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.3390/info14110611</pub-id><ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.3390/info14110611">https://doi.org/10.3390/info14110611</ext-link></mixed-citation>
          <element-citation publication-type="other">
            <person-group person-group-type="author">
              <string-name>Ding, W.</string-name>
              <string-name>Li, J.</string-name>
              <string-name>Ma, H.</string-name>
              <string-name>Wu, Y.</string-name>
              <string-name>He, H.</string-name>
            </person-group>
            <year>2023</year>
            <article-title>Science Mapping of Meta-Analysis in Agricultural Science</article-title>
            <source>Information</source>
            <volume>14</volume>
            <elocation-id>611</elocation-id>
            <pub-id pub-id-type="doi">10.3390/info14110611</pub-id>
          </element-citation>
        </citation-alternatives>
      </ref>
    </ref-list>
  </back>
</article>