TITLE:
Differences in Survival Rates between Different Patterns of Unstable Pertrochanteric Femoral Fractures
AUTHORS:
Amir Herman, Yair Landau, Alexander Hazanov, Tal Segev, Ran Thein, Nachshon Shazar
KEYWORDS:
Intertrochanteric Fractures; Survival; Fracture Classification
JOURNAL NAME:
Open Journal of Orthopedics,
Vol.3 No.6,
October
18,
2013
ABSTRACT: Background: Unstable pertrochanter femur fractures are common in orthopedic practice. They pose a surgical challenge in both reduction and fixation. The fixation devices used are based on hip intramedullary nailing with femur head lag screw or blade. The aim of this paper is to compare different types of unstable pertrochanter fractures. Materials & Methods: We retrospectively reviewed 386 unstable pertrochanter femur fractures surgically treated in our hospital from 2000 to 2009. These included 62 (16.1%) unstable pertrochanter fractures with fractured lesser trochanter (31.A2-2, 31.A2-3); 63 (16.3%) reverse oblique fractures (31.A3-1), 51 (13.2%) transverse fractures (31.A3-2), 145 (37.6%) comminuted fractures (31.A3-3) and 65 (16.8%) subtrochanter fractures. We compared survival rates between fracture types. The clinical characteristics, surgery immediate outcome (e.g., tip apex distance, reduction quality), and long term results, i.e., complications were also compared between fracture types. Results: Survival analysis showed that the fracture types can be grouped into low and high risk fracture types. The former group included, reverse oblique and comminuted fractures. Lesser trochanter, transverse and subtrochanter fractures were included in the high risk group. The survival estimates for five years were 64.6% and 49.3% for the low and high risk fracture types, respectively (p value = 0.008). Multivariate survival analysis showed that the hazard ratio for the high risk fracture group was 1.9 (95% CI = 1.37-2.67). No differences were found between unstable pertrochanter femur fractures with regards to clinical and epidemiology characteristics. Optimal tip apex distance (TAD) of less than 25 mm was found in 66.7%, 57.1% and 66.7% of lesser trochanter, reverse oblique and sutrochanter fractures, respectively. TAD of less than 25 mm was found in 81.2% of both transverse and comminuted fractures (p value = 0.032). No statistically significant differ-ence was found between fracture types, in regards to complication or revision rates. Conclusions: Survival rates were higher in patients suffering from reverse oblique or comminuted pertrochanteric fractures. No differences were found between fracture types, in regards to clinical and other outcome parameters.