AJPSAmerican Journal of Plant Sciences2158-2742Scientific Research Publishing10.4236/ajps.2021.1210103AJPS-112387ArticlesBiomedical&Life Sciences Study on the Efficient Cutting Propagation Technology for <i>Ilex</i> “China Girl” XiaobinWang1YushuLv1ShutangXing2GangLiu3JingkaiSun1YaqiongWang1CairuWang1XiaoyanYu1College of Horticulture Science and Engineering, Shandong Agricultural University, Tai’an, ChinaShandong Hanlinyuan Ecological Technology Co. Ltd., Weihai, ChinaForestry College of Shandong Agricultural University, Tai’an, China0910202112101459146730, August 202115, October 2021 18, October 2021© Copyright 2014 by authors and Scientific Research Publishing Inc. 2014This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution International License (CC BY). http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

In order to realize the efficient industrial production of Ilex “China Girl”, an orthogonal experiment with 4 factors and 3 levels was designed. Firstly, the optimal orthogonal cutting scheme was selected from 9 treatments. Then through the systematic analysis of the effects of cutting position, substrate, exogenous hormones type and concentration on rooting indexes, such as rooting rate, root number, root length and root effect index, the theoretical optimal scheme was predicted and verified. The results showed that the theoretical optimal scheme (3000 mg/L IBA treatment for 15 s, cutting in mixed matrix with peat soil, perlite and vermiculite ratio of 2:1:1) was the optimal cutting rooting scheme of Ilex “China Girl”. After the treatment of this scheme, the rooting rate of Ilex “China Girl” reached 100%, the average root number was 51.67 per plant, and the average root length was 6.13 cm. The rooting time was greatly shortened, the rooting rate and rooting effect were greatly improved. In this study, the efficient cutting propagation technology system of Ilex “China Girl” was established, which laid a foundation for the popularization and application of Ilex “China Girl”, and also provided reference for further improving the cutting propagation efficiency of other evergreen holly. This study laid a foundation for the application of Ilex “China Girl”, and also provided a reference for further improving the cutting propagation efficiency of other evergreen holly.

Evergreen Holly <i>Ilex</i> “China Girl” Cutting Propagation Rooting Index1. Introduction

Evergreen holly has a broad landscape application prospect because of its high ornamental value, such as evergreen leaves, beautiful tree shape, bright fruit that does not fall in winter [1]. However, the cold resistance of most evergreen holly is poor, cultivated areas in China are mainly concentrated in Jiangsu Province and the south of Jiangsu Province [2] [3] [4] [5]. A few evergreens holly such as Ilex cornuta, Ilex cornuta “fortunei” and Ilex crenata “convexa” can be used in gardens in Shandong Province and surrounding areas. However, their cold resistance is average, and they all suffered severe freezing damage in the extreme low temperature of −18˚C in winter of Shandong Province in 2015.

Ilex “China Girl” is an evergreen holly with strong cold resistance selected by our research group after years of adaptation studies. It is a hybrid of Ilex rugosa and Ilex cornuta. It is an evergreen shrub with beautiful leaf shape, bright green leaf color, beautiful fruit, full plant type and rapid growth. It can tolerate extreme low temperature of −18˚C in Shandong Province without freezing injury, and is especially suitable for application in Shandong Province and surrounding areas. Therefore, it is of great significance to establish an efficient cutting propagation technology system for Ilex “China Girl” to produce a large number of high-quality seedlings as soon as possible and apply them to improve the current situation of winter landscape depression in Shandong Province and surrounding areas.

The cutting propagation techniques of more than 40 evergreen holly species were systematically studied. It was found that the cutting difficulty of different holly species varied greatly, and the survival rate was 20% - 100% [6] [7] [8] [9]. At present, only Tian Weili et al. conducted a preliminary study on the cutting survival rate of Ilex “China Girl”. After 60 days, the rooting rate was 61.75% - 82.75%, and the average rooting number was 5.63 - 9.33 per plant [6]. However, in order to realize the efficient industrial production of Ilex “China Girl” and produce a large number of high-quality seedlings rapidly, it is necessary to further shorten the rooting time of cutting and improve the rooting rate and root number of cuttings.

Therefore, Ilex “China Girl” was taken as the research object, and the effects of cutting position, substrate, exogenous hormone type and concentration on rooting indexes were systematically studied. The efficient cutting propagation technology system of Ilex “China Girl” was established, which laid the foundation for the application of Ilex “China Girl”, and also provided reference for further improving the cutting propagation efficiency of other evergreen holly.

2. Materials and Methods2.1. Materials

The materials were Ilex “China Girl” introduced from Nanjing in April 2019, and planted in the seedling base of Fanzhen, Daiyue District, Tai’an City, Shandong Province.

2.2. Methods2.2.1. Materials Drawn

In early September 2020 and early June 2021, the current-year-old branches of Ilex “China Girl” with strong growth, no pests and diseases, consistent length and diameter were collected.

2.2.2. Cutting Treatment

Each branch was cut into 9 cuttings, with 3 cuttings in each upper, middle and lower part. Each cutting contained 3 axillary buds and retained 2 upper leaves. Cut horizontally at 0.3 cm above axillary bud and obliquely at lower incision. The cuttings were immersed in 1000 times of 80% carbendazim WP for 15 min. Align the biological lower ends of sterilized cuttings downwards, each 60 into a bundle. The 2 cm base of the bundled cuttings was dipped in hormone solutions of different types and concentrations for 15 s (Table 1).

2.2.3. Matrix Preparation

The perlite, peat soil and vermiculite were prepared according to Table 1 and placed in the cutting bed. The day before cutting, sprayed water with a sprayer. On the day of cutting, 80% carbendazim 800 times liquid was sprayed by sprayer.

2.2.4. Cutting

The biological lower end of the cuttings treated according to Table 2 was obliquely inserted into the matrix. Cutting depth was 2 - 3 cm. Leaves didn’t contact

Test factor level table
NumberFactors
A-hormone typeB-hormone concentration (mg/L)C-cutting substrateD-cutting position
1NAA1000perliteupper
2IBA2000Peat soil: perlite (1:1)middle
3NAA:IBA (2:3)3000Peat soil: perlite: vermiculite (2:1:1)lower
 Cutting treatment scheme
TreatmentFactorsCombination of factors
ABCD
T11111A1B1C1D1
T21222A1B2C2D2
T31333A1B3C3D3
T42123A2B1C2D3
T52231A2B2C3D1
T62312A2B3C1D2
T73132A3B1C3D2
T83213A3B2C1D3
T93321A3B3C2D1
TL2333A2B3C3D3

each other. After cutting, the matrix around the cutting hole was compacted, so that the cutting and matrix were closely contacted. Each treatment had 60 cuttings, and the experiment was repeated three times. It should be noted that 9 treatments (T1 - T9) were carried out in September 2020, and 2 treatments (T3 and TL) were carried out in June 2021.

2.2.5. Post-Cutting Management

After cutting, 1000 times of carbendazim was sprayed once. After that, 1000 times of carbendazim was sprayed once a week for three times. Automatic timing spray equipment was used to adjust the temperature and air humidity during cutting, so that the temperature in the cutting shed was maintained at 20˚C - 38˚C, and the humidity was maintained at more than 80%.

2.2.6. Rooting Index Observation

The base of cuttings treated by different schemes was observed every 10 days after cutting. The rooting rate, root number, root length and root effect index (average root length × average root number/number of cuttings) of 30 cuttings randomly selected were counted at 50 d and 60 d after cutting. It should be noted that 9 treatments (T1 - T9) in September 2020 were only counted once at 60 d after cutting, and 2 treatments (T3 and TL) in June 2021 were counted once at 50 d and 60 d after cutting.

2.2.7. Data Statistical Analysis

Data statistical analyses were performed using SPSS 26 software.

3. Results and Analysis3.1. Selection of Optimal Orthogonal Scheme

As shown in Table 3 and Figure 1, the rooting rates of T3, T5, T7 and T9 treatments were 100%. The average root number of T3 treatment was the highest (49.33 ± 6.17/plant), and the root effect index was the highest (16.20 ± 2.97). Although the average root length of T3 treatment was only 4.95 ± 0.36 cm, the

Rooting indexes of Ilex “China Girl” under 9 treatments (September 2020)
No.TreatmentRooting rate/%Average number of rootsAverage length of roots/cmRoot effect index
T1A1B1C1D151.11 ± 3.85D6.00 ± 1.58D2.27 ± 0.71C0.95 ± 0.12E
T2A1B2C2D298.33 ± 2.89A45.67 ± 5.51A4.52 ± 1.31AB14.07 ± 2.58AB
T3A1B3C3D3100.00 ± 0.00A49.33 ± 6.17A4.95 ± 0.36AB16.20 ± 2.97A
T4A2B1C2D390.00 ± 3.33B19.00 ± 3.61C5.83 ± 0.76A7.33 ± 1.34C
T5A2B2C3D1100.00 ± 0.00A22.33 ± 4.62B4.17 ± 2.31AB6.50 ± 1.37C
T6A2B3C1D284.45 ± 3.85B23.67 ± 1.59B3.83 ± 0.29B6.11 ± 1.25C
T7A3B1C3D2100.00 ± 0.00A29.67 ± 4.29B5.90 ± 0.57A11.67 ± 1.89B
T8A3B2C1D373.33 ± 6.67C16.67 ± 1.21C2.63 ± 0.98C3.37 ± 0.50D
T9A3B3C2D1100.00 ± 0.00A19.33 ± 3.06C5.50 ± 1.32A7.09 ± 2.18C

difference was not significant compared with that of T7 treatment (5.90 ± 0.57 cm/plant) with the longest average root length. Therefore, T3 treatment (A1B3C3D3), i.e., the lower cuttings were dipped in 3000 mg/L NAA solution for 15 s, and cut in mixed matrix with peat soil, perlite and vermiculite ratio of 2:1:1, was the optimal solution in 9 treatments (T1 - T9).

3.2. Prediction of Optimal Theoretical Scheme3.2.1. Effects of Hormone Type on Rooting Indexes

As shown in Table 4, the rooting rate of cuttings treated with IBA alone was the highest and significantly higher than that treated with NAA alone. The average number of roots treated with NAA alone was the highest and significantly higher than that treated with IBA alone and NAA: IBA (2:3). Many researchers generally believed that rooting rate was the most important in four rooting indexes. So IBA was the best rooting hormone.

3.2.2. Effects of Hormone Concentration on Rooting Indexes

As shown in Table 4, the rooting rate and average root number of cuttings treated with 3000 mg/L hormone were the highest and significantly higher than those treated with 1000 mg/L hormone. Therefore, the optimal rooting hormone concentration was 3000 mg/L.

3.2.3. Effects of Substrate Type on Rooting Indexes

As shown in Table 4, all rooting indexes of peat soil: perlite: vermiculite (2:1:1) were the highest, and 4 indexes were significantly higher than perlite, 2 indexes were significantly higher than peat soil: perlite (1:1). Therefore, the optimal cutting substrate was peat soil: perlite: vermiculite (2:1:1).

In addition, by comparing the range values of different rooting indexes under different influencing factors, it was found that the matrix type had the greatest impact on all rooting indexes (R = 30.37), followed by hormone concentration (R = 14.45), and then the cutting position (R = 10.56) and hormone type (R = 8.34). Therefore, matrix type was the most important factor affecting rooting

Multiple comparison and extreme difference analysis of orthogonal experiment (September 2020)
FactorsLevelsRooting rate/%Average number of rootAverage length of root/cmRoot effect index
A-hormone typeNAA83.15b33.67a--
IBA91.48a21.89b--
NAA:IBA(2:3)91.11a21.67b--
R8.3412.001.103.76
B-hormone concentration100080.37b18.22b--
200090.56a28.22a--
300094.82a30.78a--
R14.4512.551.232.47
C-substrateperlite69.63b15.44c2.91b3.48c
Peat soil:perlite (1:1)96.11a28.00b5.28a9.50b
Peat soil:perlite:vermiculite (2:1:1)100.00a33.78a5.34a12.14a
R30.3718.332.438.66
D-cutting positionupper83.70c15.89b-4.85b
middle94.26a28.33a-11.30a
lower87.78b33.00a-8.97a
R10.5617.121.106.45

index, followed by hormone concentration.

In short, according to the results of multiple comparison and range analysis of orthogonal experiment, A2B3C3D2, that was, using 3000 mg/L IBA to treat middle cuttings for 15 s, cutting in peat soil: perlite: vermiculite (2:1:1) mixed matrix, was the best theoretical scheme for cutting rooting.

3.3. Verification of Optimal Theoretical Scheme

From June to August 2021, the rooting indexes of the optimal theoretical scheme TL and the optimal orthogonal scheme T3 were observed regularly. It was found that all the rooting indexes of TL treatment were higher than those of T3, and the rooting indexes of 50 d after treatment were higher than those of 60 d after treatment (Table 5). Therefore, TL treatment (A2B3C3D2) was the best cutting rooting scheme.

4. Discussion

There are many factors affecting plant cutting propagation, including internal factors such as plant species (varieties), cutting age, sampling site, cutting specification, and external factors such as matrix, temperature, humidity, light, plant growth regulators [10] [11] [12] [13]. The results showed that substrate type was

Rooting indexes of T<sub>3</sub> treatment and T<sub>L</sub> treatment (June 2021)
TreatmentCombination of factorsCutting timeRooting rate/%Average number of rootAverage length of root/cmRoot effect index
T3A1B3C3D350d100.00 ± 0.00A40.63 ± 5.28B4.05 ± 0.22C10.89 ± 1.65D
60d100.00 ± 0.00A48.13 ± 5.43AB5.25 ± 0.26B16.09 ± 2.11C
TLA2B3C3D250d100.00 ± 0.00A51.67 ± 5.48AB6.13 ± 0.34AB20.98 ± 2.53B
60d100.00 ± 0.00A59.48 ± 6.03A7.26 ± 0.58A28.56 ± 3.72A

the most important factor affecting rooting index of Ilex “China Girl”, followed by hormone concentration.

Ideal cutting substrate should have good air permeability, moderate water retention and drainage, no bacterial infection, and certain fertility. However, different plants have different requirements for water retention and drainage [14] [15]. In this study, four rooting indexes in the mixed matrix containing 50% peat soil were significantly higher than those in perlite for Ilex “China Girl”. This may be because Ilex “China Girl” requires relatively high substrate humidity, but the water retention of perlite cannot meet its requirements.

Exogenous hormone treatment can significantly improve the rooting rate and rooting effect of cutting, but the optimal hormone types and concentrations of different plants are different [16] [17]. In this study, it was found that IBA was the optimal rooting hormone for Ilex “China Girl”. When other treatments were the same as those in this study, the highest rooting rate of Ilex “China Girl” treated with ABT by Tian et al. was only 61.75%, and the average root number was only 8.61/plant [6]. In this study, the rooting rate was up to 100% and the number of roots was up to 45.67/plant after IBA treatment, which greatly improved the rooting rate and rooting effect of Ilex “China Girl”. In addition, this study also found that the effect of 2000 - 3000 mg/L hormone treatment was significantly better than 1000 mg/L hormone treatment, and with the increase of hormone concentration, the rooting rate and average root number were further improved. However, whether further increasing hormone concentration can further improve rooting rate and average root number still needs experimental verification.

5. Conclusion

In this study, the optimal cutting rooting scheme of “Chinese young girl” was developed, that is, using 3000 mg/L IBA to treat middle cuttings for 15 s, cutting in peat soil:perlite:vermiculite (2:1:1) mixed matrix. After the treatment, the cutting rooting time of Ilex “China Girl” was greatly shortened, and the rooting rate and rooting effect were greatly improved.

Acknowledgements

This study was invested by the Shandong Agricultural Seeds Engineering Project (2017LZN017).

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest regarding the publication of this paper.

Cite this paper

Wang, X.B., Lv, Y.S., Xing, S.T., Liu, G., Sun, J.K., Wang, Y.Q., Wang, C.R. and Yu, X.Y. (2021) Study on the Efficient Cutting Propagation Technology for Ilex “China Girl”. American Journal of Plant Sciences, 12, 1459-1467. https://doi.org/10.4236/ajps.2021.1210103

ReferencesSong, X.-Q. and Zhang, D.-L. (2020) Research on the Application of Ilex Plants in American Garden Landscape. Journal of Anhui Agricultural Sciences, 48, 108-110.Zeng, W., Jin. X.L., Xing. W. and Hu, M.Y. (2016) Comparison of Cold Resistance among Nine Evergreen Ilex Cultivars. Plant Physiology Journal, 52, 55-61.Zhang, J.L., Xie, X.J., Jiao, Z.Y., Zhang, L. and Hao, R.M. (2005) The Comparison of Frozen Resistance of Several Tree Species of Ilex L. Acta Horticulturae Sinica, 32, 477-481.Cui, Y.-W., Li, W.-M., Qian, Y.-P., Tian, R.-N. and Li, Y.-L. (2019) Evaluation of Cold Resistance and Physiological Response to Low Temperature on Five Kinds of Ilex Aquifolium. Journal of Biology, 36, 55-59.Chai, Y.X., Zeng, W., Jin, X.L. and Cai, M.Y. (2017) Physiological Characteristics and Cold Hardiness between Male and Female Plants of Ilex Rotunda. Journal of Central South University of Forestry & Technology, 37, 93-98.Tian, W.L., Li, H.X., Zhang, Q., Fu, W.Q. and Zhang, L.M. (2017) Effects of Different Treatments on Cutting Rooting of Three Varieties of Holly. Journal of Fujian Forestry Science and Technology, 44, 99-101, 111.Zhang, J.H., Xu, W.M. and Lu, M.X. (2002) Seedling Cultivation Technique by Cuttage ofIlex cornuta var. Fortunei. Journal of Zhejiang Forestry Science and Technology, 22, 100-101.Jin, X.-L., Fu, J.-M., Zhang, D.-L., Du, H.-Y., Tian, Y.-C. and Zou, Y.-P. (2012) Adaptability and Cutting Propagation Technology of Ilex Cultivars. Journal of Central South University of Forestry & Technology, 32, 7-10.Tsaktsira, M., Alevropoulos, A., Tsoulpha, P., Scaltsoyiannes, V., Scaltsoyiannes, A. and Iliev, I. (2018) Inter- and Intra-Genetic Variation on Rooting Ability of Ilex Aquifoliuml Varieties and Cultivars. Propagation of Ornamental Plants, 18, 131-138.Wilkerson, E.G., Grates, R.S., Zolnier, S., Kester, S.T. and Geneve, R.L. (2005) Transpiration Capacity in Poinsettia Cuttings at Different Rooting Stages and the Development of a Cuttings Coefficient for Scheduling Mist. American Society for Horticultural Science, 130, 295-301. https://doi.org/10.21273/JASHS.130.3.295Wang, Q., Zhang, J., Zhong, C.L., Zhang, Y., Wei, Y.C. and Meng, J.X. (2020) Variation of Endogenesis Hormone and Nutritive Matter Concentration in Chukrasia tabularis Cuttings during Rooting. Journal of Central South University of Forestry & Technology, 40, 111-119.Wu, Y., Wang, G.B., Cao, F.L. and Zu, Y.G. (2016) Effects of Substrate, Cuttings and Root Promoting Agent on Rooting of Camptotheca acuminata. Journal of Nanjing Forestry University (Natural Sciences Edition), 40, 1-8.Liang, X.C., Huang, S.D., Jiang, Y.M. and Zhao, C.M. (2021) Effects of Exogenous Hormones and Substrate on Cutting Rooting of Cryptocarya concinna. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 37, 24-29.Chen, W.J., Qu, L.F., Han, J.S. and Yang, M. (2019) Effects of Base Material, Cutting Position and Rooting Angets on Cutting Rooting of Liriodendronsion americanum. Journal of Inner Mongolia Agricultural University (Natural Science Edition), 40, 24-28.Qin, A.L., Jian, Z.J., Ma, F.Q., Guo, Q.S. and Zheng, X.K. (2018) Effects of the Mother Tree Age, Growth Regulator, Containers and Substrates on Softwood Cutting Propagation of Thuja sutchuenensis. Scientia silvae sinicae, 54, 40-50.Ma, S.J., Peng, T.L., Yu, Y., Liu, Y., Li, C. and Wang, J. (2020) Effect of Plant Hormones and Magnetic Field on Rooting of Soft Cuttings for Catalpa bungei. Journal of Northeast Forestry University, 48, 21-24.Liu, H., Song, X.B., Zhou, N.F., Ma, Q.G. and Pei, D. (2017) Adventitious Root Formation with IBA and Endogenous Hormones Dynamicsin Walnut Soft-Cutting. Journal of Zhejiang A & F University, 34, 1038-1043.