Dural tear is considered one of the sequalae of head trauma, which is mostly, but not exclusively, associated with depressed fractures as many reports in literature have reported its incidence with fissure fractures, epidural hematomas and skull base fractures [1] [2].

Skull fractures are indicative for intracranial damage and the severity of injury, depressed skull fractures, as well as other pathologies, is associated with dura matter injury. Dealing with dural tears, especially in dural venous sinus related regions require certain degree requires a certain degree of experience and microscopic surgical skills in certain situations [3] [4].

Pre-operative assessment of dura matter integrity is essential, since its tearing indicates cortical laceration which requires certain care during surgery and water tight closure with or without pericranium graft to prevent infections such as meningitis, encephalitis and abscess [5].

Anticipation of dural tear pre-operatively, although not critical, is important data to be considered during surgery planning and can be proven only intra-operatively. In this study, we analyzed radiological data of patients whose operative details confirmed dural tear, to predict its presence either immediately or later as a part of the growing skull fracture.

The aim of this study is to analyze radiological factors which were related to dura matter injury and proven intra-operatively.

The study is retrospective analysis of medical records of a tertiary referral emergency hospital for the year 2020, patients’ records with diagnosis: depressed fracture, epidural hematoma, skull base fracture and growing skull fractures were reviewed; those who underwent surgery for the mentioned pathologies, or another associated injury were reviewed. Patients whose operative details included dural repair were pooled. Clinical, epidemiological and radiological data were analyzed. Risk factors, clinical and radiological predictors for dural injury were identified.

All patients with penetrating head injuries were excluded, patients with struggle where sharp object was used for assault were also excluded.

Imaging: all patients underwent non contrast computed tomography of the head (NCCT) as part of the trauma surveillance. Radiological data retrieved: primary pathology, pneumocephalus, cerebral contusion and skull base fractures.

Operative procedure: all patients underwent treatment of primary pathology with dural repair. Craniotomy was pathology tailored, for depressed fractures where dural tear was suspected a wide craniotomy was performed aiming at landing into a healthy dura for repair.

Twenty-three patients were involved in the study, 15 of them were males, mean age was 13.5 years with pediatric group predominance with 13 patients (56.5%). Domestic injuries were the most common mode of trauma with an incidence of 43.5% (10/23), followed by struggle (6/23), road traffic accidents (5/23) and animal kick (2/23) (Table 1).

Depressed fracture was the most common associated injury with an incidence of 73.9% (17/23) patients, 12 of them where compound, two epidural hematomas, two tension pneumocephalus and two growing skull fracture. Thirteen patients showed pneumocephalus, two of them were tension pneumocephalus. The most common region of injury was the parietal bone with an incidence of 60.9% (14/23) patients (Table 2).

The mean Glasgow Coma Score (GCS) was 13.5, seventeen patients were fully conscious. Nine lesions were related to one of the dural venous sinuses, all of them were depressed skull fractures except one epidural hematoma patient where the source of bleeding was superior sagittal sinus, and five of those lesions were directly over the related sinus while the other four were within 2 centimeter vicinity of the sinus.

Pneumocephalus was a finding in pre-operative radiology in 16 patients (69.6%) and underlying contusion/intracerebral hematoma in 8 patients (34.8%). Radiological analysis of the depressed fracture group was performed to identify the depth of the depression; depth of the depression was measured on NCCT as the distance between the most inner parts of the depressed segment to the inner table of the normal clavaria (Figure 1). The mean depth of depression value was 15.07 mm.

Dural repair was successfully performed in all cases, except one case where the tear was extending to the skull base and beyond total repair. No patients experienced postoperative leakage or infection.

Traumatic brain injury (TBI) is considered one of the most common causes of death and disability in the world, the problem’s scope and seriousness increases in developing countries. Management of head trauma has evolved vastly in the last three decades, which can be attributed to better understanding of secondary brain injury mechanisms and thus preventing them [6] [7].

Many factors affect the global outcome of traumatic brain injury e.g. mode of trauma, Glascow Coma Score (GCS) and secondary brain injuries among which is dural tear. CSF leakage and secondary infection are fatal complications of dural tear if not treated properly. Primary TBI cannot be prevented, however, secondary fatal sequalae can be prevented and treated when diagnosed and managed in an appropriate timing and maneuver. Predominance of male injuries rather than female is expected regarding all types of head trauma, due to more male involvement in driving and struggle.

Hypothetically, tearing of the dura can be due to penetrating skull injury or sharp bone edge of a depressed fracture, however, other clinical facts denies this as the only theory for dural tear e.g. skull base fractures associated with CSF leakage is a prove that sole fissure fracture may underly a dural tear. Another pathology proves that theory is growing skull fracture, where a fissure fracture gaps under the hammering effect of brain pulsation, which will not take place in cases with intact dura (Figure 2).

These observations confirm another mechanism for dural tearing due to high velocity impact due to either dura tension or stretch beyond the elasticity of the dura at time of impaction, or sharp bone edge descent at time of impact before recoiling to normal position.

The most common mode of trauma in our study was domestic head injury, which included household injuries, falling downstairs and falling on heavy objects. Road traffic accidents and struggle followed. This can be attributed to higher percentage of pediatrics in study population (Table 3). Parietal bone high incidence can be attributed to the size of the bone in comparison to other clavarial bones. Further analysis to our results (Table 3) shows that modes of trauma in this series for adults were exclusively struggle and RTA with incidence of 60% and 40% respectively, which matches results of previous reports of depressed fracture incidence [8] [9].

Similar to previous reports which involved operated upon patients, dural tears were most common in parietal region, this ratio can theoretically decrease in case series involving skull base fractures with evident rhinorrhea and/or otorrhea.

Depressed skull fractures are serious sequalae of head trauma with an incidence of 68% to 86% to be compound [9], a category that requires immediate surgical intervention including wound debridement, elevation of the depressed segment and dural repair in case of dural injury. Such surgery can be simple or extensive if dura is torn, the decision to design a craniotomy flap or work through the defect is difficult, since dural tear requires a designed flap which is usually bigger than the depressed defect to reach a healthy dural edge [10]. In

this study, the most common pathology associated with dural tears was depressed fractures (Figure 3), as for Hossain et al. [3] and Nayak et al. [11] with an incidence of 25% and 67.25% respectively. Surgeons should be anticipating dural tears while operating for depressed fractures, however, in this study pneumocephalus was a strong association with dural tear. In contrary to Muhammad et al., our study showed similar dural tear incidence among both pediatric and adult groups, this can be due to involvement of growing skull fractures as a category of post-traumatic dural tear in spite of their delayed presentation. Although Salia et al. [12] listed brain contusions and epidural hematomas as predictors for dural tear as signs of the injury severity, cerebral contusions and edema were associated with growing skull fractures to this study.

According to Salia et al. [12]; pneumocephalus, cerebral contusion and depth of the depression were the most predictive parameters for dural tears in patients with depressed skull fractures. Our results matched these criteria regarding depth of depression and pneumocephalus, since pneumocephalus was an association for the majority of cases (69.6%), and the mean depth of depression for the depressed fracture group in this study was 15.07 mm matching Salia’s criteria who identified a threshold of 14 mm depth for dural tear risk.

Both cases of growing skull fractures had fissure fracture with underlying contusion and brain edema respectively (Figure 4), the theory behind growing skull fractures is the hammering effect of the pulsatile nature of the cerebral cortex which is augmented by underlying pathology that raises the intracranial pressure [13] i.e. contusion and edema for the two cases in this study. On the other hand, it’s impossible to conclude whether or not other cases with mere fissure fracture had already had an underlying dural tear which passes conservatively.

Intra-parenchymal pneumocephalus as well as tension pneumocephalus (Figure 5) are sure signs of dural tear. Dural tears, in some cases, act as a ball and

valve mechanism allowing air influx into the cranial cavity which has limited absorptive capacity, without allowing it out leading to tension pneumocephalus [14]. Increasing size of the pneumocephalus leads due neurological deficits and subsequent increase of intracranial pressure requiring urgent surgical intervention [15]. In this study two cases of tension pneumocephalus were enrolled, for one case a depressed segment was identified radiologically and surgical repair was done, the other case with mount Fujie sign with no detectable dural tear intra-operatively as management line included only subdural drains.

Management of unexpected dural tears intra-operatively requires a certain degree of experience than dealing with uncomplicated cases, anticipating such a pathology pre-operatively based on both clinical and radiological data is useful for perfect operative dealing with such cases to prevent pathological secondary sequalae.

The limitation of this study includes the few number of cases, heterogeneity of the pathologies, as well as the lack of comparison to control group with intact dura.

Dural tears can be radiologically anticipated in cases of traumatic brain injury, based on the pre-operative radiological parameters. Depressed skull fractures are the highest risk pathology, especially when associated with pneumocephalus. These predictions are useful for better pre-operative planning and safe handling.

The authors declare no conflicts of interest regarding the publication of this paper.

Elsherbini, M.M., Elmokadem, A.H., Badr, H. and Khalil, A.F. (2022) Anticipation of Dural Tear in Patients with Blunt Head Trauma. Open Journal of Modern Neurosurgery, 12, 132-140. https://doi.org/10.4236/ojmn.2022.123014