Healthcare waste has now been increasingly studied in terms of the risks or dangers that can cause the environment and human health. Waste generated in clinical analysis laboratories (CALs) deserves attention, because, due to the advent of the concept of emergent pollution, it is doubtful if the materials or reagents are disposed in the sewage by CALs, which are currently considered non-contaminated or with low risk potential, under current legislation, may actually impact the environment with actions not yet understood. This study was experimental and conducted at the Environmental Laboratory of the University of the Region of Joinville. It was used Euglena gracilis (primary trophic level) algae exposed to effluents from five sectors of a CAL: Biochemistry, Hematology, Viral Load, Tuberculosis and Immunochemistry. Samples were collected from the siphons attached to the wash sinks of the CAL materials. To verify changes in algae that denote environmental danger, behavioral changes were analyzed via NGTOX, and chlorophyll concentration was calculated by chlorophyll extraction according to Mendel’s method. Viral Load (VL) and Hematology (HT) sectors were the ones that most affected algae (Tukey test). In both sectors, there was inhibition of algae mobility and gravitaxy: in VL, due to the presence of chaotropic agents that denature organic structures; and in HT, due to the change in membrane permeability attributed to methylene blue. Also in HT, there was a search for algae adaptation by increasing the rise to the surface in order to overcome the lower luminosity due to the coloration of the environment, which also affects photosynthesis. Regarding the concentration of a-chlorophyll, the VL and HT were the most affected as well, being the first one the one that had more concentration reduction because of the presence of chaotropic agents. Considering new parameters evaluated, the discarded compounds need to be better evaluated for risk, as they affect algal photosynthesis. Procedures for removal of these compounds should be considered.
Nowadays, healthcare waste has been increasingly studied in terms of the risks that can cause the environment and human health, mainly regarding the long-term exposure. Efforts have been performed in order to understand better this reality. It is known that effluents from healthcare facilities present potential risk and danger as they contain from endocrine disruptors to medicines and also microorganisms that somehow affect the health and the environment [
In turn, industries are the greatest responsibility for the generation of hazardous waste and, because of that, are the main target of inspection, even in comparison to laboratories. Although the increased monitoring and imposing fines, the Brazilian Association of Waste Treatment Companies [
Regarding specifically to environment, these residues, that are commonly called emergent pollutants, may affect primary and secondary trophic levels, which modifies the ecosystem in a way that reaches the human being [
Recent studies have demonstrated that the concentrations found in the effluents of these emergent pollutants, even after suffering dilutions in water environments, may still cause damages. In an investigation performed by Machado et al. [
Considering the lack of information about long-term risks of emergent pollutants from healthcare facilities, the waste generated in clinical analysis laboratories (CALs) deserves attention, because these places discard various substances in the sewage, which may be a potential long-term source of environmental contamination. Therefore, CALs disposal guides to the leading question of this paper: may materials or samples considered non-contaminated or of low risk potential, under current legislation, and discarded in small quantities in sinks affect the environment?
It is important to say in Brazil there is a distance between the current legislation about the management of water resources, the reality of the wastewater and sewage treatment conducted by the wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) or sewage treatment plant (STP) and the current experience, which points out to emergent pollutants, i.e., dangers and risks to health and to the environment. Considering that, adaptations and rules that attend this new reality are required. Then, investigations like the present one are needed in order to obtain results that help to foment discussions that contribute to the adequacy of water treatments, with actualization of environmental legislation. In other parts of the world, organizations like European Union, the United States Environmental Protection Agency and the World Health Organization have already published guidelines and laws purposing on warning about the risks of the presence of hormones and other emergent products in water, as well demanding their removal, achieving to establish acceptable drinking water limits [
In this context, CALs need to be studied in order to comprehend better if there are emergent risks or not, especially due to the high participation in the generation of effluents. All the CAL sectors (here defined in Biochemistry Hematology, Viral Load, Tuberculosis and Immunochemistry) releases in average 20 liters of water a day, after washing the materials and executing in sinks other procedures. Depending on the quantity of performed tests, a CAL may dispose up to 120 liters of effluent every day in the public sewage [
Considering that Joinville city presents 33.4% of its treated domestic effluents and that the majority of laboratories is situated in areas that do not have public management of these effluents, all the produced waste is disposed in natura and has as final destination the Babitonga Bay [
This study was experimental and conducted at the Environmental Laboratory of the University of the Region of Joinville. It was used Euglena gracilis KLEBS algae, obtained from the collection of University of Göttingen, Germany. With regard to the algae, behavioral changes and modification on chlorophyll concentration will be evaluated, when in touch with samples from the analyzed CAL sectors.
The samples were gathered at the Joinville Municipal Clinical Analysis Laboratory, and the authorization was acquired via approval letter no. 051/2018/SMS/ GAB/GTES, from Joinville Municipal Secretary of Health.
To the analysis, two kinds of sample were collected from each sector:
[
[
The conduction of the study had the contribution of a CAL from Joinville city, in the Northeast of Santa Catarina, that permitted the sample collection in the five sectors of the laboratory (
The WA samples were collected directly from the taps of the sinks used to wash the materials from each laboratory, with borosilicate glass jar previously sterilized, and they were used as control samples (water from the treatment plant).
The RE samples were collected from the siphons of the sinks used to wash the materials through a peristaltic pump. In this collection, borosilicate glass jars were utilized as well. For each sector, samples up to 2 liters were collected, and, after it, the samples were kept in polystyrene boxes with ice and away from the light until their packaging in freezers.
One factor that must be considered here was the quantity of reagents disposed through the sinks and that compose the RE of the sectors. In order to have an idea of the dimension of the quantity produced by sector and its impact, the quantity of performed exams by sector in the period of one year was consulted, according to the laboratory records. These data are presented in results and discussion.
| Sector | Description |
|---|---|
| Hematology Sector | Responsible for the processing of blood samples and exams as hemograms, Rh factor, direct Coombs. |
| Viral Load Sector | Responsible for exams like CD4, among others. |
| Biochemistry Sector | Responsible for exams like glucose, cholesterol, triglycerides, AST, ALAT, creatinine, PCR, urea, calcium, potassium, sodium, etc. |
| Immunochemistry Sector | Responsible for exams that use plasma separation tubes (serum): HIV, Anti-HCV, Anti-Hbs, HbsAg, Anti-HbC, Siphilys, Toxo IgG, Toxo IgM, etc. |
| Tuberculosis Sector | Responsible for sputum exams with collector pot, as a sputum sample. |
Source: primary.
Considering one of the five analyzed sectors had two kinds of sample each, and the tests were performed in triplicate, 24 samples were collected and submitted to tests with algae and microcrustaceans, plus the control one (WA), compounding 32 samples to be investigated, as well as 32 algae culture for the tests.
Of each collected sample, a 5-mL aliquot was removed in order to be added to a 40-mL culture of Euglena gracilis algae, and collections were conducted for the chlorophyll level and behavioral changes tests after 60 days of exposure, according to Nilsson et al.’s recommendation [
The behavioral experiments with Euglena gracilis in effluents presence were performed using a tool of real-time biomonitoring called NGTOX, developed and homologated by Ecobabitonga Tecnologia Ltda. The instrument monitors, by a real-time image analysis, the algae behavior through different movement parameters of the photosynthetic unicellular flagellates [
The equipment contains a system of connections involving four silicone tubes responsible for the suction of cell culture of E.gracilis, water samples with hormones for the tests, water for sample dilution, and the disposal of the analyzed material.
Three pumps activated by peristaltic motors transported the cells, the diluent and the sample up to a glass bucket of 22 mm of internal diameter and 0.2 mm of thickness. The trial bodies in contact to the diluent were blended and transferred to an observation bucket, connected to a microscope, which captured the images of the cells in movement. The images were recorded by a charged coupled device camera and digitalized by a board connected to a microcomputer, in which they were presented in a monitor. The software calculated the movement parameters, the movement speed, the ascent rate, the average cell size, etc. After that, the samples were added, and the analyses were performed by the software one more time 10 minutes later. Any alteration on the movements, average speeds, ascent rates and cell size were calculated and compared with the previous results [
Aliquots were vacuum-filtered using Whatman® 47-mm filter paper. The papers containing the filtered (precipitated cells) were transferred to a Falcon tube, received 5 mL of acetone and were after that kept at 4˚C for 60 minutes, for the extraction of pigments. Then, the mixtures were centrifugated at 6000 g for 10 min at 4˚C in order to aggregate on the waste cells.
The absorption spectrum of the supernatant was measured 665 - 705 nm for the chlorophyll reading and 400 - 445 nm for the carotenoids reading. For this, a spectrophotometer UV-160a Shimadzu was used.
The chlorophyll concentration was calculated through the intensity of peaks found out on the spectrum, like the values plotted on an Excel® sheet with the Lorenz formula for the concentration calculation.
In order to have an idea of the quantity that was produced and to verify how much the produced quantity could interfere or not in a possible environmental impact, the monthly average production was calculated for a certain period of the year.
According to the production records of the studied laboratory, it was seen that the total of performed exams during the period between January and December of 2018 (the survey period) were 1,005,557. Considering the quantity of exams conducted by the sectors, it was verified that the Biochemistry sector presented the highest number of exams in comparison to the other ones, followed by the Immunochemistry sector and the Hematology sector (
The high demand in the Biochemistry sector is justified by the nature of the performed exams. The majority of them are part of the medical clinic routine and required for chronical diseases tracking and controlling, like diabetes, liver and kidney diseases [
The next phase of the investigation was to know the reagents used by the sectors, regardless of demands, in order to understand if any of the components would be capable of affecting the algae activity.
Many are the reagents used in laboratory exams. The majority of them are disposed in common sewer without the proper concerns, due to either neglection, or lack of rigid laws. These chemical compounds vary from dyes used for contrasts in cells for chaotropic agents to protein dehydration, as well as methanol traits and iron microparticles [
The dyes used in the sectors are listed in
In the Hematology sector, the dyes are used in a blood smear technique. They are also called panchromic and correspond to a mixture of dyes with varied characteristics, that in appropriate conditions dye the nuclear and cytoplasmatic components of leukocytes in shades of red and blue [
| Sector | Dye | General Composition |
|---|---|---|
| Hematology sector | GIENSA® MAY GRUNWALD® | · Giemsa dye · Glycerol · Methanol |
| Tuberculosis sector | ZIEHL-NEELSEN® | · Basic fuchsin · Ethyl alcohol · Methylene blue · Hydrochloric acid |
| CCG® | · Carbolized crystal violet · Lugol’s solution · Alcohol-acetone bleaching solution · Carbolized gram’s fuchsin |
Source: kit instructions.
| Dyes | Chemical Composition |
|---|---|
| Giemsa | Methylene blue Azure B Azure A Azure C Thionine |
| Basic fuchsin | Rosalinine chloride Pararosaniline chloride |
| Carbolized fuchsin | Rosalinine chloride Pararosaniline chloride Ethyl alcohol Cast phenol |
| Carbolized crystal violet | Pararosaniline chloride |
| Lugol | Potassium iodide |
Source: kit instructions.
In the Tuberculosis sector, there is the Ziehl-Neelsen reagent, which consists on highly lipophilic composes that promote the dyeing of the cell wall bacteria with highly lipophilic characteristics. Bacteria that have this kind of membrane are resistant to common coloring methods. Ziehl fuchsin dyes all the bacteria in red, and, after the bleaching with alcohol-acid, only the acid-fast bacilli will keep the color. In order to make the visualization easier, the bottom is dyed with methylene blue, establishing a clear contrast between cell elements and other bacteria (blue ones) and the acid-fast bacilli (red ones) [
In the Hematology and Tuberculosis sectors, the common dye is the methylene blue, represented in
In the Viral Load sector, the reagents used are listed in
The binding buffer solution promotes the quantification of a certain DNA and is composed by a chaotropic agent, the guanidinium isothiocyanate (
| Sector | Reagent | Chemical Composition |
|---|---|---|
| Viral Load | Binding buffer | Guanidinium isothiocyanate Ethanol |
| Wash buffer | NaCl EDTA | |
| Elution buffer | Silica Iron microparticles |
Source: analyzed kit instructions.
It decreases the hydrogen bonds in the middle, which makes the viral DNA links to the silica, and this process is easier due to the ethanol presence. The chaotropic agents are capable of interfere in the organic structures, causing the protein and macrocells dehydration. This way, it’s seen the reduction of enzymatic activity and the cell stress induction, which can be a risk for the living beings, depending on the exposed quantity [
Taking into account this used reagents survey, which are disposed directly in common sewer, the next idea was to study the behavioral changes and the chlorophyll alterations in algae to verify if these modifications are related to the reagents cited here and if they have any risk or environmental hazard.
The behavioral changes of algae before the effluents are demonstrated in
Moreover, Hematology sector went through speed inhibition, unlike the Viral Load sector, in which this parameter worked as a defense mechanism of algae before the imposed adversity. In Hematology sector, the stimulus observed and correspondent to the defense mechanism occurred due to the increment of going to the surface. The same was seen in the Tuberculosis sector. This behavior aims to try to solve adverse conditions regardless to the low photosynthetic efficiency and to seek greater luminosity in the surface [
Mobility and r-value changes may have a multiple of origins, from the mere viscosity alteration promoted by any modification in the environment density to variations in the algae’s physiology. Viscosity was not a reason for the alterations observed here, because changes in the viscometer were not seen. Physiology alterations are a condition that deserves attention, since they compromise algae’s vital activities, which may involve manifestations of any environmental impact. Mobility altered by physiological changes derived from the environment contaminants interferes in the going to the surface seeking for luminosity. The same occurred with r-value, that measures the algae dispersion and the feeling of collectivity reduction. Under this dispersion, not all the algae reach the surface in order to obtain luminosity, what jeopardizes the photosynthesis. In order to survive, algae adopt defense compensatory and adaptative mechanisms [
To better comprehend the relation between the effluent compounds and the manifestations observed in the algae behavior, it was taken into account what each reagent could cause to E.gracilis.
In Hematology sector, both mobility inhibition and r-value reduction occurred due to the presence of the dyeing methylene blue, which, in accordance with Yamashita et al. [
On the other hand, in Tuberculosis sector, the affected parameter was the mobility, likewise in Hematology sector, but r-value was not changed. Two compensatory mechanisms were also noticed: going to the surface, here understood as an effort to overcome the low luminosity, as well as it occurred in Hematology sector, since in this sector the dyeing is also disposed; and speed increase. The inhibition of only one parameter and the ability of adopting two defense mechanisms are possibly due to the absence of other potentially toxic compounds that are found in Hematology sector disposal, like the methanol, for example. Another hypothesis is the low disposed quantity, since the analyzed laboratory runs a few exams.
In Viral Load sector, in turn, the inhibition both in mobility and in r-value was provoked by the chaotropic agents, which, among the already mentioned activities, cause macromolecules denaturation, that affects the flagellar movement, as well the gravitaxy, important conditions to a proper mobility and r-value perception. In this sector, the defense mechanism was stimulated due to the speed increase, since it was the best way to reach luminosity under the limitations imposed by the guanidinium isothiocyanate [
Considering these observations, it was necessary to verify more in-depth the photosynthesis, here evaluated according to the possible alterations in chlorophyll concentrations.
Changes in chlorophyll concentration are conditions that denote environmental risk, since the algae’s vital activities will be modified and impacts in primary trophic level will occur. The analyzed chlorophyll was the a one, because it is more common in photosynthesis [
When the a-chlorophyll concentration calculation according to Lorenz’s equation was performed, it was observed significant reduction in comparison to the control in Viral Load and Hematology sectors, and the latter presented the lowest concentration, as shown in
The diminished concentration in Hematology sector is justified by the photodynamic action caused by the methylene blue, already mentioned. This dyeing, when in presence of certain wavelengths, may lead to the production of ROS, species that respond to all cellular components, including chlorophyll [
Then, besides the deleterious effect on the membrane permeability, there is the photodynamic activity, also adverse to algae’s vital activities, which clears out the higher behavioral inhibitions observed in the test using NGTOX.
In Viral Load sector, the reduction in concentration occurs due to the guanidinium isothiocyanate. This compound has nitrogens that ionically link on the magnesium present in the environment [
This way, there is the sequester of the ions present in the chlorophyll molecule, dehydrating it. This is the reason of the concentration reduction observed in the experiments.
Since knowing the alterations effluents from the analyzed sectors might cause to the primary trophic level, here represented by E. gracilis algae, and understanding the environmental risks involved, the hypothesis that the environment may have been suffering dangerous alterations or environmental risks caused by the presence of effluents, being these alterations different among the laboratories, is true, according to the experiments performed by this investigation.
The Brazilian normative RDC ANVISA no. 306 [
A revision of the current legislation is always required, because, due to the advent of emergent pollutants, what was previously understood as a risk nowadays counts on the presence of new compounds that need to have its disposal regulated.
Therefore, biomonitoring data found out were relevant in order to obtain more knowledge and to be aware of the importance of the issue, indicating the possibility of environmental toxicity provoked by the effluents from the CALs. long-term revisions of conducts and legislations trying to minimize the problems related to this kind of emergent pollutants need to be thought.
Investigation performed with funding by the Research Support Funds of the University of the Region of Joinville (Univille).
The researchers thank Univille and the Research Support Funds that make possible the development of the Environmental Impacts and Health Integrated Program (ECOSAM).
The authors declare no conflicts of interest regarding the publication of this paper.
Pinto, L.H., Bez, S.Z., Soares, J.C., Bonfim, B. and Alzahrani, Q. (2020) Study of Behavioral Changes and Photosynthetic Activity of Euglenas gracilis in the Presence of Effluents from the Laboratory of Clinical Analysis. Journal of Environmental Protection, 11, 1015-1029. https://doi.org/10.4236/jep.2020.1112064