African emperor moth (
Gonimbrasia zambesina) caterpillars are considered healthy food as they are rich in protein and unsaturated fats. In Kenya,
G. zambesina
caterpillars are predominantly found along the coastal region
,
where they emerge in during the short and the long rains. The caterpillars forage in the wild on mango (Mangifera indica) leaves and Euclea natalensis (Ericales: Ebenaceae) leaves. The caterpillars are consumed whole or may be transformed into fine flour. The caterpillars’ flour can be utilized in the bakery industry for the enrichment of bakery products since wheat (the major component of bakery products) is low in protein. However, consumers are concerned about the microbiological quality of bakery products enriched with insect flour. There are also concerns about the effect of these insects’ flour on the shelf life of bakery products since they have unsaturated fats. Therefore, this study evaluated the microbial quality and shelf life of wheat muffins enriched with G. zambesina caterpillar flour at 0%, 5%, 10%, 15%, and 20%. For all the samples analyzed, total viable count (TVC) was <30 cfu/g, total coliform count (TCC) was <30 cfu/g, Salmonella spp, and Staphylococcus aureus were not detected. The colonies for yeast and moulds were <30 cfu/g throughout the evaluation time of 21 days. The PVs of wheat muffins increased with
an
increase in the substitution level. The PVs of enriched wheat muffins increased with
an
increase in storage time and temperature. The
shelf-life
of the wheat muffins decreased with an increase in the substitution level of wheat flour with G. zambesina caterpillar flour. The predicted shelf life of 0%, 5%, 10%, 15%, and 20% wheat muffins was 120.0 days, 111.0 days, 103.0 days, 102.0 days and 90.0 days, respectively. Therefore, wheat muffins enriched with G. zambesina caterpillar flour have good microbiological quality and shelf life.
The protein malnutrition situation in sub-Saharan Africa and changing food systems are forcing the food sector players to explore various alternative sources of proteins [1] [2]. Food industries have shifted their attention to the use of edible insects as a high-quality protein product and a nutrient source for other foods through fortification [3]. Fortification with insect flour aims to improve the food product’s nutritional value, correct any deficiencies in minerals or vitamins, and enhance its health-protecting substances [4] [5]. Food fortification with insects has been mostly orchestrated by the new technologies that are currently in use by the food industries, the need for transformation that would ensure proper food management, and the cost of production of insects as raw materials due to their high feed conversion efficiency and the rate of reproduction is high in comparison to other animal sources [5] [6]. Some of the insects that have been used for fortification/enrichment include Rhynchophorus phoenicis larvae, Macrotermes subhylanus, Acheta domesticus, Tenebrio molitor larvae and Nauphoeta cinerea [5] [7] [8] [9] [10]. Lepidoptera such as G. zambesina caterpillars can also be used for fortification since they are abundant, easy to rear and are high in protein content with more than 50% of their body weight being protein [11]. In coastal Kenya, there is an initiative by the Kipepeo butterfly centre, Gede, Kilifi to train farmers on the domestication of G. zambesina caterpillars to improve production for export and local consumption.
For successful fortification, the chosen food should be that whose consumption is wide and adequate and have a gap deficit in its nutritional elements that need to be bridged [5]. Wheat flour, a major component of bakery products is low in protein with the soft wheat used to make muffins having only 8% - 10% protein content [12]. Therefore, its protein quality can be improved by enriching with an alternative protein source such as insects flour/powder [12]. To literature, bakery products such as bread, cookies, biscuits, and wheat buns enriched with some insect powder have been developed to improve their nutritional value [5] [7] [8] [10] [13] [14]. However, the progress already made towards meeting protein security is under threat as there are fears that gains may have been reversed by the adverse effects of the COVID-19 pandemic on raw material production and transportation, production cost and consumer accessibility of end products [1]. Therefore, for the food industry to cope with the current consumer demand for insect-based food products, there should be a much more emphasis on combined approaches for conventional food fortification and food to food fortification by optimal utilization of all the edible insects that are underutilized such as G. zambesina caterpillar larva.
Fortification of bakery products not only increases their nutritional value but also has got an effect on their microbiological properties and oxidative stability. The consumers and producers are both concerned about the microbiological effects of the addition of insect flour, insect parts, or insect protein into bakery products [15] [16]. This is because previous studies on the microbiological safety of most edible insects, especially those harvested from the wild, have shown that they harbour microbes of health concerns [17] - [22]. Some insects, such as some edible caterpillars have also been reported to harbour both the pathogenic and spoilage microorganism in their gut [23] [24]. Furthermore, wheat muffins are classified as bakery products with a high water activity (aw) > 0.85, which often are characterized by spoilage bacteria and yeast and moulds. In some instances, they have also been intimated to the outbreak of foodborne illnesses caused by Salmonella and Bacillus cereus [25]. The presence of bacteria in bakery products may be due to post-process contamination and poor packaging and storage conditions [25]. This is because the high baking temperatures readily destroy vegetative pathogenic microorganisms due to their low thermal resistance (D values), such that they destroy most of the microorganisms in the raw materials [7] [25] [26].
Bakery products may deteriorate in quality either due to the germination of yeasts and mould spores which can survive the baking temperatures since they have high thermal resistance (D values), food chemical reactions, and enzymatic activities [14] [25]. Yeast and moulds are associated with high sugar foods [27]. When the yeast and moulds grow to levels that are above the acceptable limits for bakery products, the quality of these products is compromised [26]. The shelf life of bakery products is also limited by the growth of moulds [27]. Shelf life is defined as the period in which a food product is satisfactorily safe for consumption and appeals to the senses of consumers [14]. The fortification of bakery products with insect powder which is rich in unsaturated lipids makes them susceptible to lipid oxidation which may lead to the formation of rancidity compounds [28]. This, like the yeast and moulds, not only results in the loss of the nutritional value of the bakery products but also affects their shelf life [29] [14].
Due to the increasing use of insects in enriching bakery products, there is a need to take precautions by determining the microbiological properties of these products such that there is a surety about their safety. To ascertain that no form of microbiological contamination took place during production, bakery industries have got a responsibility to carry out microbiological tests on the insect-based bakery products [14]. Furthermore, there is also a need to determine their oxidative stability due to the addition of unsaturated lipids present in insect ingredients [30]. The oxidative stability can be determined by monitoring the chemical changes such as oxidative rancidity, caused by the oxidation of fats [30] [31]. The oxidation of oils results in the formation of primary products, peroxides, which are measured as peroxide values [31]. The peroxide value can be used to estimate the shelf life either through conventional storage or accelerated shelf life [14]. In performing the conventional storage test, food is stored under conditions that are expected during normal storage for a long time while the accelerated shelf life test is done by storing food products under higher temperatures or oxygen concentrations for some time as tests are frequently performed on selected indicators [30]. Therefore, this study aimed to investigate the microbial safety of wheat muffins enriched with G. zambesina caterpillar flour. It also aimed to estimate the shelf life of the wheat muffins based on peroxide accumulation.
2. Materials and Methods2.1. Study Design and Study Area
The experiments were arranged in a completely randomized design with 5 treatments of wheat muffins enriched with G. zambesina caterpillar flour at 0%, 5%, 10%, 15%, and 20% substitution levels. Gonimbrasia zambesina caterpillars were domesticated and processed between August and December 2020 at Kipepeo butterfly centre, Gede, Kilifi, Kenya. Batter preparation and baking were done in the food processing laboratory of Jaramogi Oginga Odinga University of Science and Technology (JOOUST). Microbiological analysis was done in the microbiology laboratory of JOOUST whereas peroxide value determination was done at the chemistry laboratory of Masinde Muliro University of Science and Technology (MMUST). All analyses were done in triplicate. This study was authorized by Ethical Review Committee (ERC) of JOOUST and a research permit by the National Commission for Science, Technology and Innovation (NACOSTI) was obtained.
2.2. Raw Material Acquisition and Processing
Domestication of G. zambesina caterpillars
Gonimbrasia zambesina caterpillars were reared in two rectangular cages made of steel, wire mesh and net. The cages were 1.2 m long, 1.0 m wide and 0.5 high. Each cage was on four stands, every 0.6 m high. The stands were dipped in ice cream boxes filled with water to prevent predators from accessing the cages. Eggs of G. zambesina moth deposited on mango tree (Mangifera indica) leaves were taken by plucking off gently the leaf. These were transported to the cages where fresh mango leaves were added to protect the eggs from direct sunlight and heavy rains and also act as starter feed for the newly hatched larvae. The doors of the cages were sealed to prevent the hatched larvae from escaping. The eggs of theG. zambesina moth were monitored for hatching at 8:00 am, 12:30 pm, and 4:30 pm daily. The eggs took about 2 - 5 days to hatch. However, hatching was not uniform since, during their collection, the exact time and day of deposition on the leaves were not known. The hatched caterpillars were continuously fed on fresh M. indica leaves. The stalks of consumed mango leaves were removed every morning and evening during routine checking and replaced with fresh ones. Moulting of G. zambesina larvae from the 1st instar to the 6th instar was at an interval of 4 - 6 days for 3 - 4 weeks depending on the feed consumption rate of each larva and the date on which it was hatched.
Harvesting of G. zambesina caterpillars
Mature G. zambesina caterpillars (those that have reached the 6th instar stage of larval development) were hand-picked from the cages (Figure 1). Gonimbrasia zambesina caterpillars are regarded as mature if, after continuous feeding for 3 - 4 weeks, they stop feeding and burrow in their manure inside the cage. The harvested caterpillar was weighed and 10% of the harvested populations were released to the environment into ensure continuity in biodiversity.
Processing of G. zambesina caterpillar
About 5 kg of the harvested G. zambesina caterpillars were killed by freezing at −25˚C for 30 min and degutted using a scalpel. The caterpillars were washed in running tap water and drip-dried for 20 min on drying nets. They were then transferred into a locally made wooden electric dryer and dried at 55˚C for 3 days to a constant weight. To consider the sample dry, three samplings were done at an interval of one hour which resulted in less than 1% change in weight. The dry caterpillars were milled using a coffee bean grinder (DeLonghi KG-79, Wuhan, China). The G. zambesina caterpillar flour was sieved through a 250 µm sieve to obtain fine flour, packaged and transported to the food processing laboratory of JOOUST in sterilized polyethylene zip-lock bags (Vinayak Udyog, New Delhi, India).
2.3. Wheat Muffins Formulation and Baking
Formulation of wheat muffins enriched with G. zambesina caterpillar flour
The recipe and the ingredients for the wheat muffins preparation were according to Purnoma et al. [12] with slight modifications. Wheat flour was substituted
with G. zambesina caterpillar flour at 5 levels; 100:0 (the control), 95:5, 90:10, 85:15 and 80:20 w/w. Approximately 150 g of the wheat flour composited with G. zambesina caterpillar flour was weighed into a mixing bowl and mixed using a clean wooden spoon. Melted margarine (98.57 g), water (47.14 g), and whisked eggs (85.71 g) were added into the bowl according to the recipe at an interval of 30 sec, respectively while mixing using a hand mixer (Model: RM/382, Guangdong, China) at high speed (as indicated on the equipment) for 3 min. Baking powder (2.14 g) and refined sugar (91.43 g) were added to the mixing bowls and mixing was done at low speed (as indicated on the hand mixer) for 2 min to form the batter. The muffin batter was poured into the wells of 3 standard 6-well muffin pans. Baking was done in triplicate at 180˚C for 20 min in a preheated forced air circulation oven (Electrolux AR 85, Italy). The baked wheat muffins were then removed from the oven (Electrolux AR 85, Italy) and cooled for 20 min at room temperature. Packaging was done in sterilized polyethylene zip-lock bags (Vinayak Udyog, New Delhi, India), awaiting microbial analysis and peroxide value determination.
2.4. Microbiological Analyses
The microbiological assessment of wheat muffins enriched with G. zambesina caterpillar flour stored at 4˚C was done 48 hr after baking. For total viable count (TVC), total coliform count (TCC), S. aureus determination, and enumeration of yeast and moulds, 5 g of the grounded sample were diluted into 45 mL of sterilized peptone water to make a stock dilution. The dilution was homogenized by vortexing at 3000 rpm for 5 min and serially diluted three fold. Aliquots (1 mL) from each serial dilution were inoculated in triplicate plates.
TVC
The total viable count was determined according to AOAC [32] Method 966.23 in plates with Plate Count Agar (PCA) (CM0152). The plates were incubated at 35˚C for 48 hr. The results were expressed as cfu/g of the sample.
TCC
The total coliform count was determined according to AOAC [32] Method 966.24 in plates with MacConkey Agar (MA) (Himedia Ref M043). The plates were inverted and incubated at 35˚C for 48 hr. The results were expressed as cfu/g of the sample.
Staphylococcus aureus
Staphylococcus aureus counts were determined according to Nyangena et al. [17] in petri dishes with Baird-Parker medium (Himedia Ref M043) enriched with egg-yolk tellurite emulsion (Himedia, India). The plates were incubated at 35˚C for 48 hr. Colonies of typical S. aureus appearance (grey-black to jet black, circular, smooth, convex, and moist and 2 - 3 mm in diameter) were monitored for growth.
Detection ofSalmonella
Detection of Salmonella spp was according to Nyangena et al. [17]. Briefly, 25 g of ground sample was diluted into 225 mL of nutrient broth (Himedia Ref M002) in a closable container, gently shaken, and incubated at 35˚C for 24 hr. Then, 25 mL of the enriched homogenate was transferred to 225 mL of tetrathionate broth (Himedia, India) and incubated at 37˚C for 24 hr. A 3mm loopful of incubated culture was streaked in triplicate plates on Salmonella-Shigella Agar (Himedia, India). Plates were incubated at 37˚C for 24 hr and observed for the typical salmonella colonies (colourless colonies with black centers).
Enumeration of yeast and moulds
Total yeast and moulds counts were enumerated according to Nyangena et al. [17] on days 1, 7, 14, and 21 of baking in plates with Potato Dextrose Agar (PDA) (Himedia Ref M096) acidified with 10% tartaric Acid (Sigma-Aldrich, Schnelldorf, Germany) to pH 3.5 using a sterile micropipette. The aliquot was spread over the media using a sterile spreader until it was absorbed into the media. The plates were incubated at 25˚C for 72 hr. Plates with between 30 - 300 colonies were selected and the colonies were counted. The results were expressed as cfu/g of the sample.
2.5. Peroxide Value (PV) and Shelf Life Estimation
Peroxide value was determined according to AOAC [32] Method 965.33 for triplicate samples stored at 25˚C, 37˚C, and 45˚C over 21 days. Briefly, 0.3 g of oil extracted from the enriched wheat muffins through the Soxhlet extraction method according to AOAC [32] Method 920.39 was weighed into a 250 mL stoppered Erlenmeyer flask, and 30 mL of acetic acid chloroform solvent mixture was added and swirled to dissolve. Saturated potassium iodide solution (0.5 mL) was added using a mohr pipet, left to stand in the dark for 1 min with occasional shaking and then 30 mL of distilled water was added. The solution was titrated against 0.01M sodium thiosulfate with vigorous shaking until the yellow colour almost disappeared. Then, 0.5 mL 1% starch solution was added and titration continued with vigorously shaking until the blue colour disappeared. The peroxide value was calculated as follows:
P V 1 [ meq O 2 / kg ] = T × M × 100 W (1)
where: P V 1 is peroxide value expressed in meq O2/kg, M is the molarity of sodium thiosulfate solution consumed in mol/L, T is the titer of the sodium thiosulfate solution, W is weighed portion of substance in grams.
Data processing
A regression plot of a semi-logarithmic scale was established for the rate constant for each sample at the three temperatures (Lnk) against the absolute inverse of temperature ( 1 T ) to obtain an Arrhenius equation based on:
ln k = ln k o − E a R ( 1 T ) (2)
1 T = 1 T * − 1 T r e f (3)
where: k is the reaction rate constant; R is the molar gas constant (8.314 J/K/mol), T is the absolute temperature (K); E a is the apparent activation energy (J/mol), and k o is the pre-exponential factor; T r e f is corresponding to the average of the temperature range used during the experiment where in this case was taken to be 37˚C (310.15 K) and T * is the temperature to which prediction of shelf life is done, in this case, it was 22˚C (295.15 K).
First-order regression models for wheat muffin enriched with G. zambesina caterpillar flour at each substitution level at 25˚C, 37˚C, and 45˚C temperatures as presented in Table 1.
The Arrhenius parameters were obtained to estimate the shelf life according to a formula described by the method of [33]:
Shelf-life = [ A lim ] − [ A o ] K r e f exp [ − E a R ( 1 T * − 1 T r e f ) ] (4)
where: A o is the initial peroxide value at time zero; K r e f is the rate constant at the reference temperature; E a is the apparent activation energy (J/mol); T * is the temperature to which prediction of shelf life is done, in this case, it was 22˚C (295.15 K); A lim is the standard acceptable limit for peroxide value in processed foods which is 10.0 meq O2/kg oil according to East African Standard (EAS 795:2013); T r e f is corresponding to the average of the temperature range used during the experiment where in this case was taken to be 37˚C (310.15 K).
First order regression models for the wheat muffins enriched withG. zambesina caterpillar flour at 25˚C, 37˚C, and 45˚C storage temperatures
Substitution level
Temperature
Regression equation
R2
0%
25˚C
Y = 0.0347x + 0.0749
0.9295
37˚C
Y = 0.0388x + 0.0731
0.9465
45˚C
Y = 0.0426x + 0.1219
0.8984
5%
25˚C
Y = 0.0311x + 0.1089
0.8476
37˚C
Y = 0.032x + 0.1365
0.7929
45˚C
Y = 0.0431x + 0.1824
0.8025
10%
25˚C
Y = 0.0332x + 0.0913
0.9018
37˚C
Y = 0.0378x + 0.0774
0.9453
45˚C
Y = 0.0471x + 0.087
0.9552
15%
25˚C
Y = 0.0269x + 0.064
0.9277
37˚C
Y = 0.0327x + 0.0872
0.9021
45˚C
Y = 0.0389x + 0.1363
0.8497
20%
25˚C
Y = 0.0266x + 0.0659
0.9094
37˚C
Y = 0.0337x + 0.0477
0.9685
45˚C
Y = 0.0441x + 0.094
0.9416
Key: y is the peroxide value and x is the temperature.
2.6. Statistical Analysis
Data were analyzed using SAS® software version 8.3. Normality of microbiological and shelf life data was tested using PROC UNIVARIATE and homogeneity was tested using Levene’s method. Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) was carried out using PROC GLM to test the hypotheses of the study at a 95% confidence level. Tukey’s Honestly Significant Difference (HSD) method was used in the separation of the means at p ≤ 0.05.
3. Results and Discussion
The TVC and TCC of wheat muffins enriched with G. zambesina caterpillar flour were <30 cfu/g for all samples (Table 2). Staphylococcus aureus and Salmonella were not detected in all the samples analysed. Yeast and moulds counts were low (<30 cfu/g) in wheat muffins enriched with G. zambesina caterpillar flour for days 1, 7, 14, and 21 of evaluation. Edible caterpillars have been found to harbour pathogenic and spoilage microorganisms [24]. Therefore, they are of public health concern more so in the utilization of their flour in the bakery industry [17] [23]. However, the utilization of G. zambesina caterpillars’ flour for the enrichment of wheat muffins during processing was observed to produce microbiologically safe wheat muffins for human consumption. This might be attributed to the domestication of the caterpillars which may have modulated the source to new microorganisms and the intrinsic ones in G. zambesina caterpillars [15]. The results of this study corroborate with those by Ayensu et al. [7] in their research on the nutritional composition and acceptability of biscuits fortified with R. phoenicis larvae and orange-fleshed sweet potato in pregnant women.
The total viable counts were below the maximum permissible limits for edible foods (<105 CFU/g) [26]. This might be ascribed to good handling practices of the muffins post baking and proper packaging in sterile polyethylene zip-lock bags (Vinayak Udyog, New Delhi, India) [25]. The absence of coliforms, S. aureus, and Salmonella in wheat muffins enriched with G. zambesina caterpillar flour might be attributed to the dehulling of wheat during wheat flour (major component of the muffins) processing that concentrates 90% of microorganisms
Microbiological quality of G. zambesina caterpillar flour enriched wheat muffins
Level of Substitution
TVC (cfu/g)
TCC (cfu/g)
Staphylococcus aureus
Salmonella spp.
YM cfu/g
0%
<30
<30
Not detected
Not detected
<30
5%
<30
<30
Not detected
Not detected
<30
10%
<30
<30
Not detected
Not detected
<30
15%
<30
<30
Not detected
Not detected
<30
20%
<30
<30
Not detected
Not detected
<30
Key: TVC = Total viable count; TCC = Total coliform count; YM = Yeasts and moulds.
on the bran which is then separated from the germ and pollard [34] [35] Coliforms are indicator organisms [36]. Their absence in wheat muffins enriched with G. zambesina caterpillar flour is an indication that good handling and manufacturing practices were adhered to during the processing [36]. The absence of coliforms might further be attributed to proper packaging which was done in sterilized polyethylene zip lock bags (Vinayak Udyog, New Delhi, India). Most coliform contaminations in bakery products occur due to poor post-process handling [26]. The absence of S. aureus and Salmonella in all the analysed samples might be attributed to good handling and manufacturing practices. Salmonella spp is commonly found in the egg content, which was used as an ingredient in the enriched wheat muffins [26]. The absence might be ascribed to the fact that Salmonella is a member of enterobacteriaceae family, hence very sensitive to heat. The high baking temperature for the enriched wheat muffins might have killed the Salmonella cells [26] [37]. It can further be attributed to degutting and rinsing of the G. zambesina caterpillars which might have reduced the gut microorganism [38]. For food to meet the microbiological guidelines on safety, there should be no detection of Salmonella in 25 g of the sample tested [17].
At 21 days of storage, the yeast and moulds counts were lower than 30 cfu/g in all the wheat muffins samples. This was way below the maximum acceptable limit for yeast and moulds in foods (1000 cfu/g) [39]. Yeast and moulds are associated with high sugar foods such as wheat muffins which are often responsible for their spoilage thereby limiting their shelf life [27] [39]. Therefore, based on the findings of this study, wheat muffins enriched with G. zambesina caterpillar flour are safe microbiologically safe for human consumption over a storage period of 21 days.
As shown in Figure 2, the initial PVs for wheat muffins enriched with G. zambesina caterpillar flour at 0%, 5%, 10%, 15% and 20% substitution levels were 4.50 meq O2/kg, 5.00 meq O2/kg, 4.67 meq O2/kg, 5.50 meq O2/kg, 5.34 meq O2/kg, respectively. The PV increased with an increase in storage temperature and time for all the wheat muffin oil samples. The control wheat muffins recorded lower PV compared to those enriched withG. zambesina caterpillar flour at 0%, 5%, 10%, 15%, and 20% substitution levels.
The initial PVs of all the oils of wheat muffins enriched with G. zambesina caterpillar flour was higher than that of fresh amaranth seed oil (0.487 meq O2/kg oil) and that of fresh coconut oil (0.24 to 0.49 meq O2/kg oil) [14]. This discrepancy in the initial PVs of these oils might be attributed to the primary oxidation of lipids that might have started immediately after the wheat muffins’ processing [14]. During cooling, the enriched wheat muffins were exposed to atmospheric oxygen. Exposure of lipids to oxygen (depending on concentrations) enhances oxidation [14] [40]. Furthermore, the addition of sodium bicarbonate (metal ion) to the wheat muffins as a chemical leavener might have also played a role in their initial PVs. Such metal ions act as a catalyst in an oxidative reaction [40]. The PVs can also be further ascribed to the high baking temperatures (180˚C).
There exist a linear relationship between temperature and the rate of oxidation [40].
Based on the initial PVs, wheat muffins enriched with G. zambesina caterpillar flour can be classified to be at a low oxidative state or the moderate oxidative state. This however changed with storage time as the PVs increased. Conventionally, food products are classified into three oxidative states based on their PVs [41]. A food product is classified as a low oxidative state when it has a PV of between 1 and 5 meq O2/kg oil, a moderate oxidative state when the PV is between 5 and 10 meq O2/kg oil, and a high oxidative state if the PV is above 10 meq O2/kg oil [14] [41]. The oxidative level of oils is reflected in the number of hydro peroxides in it which ultimately informs the tendency of an oil to become rancid [41]. A food product with a PV of between 20 to 40 meq O2/kg oil exhibits noticeable acidity and rancid taste [14].
The increase in the PVs of G. zambesina caterpillar flour enriched wheat muffins with an increase in storage temperatures might be ascribed to the linear relationship between temperature and the rate of fat oxidation [40]. Exposure of lipids to higher temperatures enhances the rate of lipid oxidation, while at lower temperatures, the rate of lipid oxidation is slow [29]. The higher PVs for the enriched wheat muffins reported on test day 21 might be attributed to the fact that as lipid oxidation takes place over a period of time, there is a buildup of the hydro peroxides in the food product which leads to deterioration in quality [40]. The higher PVs for the wheat muffins enriched with G. zambesina caterpillar flour at higher substitution levels were expected since edible caterpillars flour is rich in unsaturated fatty acids [42]. Unsaturated fatty acids are broken down by oxygen through an autolytic free radical mechanism [25] [41]. Higher substitution levels of wheat flour with G. zambesina caterpillar flour translated to higher quantities of unsaturated fatty acids added to the enriched wheat muffins. At 25˚C storage temperature, the highest PV was 9.83 meq O2/kg oil. According to the East African Standard, the PV limit for refined oil is 10 meq O2/kg oil (EAS 795:2013) [14]. However, the PV limit for refined oil according to Codex Alimentarius is 15 meq O2/kg oil [41].
There was a significant difference (p < 0.05) in the predicted shelf life of wheat muffins enriched with G. zambesina caterpillar flour (Table 3). The control wheat muffins had a shelf life of 120.0 days. Wheat muffins with 20% G. zambesina caterpillar flour had shorter shelf life (90 days). Generally, the shelf life of wheat muffins enriched with G. zambesina caterpillar flour is reduced with an increase in substitution levels. To predict the shelf life of wheat muffins enriched with G. zambesina caterpillar flour, the quality reference estimation for a maximum PV was taken to be 10 meq O2/kg. The longer shelf life reported for the reference wheat muffins might be attributed to the low quantities of unsaturated fatty acid in G. zambesina caterpillar flour used in substituting wheat flour [42]. The short shelf life of 20% wheat muffins is ascribed to high amounts of unsaturated fatty acids oxidized at a 20% substitution level. Based on the findings of this study that there was no significant difference (p < 0.05) in shelf life among 0%, 5%, and 10% G. zambesina enriched wheat muffins, the bakery industry can embrace the utilization of the G. zambesina caterpillar flour to enrich bakery products.
Predicted shelf life of wheat muffins enriched with G. zambesina caterpillar flour
Substitution level
Arrhenius equation
R2
Shelf-life (days)
0%
Y = −962.37x − 3.2398
0.9934
120.0a
5%
Y = −1424.0x − 3.3292
0.7023
111.0a
10%
Y = −1597.3x − 3.2195
0.9234
103.0a
15%
Y = −1726.7x − 3.3996
0.9903
102.0ab
20%
Y = −2344.2x − 3.3414
0.9715
90.0b
Note: Values with the same letter along the column are not significantly different at p < 0.05.
4. Conclusion and Recommendation
Wheat muffins enriched with G. zambesina caterpillar flour are microbiologically safe for human consumption. Adhering to good handling and manufacturing effectively controls the growth of yeast and moulds which are the major cause of spoilage in bakery products with a high and intermediate water activity (aw). The PV of wheat muffins enriched with G. zambesina caterpillar flour at room temperature (25˚C) is below the East African Standard for PV limit (10 meq O2/kg oil). Wheat muffins enriched with G. zambesina caterpillar flour generally have a shelf life between 120.0 days to 90.0 days due to their good microbiological quality and PVs. This study recommends that further tests, e.g. moisture content, free fatty acidity, and para-Anisidine value (p-AV) should be conducted to the determination of the shelf life of wheat muffins enriched with G. zambesina caterpillar flour.
Acknowledgements
This study was funded by Jaramogi Oginga Odinga University of Science and Technology through the Africa Centre of Excellence for sustainable use of insects as food and feed (INSEFOODS).
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
Cite this paper
Opondo, F., Nakhumicha, A. and Anyango, J. (2022) Microbiological Assessment and Shelf-Life Determination of Wheat Muffins Enriched with Domesticated African Emperor Moth (Gonimbrasia zambesina Walker) Caterpillar Flour. Food and Nutrition Sciences, 13, 734-749. https://doi.org/10.4236/fns.2022.138053
ReferencesUNICEF (2020) In Brief to the State of Food Security and Nutrition in the World.Gillespie, S. and van den Bold, M. (2017) Agriculture, Food Systems, and Nutrition: Meeting the Challenge. Global Challenges, 1, Article ID: 1600002. https://doi.org/10.1002/gch2.201600002de Carvalho, N.M., Madureira, A.R. and Pintado, M.E. (2020) The Potential of Insects as Food Sources—A Review. Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition, 60, 3642-3652. https://doi.org/10.1080/10408398.2019.1703170Agrahar-Murugkar, D. (2020) Food to Food Fortification of Breads and Biscuits with Herbs, Spices, Millets and Oilseeds on Bio-Accessibility of Calcium, Iron and Zinc and Impact of Proteins, Fat and Phenolics. LWT, 130, Article ID: 109703. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.lwt.2020.109703Zielińska, E., Pankiewicz, U. and Sujka, M. (2021) Nutritional, Physiochemical, and Biological Value of Muffins Enriched with Edible Insects Flour. Antioxidants, 10, 1122. https://doi.org/10.3390/antiox10071122Cappelli, A., Oliva, N., Bonaccorsi, G., Lorini, C. and Cini, E. (2020) Assessment of the Rheological Properties and Bread Characteristics Obtained by Innovative Protein Sources (Cicer arietinum, Acheta domesticus, Tenebrio molitor): Novel Food or Potential Improvers for Wheat Flour? LWT, 118, Article ID: 108867. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.lwt.2019.108867Ayensu, J., Lutterodt, H., Annan, R.A., Edusei, A. and Loh, S.P. (2019) Nutritional Composition and Acceptability of Biscuits Fortified with Palm Weevil Larvae (Rhynchophorus phoenicis Fabricius) and Orange-Fleshed Sweet Potato among Pregnant Women. Food Science & Nutrition, 7, 1807-1815. https://doi.org/10.1002/fsn3.1024Kinyuru, J.N., Kenji, G.M. and Njoroge, M.S. (2009) Process Development, Nutrition and Sensory Qualities of Wheat Buns Enriched with Edible Termites (Macrotermes subhylanus) from Lake Victoria Region, Kenya. African Journal of Food, Agriculture, Nutrition and Development, 9, 1739-1750. https://doi.org/10.4314/ajfand.v9i8.48411Osimani, A., Milanovic, V., Cardinali, F., Roncolini, A., Garofalo, C., Clementi, F., Aquilanti, L., et al. (2018) Bread Enriched with Cricket Powder (Acheta domesticus): A Technological, Microbiological and Nutritional Evaluation. Innovative Food Science & Emerging Technologies, 48, 150-163. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ifset.2018.06.007de Oliveira, L.M., da Silva Lucas, A.J., Cadaval, C.L. and Mellado, M.S. (2017) Bread Enriched with Flour from Cinereous Cockroach (Nauphoeta cinerea). Innovative Food Science & Emerging Technologies, 44, 30-35. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ifset.2017.08.015Subramanian, S., Tanga, C.M., Kusia, E., Cerretti, P., Khamis, F., Copeland, R.S., Ekesi, S., et al. (2017) Poster 10: Diversity of Edible Saturniids (Lepidoptera: Saturniidae) and Their Parasitoids in Kenya. Symposium on Biological Control of Arthropods, Langkawi, 11-15 September 2017, 260. https://doi.org/10.1079/9781786394118.0260Purnomo, E.H., Sitanggang, A.B., Agustin, D.S., Hariyadi, P. and Hartono, S. (2012) Formulation and Process Optimization of Muffin Produced from Composite Flour of Corn, Wheat and Sweet Potato [Formulasi dan Optimasi Proses Produksi Mufin dari Tepung Komposit Jagung, Gandum dan Ubi Jalar]. Jurnal Teknologi dan Industri Pangan, 23, 165-165. https://doi.org/10.6066/jtip.2012.23.2.165Bawa, M., Songsermpong, S., Kaewtapee, C. and Chanput, W. (2020) Nutritional, Sensory, and Texture Quality of Bread and Cookie Enriched with House Cricket (Acheta domesticus) Powder. Journal of Food Processing and Preservation, 44, e14601. https://doi.org/10.1111/jfpp.14601Gichau, A.W,, Okoth, J.K., Makokha, A. and Wanjala, G.W. (2019) Use of Peroxide Value and Moisture Content as a Measure of Quality for Amaranth-Sorghum Grains Based Complementary Food. Nutrition and Food Technology, 5, 1-5. https://doi.org/10.16966/2470-6086.162van der Fels-Klerx, H.J., Camenzuli, L., Belluco, S., Meijer, N. and Ricci, A. (2018) Food Safety Issues Related to Uses of Insects for Feeds and Foods. Comprehensive Reviews in Food Science and Food Safety, 17, 1172-1183. https://doi.org/10.1111/1541-4337.12385Belluco, S., Losasso, C., Maggioletti, M., Alonzi, C.C., Paoletti, M.G. and Ricci, A. (2013) Edible Insects in a Food Safety and Nutritional Perspective: A Critical Review. Comprehensive Reviews in Food Science and Food Safety, 12, 296-313. https://doi.org/10.1111/1541-4337.12014Nyangena, D.N., Mutungi, C., Imathiu, S., Kinyuru, J., Affognon, H., Ekesi, S., Fiaboe, K.K., et al. (2020) Effects of Traditional processing Techniques on the Nutritional and Microbiological Quality of Four Edible Insect Species Used for Food and Feed in East Africa. Foods, 9, 574. https://doi.org/10.3390/foods9050574Amadi, E.N. and Kiin-Kabari, D.B. (2016) Nutritional Composition and Microbiology of Some Edible Insects Commonly Eaten in Africa, Hurdles and Future Prospects: A Critical Review. Journal of Food: Microbiology, Safety & Hygiene, 1, Article ID: 1000107.Govorushko, S. (2019) Global Status of Insects as Food and Feed Source: A Review. Trends in Food Science & Technology, 91, 436-445. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tifs.2019.07.032Rumpold, B.A. and Schlüter, O.K. (2013) Potential and Challenges of Insects as an Innovative Source for Food and Feed Production. Innovative Food Science & Emerging Technologies, 17, 1-11. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ifset.2012.11.005Ng’ang’a, J., Imathiu, S., Fombong, F., Ayieko, M., Vanden Broeck, J. and Kinyuru, J. (2019) Microbial Quality of Edible Grasshoppers Ruspolia differens (Orthoptera: Tettigoniidae): From Wild Harvesting to Fork in the Kagera Region, Tanzania. Journal of Food Safety, 39, e12549. https://doi.org/10.1111/jfs.12549Messina, C.M., Gaglio, R., Morghese, M., Tolone, M., Arena, R., Moschetti, G., Settanni, L., et al. (2019) Microbiological Profile and Bioactive Properties of Insect Powders Used in Food and Feed Formulations. Foods, 8, 400. https://doi.org/10.3390/foods8090400Kelemu, S., Niassy, S., Torto, B., Fiaboe, K., Affognon, H., Tonnang, H., Ekesi, S., et al. (2015) African Edible Insects for Food and Feed: Inventory, Diversity, Commonalities and Contribution to Food Security. Journal of Insects as Food and Feed, 1, 103-119. https://doi.org/10.3920/JIFF2014.0016Mutungi, C., Irungu, F.G., Nduko, J., Mutua, F., Affognon, H., Nakimbugwe, D., Fiaboe, K.K.M., et al. (2019) Postharvest Processes of Edible Insects in Africa: A Review of Processing Methods, and the Implications for Nutrition, Safety and New Products Development. Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition, 59, 276-298. https://doi.org/10.1080/10408398.2017.1365330Smith, J.P., Daifas, D.P., El-Khoury, W., Koukoutsis, J. and El-Khoury, A. (2004) Shelf Life and Safety Concerns of Bakery Products—A Review. Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition, 44, 19-55. https://doi.org/10.1080/10408690490263774Das, K.K., Sarkar, A. and Hossain, A. (2020) Isolation of Pathogenic Microorganisms and Determination of Their Antibiotic Resistance Patterns Collected from Different Bakery Products of Dhaka City. Food Research, 4, 1312-1316. https://doi.org/10.26656/fr.2017.4(4).400Saeed, I., Shaheen, S., Hussain, K., Khan, M.A., Jaffer, M., Mahmood, T., Khan, F., et al. (2019) Assessment of Mold and Yeast in Some Bakery Products of Lahore, Pakistan Based on LM and SEM. Microscopy Research and Technique, 82, 85-91. https://doi.org/10.1002/jemt.23103Kontio, V. (2017) Fatty Acid Composition and Shelf Life of Cricket Flour.Farhoosh, R. and Hoseini-Yazdi, S.Z. (2013) Shelf-Life Prediction of Olive Oils Using Empirical Models Developed at Low and High Temperatures. Food Chemistry, 141, 557-565. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodchem.2013.03.024Prchalová, J., Cìzkova, H., Sevcik, R., Hanusova, K. and Rajchl, A. (2016) Evaluation of Shelf-Life of Fruit Baby Food. Agronomy Research, 14, 556-568.Ajith, S., Pramod, S., Prabha Kumari, C. and Potty, V.P. (2015) Effect of Storage Temperatures and Humidity on Proximate Composition, Peroxide Value and Iodine Value of Raw Cashew Nuts. Journal of Food Science and Technology, 52, 4631-4636. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13197-014-1476-6AOAC (2000) Official Methods of Analysis. 18th Edition, Association of Official Analytical Chemist, Washington DC.Manzocco, L., Panozzo, A. and Calligaris, S. (2012) Accelerated Shelf Life Testing (ASLT) of Oils by Light and Temperature Exploitation. Journal of the American Oil Chemists’ Society, 89, 577-583. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11746-011-1958-xNtuli, V., Mekbib, S.B., Asita, A.O., Molebatsi, N., Makotoko, M. and Chatanga, P. (2013) Microbial and Physicochemical Characterization of Maize and Wheat Flour from a Milling Company, Lesotho.Sperber, W.H. and North American Millers’ Association Microbiology Working Group (2007) Role of Microbiological Guidelines in the Production and Commercial Use of Milled Cereal Grains: A Practical Approach for the 21st Century. Journal of Food Protection, 70, 1041-1053. https://doi.org/10.4315/0362-028X-70.4.1041Martin, N.H., Trmcic, A., Hsieh, T.H., Boor, K.J. and Wiedmann, M. (2016) The Evolving Role of Coliforms as Indicators of Unhygienic Processing Conditions in Dairy Foods. Frontiers in Microbiology, 7, Article No. 1549. https://doi.org/10.3389/fmicb.2016.01549Debonne, E., Van Bockstaele, F., Van Driessche, M., De Leyn, I., Eeckhout, M. and Devlieghere, F. (2018) Impact of Par-Baking and Packaging on the Microbial Quality of Par-Baked Wheat and Sourdough Bread. Food Control, 91, 12-19. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodcont.2018.03.033Kourimská, L. and Adámková, A. (2016) Nutritional and Sensory Quality of Edible Insects. NFS Journal, 4, 22-26. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nfs.2016.07.001Durovic, V., Radovanovic, M., Mandic, L., Knezevic, D., Zornic, V. and Dukic, D. (2021) Chemical and Microbial Evaluation of Biscuits Made from Wheat Flour Substituted with Wheat Sprouts. Food Science and Technology International, 27, 172-183. https://doi.org/10.1177/1082013220942441Flick Jr., G.J., Hong, G.P. and Knobl, G.M. (1992) Lipid Oxidation of Seafood during Storage. In: St. Angelo, A.J., Ed., Lipid Oxidation in Food, American Chemical Society, Washington DC, 183-207. https://doi.org/10.1021/bk-1992-0500.ch011Moigradean, D., Poiana, M.A. and Gogoasa, I. (2012) Quality Characteristics and Oxidative Stability of Coconut Oil during Storage. Journal of Agroalimentary Processes and Technologies, 18, 272-276.Van Huis, A. (2015) Edible Insects Contributing to Food Security? Agriculture & Food Security, 4, Article No. 20. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40066-015-0041-5