The remediation of inefficient garden land and defective forest land is one of th e important sources and types of supplementary cultivated land in th e comprehensive land remediation of the whole region. The remediation and development of inefficient garden land and defective forest land will effectively alleviate the multiple pressures faced by cultivated land at present. Taking Zhemu Town, Guilin City, China as an example, on that basis of the data of the third national land survey, using analytic hierarchy process, this paper selects six evaluation factors, including water source, traffic, slope, field concentration, farmland infrastructure and villagers’ will, to study the remediation potential of inefficient garden land and defective forest land in Zhemu Town, and delimits four potential divisions, in order to provide the basis for the arrangement of land remediation projects in Zhemu Town. The results show that the northern, central and western regions of Zhemu Town have great remediation potential.
Comprehensive land improvement in the whole region can effectively protect cultivated land resources, realize centralized contiguous cultivated land, and thus carry out large-scale management of rural cultivated land, accelerate the pace of agricultural modernization, improve rural ecological environment, and promote the development and construction of green villages in China, which plays a vital role in the coordinated development of urban and rural areas in China. The remediation of inefficient garden land and defective forest land is one of the important remediation types in the comprehensive land remediation of the whole region, the research on the remediation potential of inefficient garden land and defective forest land can effectively broaden the ways of supplementing cultivated land, provide strong support for solving the problem of balance between occupation and compensation of cultivated land (Liu, 2020), and have extremely important significance for promoting the scientific development of land resources in China and improving the use value of land resources. At present, there are many researches on the analysis of land remediation potential (Zheng et al., 2018; Yan & Cheng, 2019; Yang et al., 2013; Ding, 2017; Cao & Li, 2016), for example, Li Quanbao (2019) discussed the key problems and suggestions in the development of garden land and defective forest land as new cultivated land sources on the basis of exploring the development practice of garden land and defective forest land (Li, 2019), Jiang Changsheng (2018) explored some methods about the development of remediation potential of garden land and defective forest land, which provided methodological guidance for the analysis of remediation potential of inefficient garden land and defective forest land (Jiang, 2018). Li Quanbao (2016) focused on the problems encountered in the actual development of garden land and defective forest land, while Jiang Changsheng (2018) only studied the technical methods needed for the development of garden land and defective forest land. Neither scholar discussed the problems and methods together. In this paper, analytic hierarchy process is used to analyze the remediation potential of inefficient garden land and defective forest land in Zhemu Town, not only the technical methods but also the remediation potential were studied, it is suggested that the local people’s government can make reasonable arrangements for the land remediation project in Zhemu Town with reference to the analysis results and the wishes of the villagers, so as to contribute to improving the income of the villagers in Zhemu Town, promoting the coordinated development of economy, society and ecology in the project area, and realizing the rural revitalization strategy in China.
Zhemu Town is located in the southern suburb of Guilin, in the northern part of Yanshan District, Zhemu Town has a subtropical climate, heavy rainfall is mainly concentrated in summer, the annual average precipitation is about 1894 mm, the sunshine time is long, the annual average sunshine number is about 1550 hours, the climate is mild, the annual average temperature is about 19˚C, and Zhemu Town faces the river and Lijiang River from northwest to southeast, its tributary Xiangsi River flows through Zhemu Town from southwest, and there is Baizhujing Reservoir in the south, which is rich in water resources. Zhemu Town is a typical karst area, mainly composed of limestone strata. The territory is mainly plain, with a small number of hills distributed in the east. The terrain is low in the east and north, high in the southeast, and the highest point is the top of the middle and east hills, with an altitude of about 400 meters. Details are shown in
According to the data of the third national land survey, Zhemu Town has a total
of 8633.65 hectares of land. Among them, the area of cultivated land is 1595.78 hectares, accounting for 18.48% of the total land area of Zhemu Town; the area of the garden is 941.47 hectares, accounting for 10.90%; the area of forest land is 3438.40 hectares, accounting for 39.83%. Details are shown in
Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) is selected to determine the weight of potential evaluation index of inefficient garden land and defective forest land. Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) is a decision-making method that decomposes the elements always related to decision into objectives, criteria, schemes and other levels, and carries out qualitative and quantitative analysis on this basis (Huang et al., 2012; Liu et al., 2013; Peng & Jiang, 2020; Chen & Cao, 2019). Combined with the actual situation of Zhemu Town, we collected relevant data and referred to the existing literature (Lu et al., 2020; Jiang et al., 2012; Deng, 2018; Fan, 2019; Shang, 2020; Ji, 2018; Wang et al., 2017).
The process of data processing is shown in the following flowchart (
1) Evaluation module
The remediation potential map spot of inefficient garden land and defective forest land in Zhemu Town was taken as the evaluation unit.
2) Evaluation index and weight
On the basis of the actual situation of land resources characteristics in Zhemu Town and drawing lessons from Yan Jing’s (2015) selection of evaluation factors in the article “Evaluation of Land Remediation Potential in Nibo Town, Xide County”, finally, selected water source, traffic, slope, field concentration, farmland infrastructure, villagers will of six factors as low-efficiency garden and defective forest land remediation potential evaluation indicators to analyze.
Each evaluation factor is divided into different grades according to the actual situation of Zhemu Town. Following the principle that the higher the grade, the higher the score, each evaluation factor is given the highest grade of 100 points and the lowest grade of 0 points. At the same time, according to the different influence degrees of each evaluation factor on the evaluation of land remediation potential, different weights are given, and the sum of each weight is equal to 1. The weight of each factor is shown in
3) Standardized treatment of evaluation indicators
ArcGIS 10.3 software is used to standardize the evaluation index of remediation potential of inefficient garden land and defective forest land. The specific process is shown in
The score of villagers’ wishes is based on widely listening to the needs and wishes of villagers and adopting a unified standardized score of 85 points according to the actual engineering construction.
4) Calculation formula of remediation potential
| Factor | Water source | Traffic | Slope | Degree of field concentration | Farmland infrastructure | Villagers’ will |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Weight | 0.2 | 0.15 | 0.2 | 0.15 | 0.15 | 0.15 |
| Evaluation factor Evaluation factor Standardized score | 80 - 100 | 60 - 80 | 40 - 60 | 20 - 40 | 0 - 20 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Water source | It is distributed around the river, and the water source conditions are very abundant | Around the reservoir, it is convenient to use water and the water source conditions are sufficient | There are ponds, potholes and low water storage, and the water resources conditions are average | It is far away from the water source, only sporadic potholes are low, and the water resources are insufficient | - |
| Traffic | Roads, railways, waterways and other traffic roads pass by, and the traffic is very convenient | There are roads, field paths, etc., and the traffic is more convenient | There are field paths passing by near the highway, and the traffic conditions are average | It is far away from the highway, scattered in the field paths, and the traffic is poor | There is no road and it is far away from the transportation road, and the traffic conditions are very poor |
| Slope | ≤2 | 2 - 6 | 6 - 15 | 15 - 20 | 20 - 25 |
| Degree of field concentration | Each field is concentrated and distributed in a large area, and the concentration degree is very high | The fields are concentrated and distributed, and the degree of concentration is high | Some fields are concentrated and distributed | The concentrated distribution of fields is small and the concentrated area is small | The fields are scattered and not concentrated |
| Farmland infrastructure | Farmland infrastructure such as ditches and main canals are widely distributed around the field, and the farmland infrastructure conditions are very good | The farmland infrastructure around the field is relatively perfect, and the farmland infrastructure conditions are better | A small amount of farmland infrastructure is distributed around the field, and the farmland infrastructure conditions are general | Farmland infrastructure is scattered around the field, and the condition of farmland infrastructure is poor | There is no farmland infrastructure distribution or occasional distribution around the field |
| Villagers’ will | - | - | - | - | - |
The calculation formula of remediation potential score is as follows:
S i = P i ∗ W i (1)
In which S i refers to the score value of remediation potential, P i refers to the value of each evaluation index, and W i refers to the weight of each index relative to the target layer.
Total land remediation potential score S is the sum of remediation potential scores of all evaluation factors, and the calculation formula is as follows:
S = ∑ S i (2)
Therefore, the higher the score, the greater the potential of land remediation.
5) Classification of remediation potential
According to the final score, the remediation potential is divided into first- class potential area, 70 - 80 second-class potential area, 60 - 70 third-class potential area and less than 60 fourth-class potential area, so as to analyze the remediation potential of inefficient garden land and defective forest land in Zhemu Town.
Inefficient gardens refer to some gardens with low output due to extensive utilization. It is not only necessary but also urgent to renovate inefficient orchards. By selecting suitable crops and improving planting methods according to local conditions, the output of orchards can be effectively improved, and it is also conducive to improving the living standards and happiness of local villagers.
Using ArcGis10.3 analysis and calculation, the total area of remediation area of low-efficiency garden in Zhemu Town is 785.62 hectares, of which the first-class potential area covers an area of 394.19 hectares, accounting for 50.17% of the total area of remediation area of low-efficiency garden; The secondary potential area covers an area of 305.65 hectares, accounting for 38.91%; the third-level potential area covers an area of 61.84 hectares, accounting for 7.87%; the fourth-level potential area covers an area of 23.94 hectares, accounting for 3.05%. The remediation potential of low-efficiency garden in Zhemu Town is mainly the first-class potential area and the second-class potential area, while the third-class potential area and the fourth-class potential area are small (see
From the potential distribution map of inefficient garden in Zhemu Town (left in
The reason for this situation is that the Lijiang River passes through the north of Zhemu Town, the Xiangsi River, a tributary of the Lijiang River, flows through the central and western parts of Zhemu Town from northeast to southwest, and there is Baizhujing Reservoir in the southeast, which makes the water
| Potential zoning | Area (in hectares) | Proportion |
|---|---|---|
| the first level potential area | 394.19 | 50.17% |
| secondary potential arer | 305.65 | 38.91% |
| tertiary potential area | 61.84 | 7.87% |
| four-level potential area | 23.94 | 3.05% |
resources in the north, central and western parts of Zhemu Town abundant; moreover, the farmland infrastructure in the central and western parts of Zhemu Town is relatively perfect and the traffic conditions are good, and the slope in the central and western parts of Zhemu Town is relatively low, which makes the inefficient garden remediation potential in the central and western parts of Zhemu Town great; because the distribution of inefficient gardens in northern China is less, the first and second potential areas are only sporadic; the steep slope in the middle and east of Zhemu Town makes the renovation potential of inefficient garden in the middle and east of Zhemu Town small. It is suggested that the government of Zhemu Town can refer to the research results and combine the wishes of local villagers to scientifically arrange inefficient garden remediation projects, and should focus on remediation of inefficient gardens in the central, western and southeastern regions of Zhemu Town.
Defective forest land refers to forest land which is destroyed by natural or human intervention, with low coverage rate, low economic value and low ecological value. The development and remediation of defective forest land will effectively improve the quality of local cultivated land, enhance the economic value of land, increase the income of villagers, and maintain and adjust the local ecological environment.
According to the analysis and calculation of ArcGis10.3, the total area of remediation area of residual forest land in Zhemu Town is 1002.94 hectares, of which the first-class potential area covers 554.27 hectares, accounting for 55.27% of the total area of remediation area of residual forest land; the secondary potential area covers an area of 289.65 hectares, accounting for 28.88%; The third-level potential area covers an area of 54.88 hectares, accounting for 5.47%; the fourth-level potential area covers an area of 104.14 hectares, accounting for 10.38%. The largest potential area of low-efficiency garden remediation in Zhemu Town is the first-class potential area, followed by the second-class potential area, the fourth-class potential area again, and the third-class potential area is the smallest (see
From the potential distribution map of defective forest land in Zhemu Town (
The reason for this situation is that the Lijiang River passes through the north of Zhemu Town, Xiangsi River, a tributary of Lijiang River, flows through the central and western parts of Zhemu Town from northeast to southwest, there is Baizhujing Reservoir in the southeast, which makes the water resources in the north, midwest and southeast of Zhemu Town abundant. In addition, in the north, central and western regions of Zhemu Town, the farmland infrastructure is relatively perfect, the traffic accessibility is good, the slope in the central and western regions is relatively low, and the distribution of residual forests in the northern region is relatively concentrated, which makes the first-class potential area in the north of Zhemu Town the widest distribution and the greatest remediation potential, followed by the central and western regions and the southeast region; the southern and central eastern parts of Zhemu Town have a large slope and high terrain, which makes the remediation potential of the defective forest land in the central and eastern parts of Zhemu Town small. In the southeast boundary of Zhemu Town, it is mainly a four-level potential area with small remediation potential due to its far distance from the water source and large
| Potential zoning | Area (in hectares) | Proportion |
|---|---|---|
| the first level potential area | 554.27 | 55.27% |
| secondary potential arer | 289.65 | 28.88% |
| tertiary potential area | 54.88 | 5.47% |
| four-level potential area | 104.14 | 10.38% |
slope. It is suggested that the government of Zhemu Town can refer to the research results and combine the wishes of local villagers to scientifically arrange the remediation projects of defective forest land, and should focus on the remediation of defective forest land in the north, central and western regions of Zhemu Town, especially the defective forest land concentrated in the north.
At present, scholars pay more attention to and study the potential of land remediation, but they mainly focus on the potential of agricultural land remediation, which provides a good research method for guiding the development of land remediation potential. The innovation of this paper lies in relying on the research carried out under the background of global comprehensive improvement and under the guidance of rural revitalization strategy, which is different from the traditional research on the improvement potential of agricultural land, but detailed to the comprehensive improvement potential of inefficient gardens and defective woodlands in agricultural land, and using the research method of Yan Jing (2015) as a reference, adopting analytic hierarchy process to study the land improvement potential of inefficient gardens and defective woodlands in Zhemu Town. It not only fills the study on the remediation potential of single inefficient garden and incomplete forest land, but also provides some reference significance for the subsequent study on inefficient garden and incomplete forest land.
Under the background of comprehensive land remediation, combined with analytic hierarchy process, the remediation potential of inefficient garden land and defective forest land in Zhemu Town was obtained. In Zhemu Town, compared with the remediation area of inefficient garden, the remediation area of defective forest land has more remediation advantages and the remediation potential is higher than that of inefficient garden. According to the potential analysis results of the final inefficient garden land and defective forest land, relevant departments and local governments can focus on rectifying the inefficient garden land and defective forest land with great potential in the north, central and western regions and southeast regions of Zhemu Town. Further strengthen the management and remediation of land in Zhemu Town, actively guide the masses to participate, and fully explore the potential of local land comprehensive remediation.
Through the development and renovation of inefficient gardens and defective forest land in Zhemu Town, the cultivated land area in Zhemu Town will be increased to a great extent, and the income of local villagers, their satisfaction with life and their personal happiness index will be improved; it is also conducive to promoting the scientific allocation and flow of land elements in Zhemu Town and promoting the comprehensive improvement of fields, water, roads, forests and villages in the project area; promote the planning and development of comprehensive land improvement in the whole local area, and then promote the coordinated development of urban and rural areas in China, and accelerate the realization of rural revitalization strategy in China.
The authors declare no conflicts of interest regarding the publication of this paper.
Liu, M. Y., Cai, X. W., Song, Y. N., Zhao, Y., & Liu, Z. H. (2021). Potential Analysis of Inefficient Garden Land and Residual Forest Land Remediation in Comprehensive Land Remediation of the Whole Region—A Case Study of Zhemu Town, Guilin City, China. Journal of Geoscience and Environment Protection, 9, 79-90. https://doi.org/10.4236/gep.2021.910006