Wesson in [1], page 105 has the following result of how the momentum is affected by a 5 dimensional input (from the fifth dimension). In other words we have the following expression, namely

∫ p α d x α = ± h c ⋅ L l (1)

We will be defining what the momentum p α is in our treatment of the early universe whereas the first five dimensional input value L here comes from the inverse of the square root of the cosmological constant

L ≡ 3 Λ (2)

Whereas the term l is equal to the Compton wavelength of a “particle” m for which

l ≡ h m ⋅ c (3)

So if we use the reasoning done in [2] in the early universe, namely [2] we have that due to that documents page 2, formula (9)

〈 p 〉 = − β ˜ 2 m P ⋅ ν π G ⋅ ln t ϖ c (4)

And keeping in mind the Wesson 5 dimensional line element [1] given by

d S 5-dim 2 = L 2 l 2 ⋅ d s 4-dim 2 − L 4 l 4 ⋅ d l 2 (5)

We get an infinitesimal r value due to from the 5^th dimension fixing the value of to be very small in a deterministic fashion

∫ p α d x α = ± h c ⋅ L l = ± h c ⋅ 3 Λ m particle h = r m p l ⋅ ( 1 − log [ r ϖ ⋅ c ] ) ⇔ r ≈ ε + (6)

This is in tandem with the value of z, as to red shift showing up in [3] and it shows how to obtain a very small radial value in a different manner, namely in a tiny scale factor due to an enormous z red shift as given in [3].

Quote

Note this comes from a scale factor, if z ~ 10 55 ⇔ a scalefactor ~ 10 − 55 , i.e. 55 orders of magnitude smaller than what would normally consider, but here note that the scale factor is not zero, so we do not have a space-time singularity.

End of quote

However that scale factor being very small, with enormous red shift is in tandem with Equation (6). So go to the HUP.

Note this comes from a scale factor, if z ~ 10 55 ⇔ a scalefactor ~ 10 − 55 , i.e. 55 orders of magnitude smaller than what would normally consider [3],

〈 ( δ g u v ) 2 ( T ^ u v ) 2 〉 ≥ ℏ 2 V Volume 2 → u v → t t 〈 ( δ g t t ) 2 ( T ^ t t ) 2 〉 ≥ ℏ 2 V Volume 2 &     δ g r r ~ δ g θ θ ~ δ g ϕ ϕ ~ 0 + (7)

δ t Δ E ≥ ℏ δ g t t ≠ ℏ 2 Unless     δ g t t ~ O ( 1 ) (8)

δ g t t ~ a 2 ( t ) ⋅ ϕ ≪ 1 (9)

Then, there is no way that Equation (9) is going to come close to δ t Δ E ≥ ℏ 2 .

To begin this process, we will break it down into the following co ordinates [3].

In the rr, θ θ and ϕ ϕ coordinates, we will use the Fluid approximation, T i i = d i a g ( ρ , − p , − p , − p ) [3] with

δ g r r T r r ≥ − | ℏ ⋅ a 2 ( t ) ⋅ r 2 V ( 4 ) | → a → 0 0 δ g θ θ T θ θ ≥ − | ℏ ⋅ a 2 ( t ) V ( 4 ) ( 1 − k ⋅ r 2 ) | → a → 0 0 δ g ϕ ϕ T ϕ ϕ ≥ − | ℏ ⋅ a 2 ( t ) ⋅ sin 2 θ ⋅ d ϕ 2 V ( 4 ) | → a → 0 0 (10)

We win put in different values of the scalar potential and make comments as to what this pertains to in terms of early universe physics.

The first one will be using a scalar field from inflaton physics, as presented by Padmanabhan [4]. For the record, Dr. Tony Scott has communicated his disapproval of involving the Padmanabhan potential to the author in communications, but this will be presented as one of the possible choices.

First we have from [2]

V ( ϕ ) = V 0 exp ( − λ ϕ m P ) ↔ V 0 exp ( − 16 π G ν ⋅ ϕ ) (11)

And also [2] [5]

a ( t ) = a initial t ν ⇒ ϕ = ln ( 8 π G V 0 ν ⋅ ( 3 ν − 1 ) ⋅ t ) ν 16 π G ⇒ ϕ ˙ = ν 4 π G ⋅ t − 1 ⇒ H 2 ϕ ˙ ≈ 4 π G ν ⋅ t ⋅ T 4 ⋅ 1.66 2 ⋅ g ∗ m P 2 ≈ 10 − 5 (12)

Where we can put in the values of Equation (12) into Equation (9). We can write an expression for V 0 from [6], page 153 taking the form of if the denominator is the e fold value of inflation,

V 0 1 / 4 = 0.022 m P q N e-folds (13)

And using the Starobinsky model, plus [2] [7] [8] to get a value of L.

And so we obtain if we have a scale factor behaving as in (12)

Λ ≈ − [ V 0 3 γ − 1 + 2 N + γ ⋅ ( 3 γ − 1 ) 8 π G ⋅ t ˜ 2 ] 1 κ ∫ − g ⋅ d 3 x + ( 6 ⋅ ( a ¨ a + ( a ˙ a ) 2 ) ) | t = t ˜ ≈ − [ V 0 3 γ − 1 + 2 V 0 ⋅ ( 1 − exp [ − q ⋅ ϕ / m P ] ) 2 + γ ⋅ ( 3 γ − 1 ) 8 π G ⋅ t ˜ 2 ] 1 κ ∫ − g ⋅ d 3 x     + 6 ⋅ − t ⋅ γ ⋅ ( 3 γ − 1 ) m P G ⋅ 1 8 π + 48 π G 3 ⋅ [ V 0 ⋅ ( 1 − exp [ − q ⋅ ϕ / m P ] ) 2 ] (14)

This can be put into the value of Equation (9), If we presume Planck time, then if the value of Equation (9) is very small which is frequently a result, we will have a very large value for change in Energy, which would in its own way confirm the enormous value of M initially confirmed as forming which is in [8] via the relationship of change in energy E will be proportional to the very large value of M so initially formed.

Comparing with the other assumed early uncertainty principles what is in Equation (9) plus the inputs into Equation (14) put into Equation (9) which influences Equation (8) should be compared with following Uncertainty principle [9] [10] [6] [11]

Δ t ≥ ℏ Δ E + γ t P 2 Δ E ℏ ⇒ ( Δ E ) 2 − ℏ Δ t γ t P 2 ( Δ E ) 1 + ℏ 2 γ t P 2 = 0 ⇒ Δ E = ℏ Δ t 2 γ t P 2 ⋅ ( 1 + 1 − 4 ℏ 2 γ t P 2 ⋅ ( ℏ Δ t 2 γ t P 2 ) 2 ) = ℏ Δ t 2 γ t P 2 ⋅ ( 1 ± 1 − 16 ℏ 2 γ t P 2 ( ℏ Δ t ) 2 ) (15)

Δ E ≈ ℏ Δ t 2 γ t P 2 ⋅ ( 1 ± ( 1 − 8 ℏ 2 γ t P 2 ( ℏ Δ t ) 2 ) ) ⇒ Δ E ≈ either   ℏ Δ t 2 γ t P 2 ⋅ 8 ℏ 2 γ t P 2 ( ℏ Δ t ) 2 ,   or   ℏ Δ t 2 γ t P 2 ⋅ ( 2 − 8 ℏ 2 γ t P 2 ( ℏ Δ t ) 2 ) (16)

A point by point comparison of these values should be the next objective of a research project. Furthermore the items brought up in references [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] will be able to be vetted provided that we make the comparison between Equation (8) and Equation (9) with Equation (15) and Equation (16) in a rigorous manner.

In particular, I would look forward to eventual experimental verification, if the early universe HUP were really understood of investigating the great ideas brought up by Corda in [12].

Determination of that would be exciting experimental gravitational physics.

This work is supported in part by National Nature Science Foundation of China grant No. 11375279.

The author declares no conflicts of interest regarding the publication of this paper.

Beckwith, A.W. (2023) How 5 Dimensions May Fix a Deterministic Background Spatially as to Be Inserted for HUP in 3 + 1 Dimensions, and Its Relevance to the Early Universe. Journal of High Energy Physics, Gravitation and Cosmology, 9, 1-6. https://doi.org/10.4236/jhepgc.2023.91001