TITLE:
The Struggles within: Mapping Perceived Inequity, Unequal Workload, and Constrained Voice among Higher Education Faculty
AUTHORS:
Maria Matthews, Annamarie Sisson, Nicholous Deal, Rhonda Bursey, Sheri Landry
KEYWORDS:
Higher Education, Faculty Workload, Organizational Inequality, Employee Silence
JOURNAL NAME:
Open Journal of Social Sciences,
Vol.14 No.11,
November
17,
2026
ABSTRACT: This exploratory cross-sectional study maps faculty-reported concerns about teaching evaluation, workload, unequal treatment, and constrained voice. Of 168 survey records, three with incompatible employment-context evidence were excluded from record-level analyses, leaving 165 records of incompletely verified faculty status. In the initial wave, 53 of 67 valid respondents (79.1%) reported evaluation-related behavioural changes; a distinct counterfactual item in the second wave received four Yes answers among six respondents. Differential treatment was reported by 47 of 72 respondents (65.3%) answering that item. Across four open-ended questions, 243 candidate answers from 73 records were identified; after respondent- and answer-level exclusions, 84 answers from 32 distinct contributors were retained for manifest content analysis. The four descriptive categories addressed evaluation-related adaptation, workload and research displacement, unequal treatment and favouritism, and gatekeeping, mentoring, voice, and strain. These are reports of perceived concerns, not population prevalence or demonstrated causal processes. Conditional belonging is proposed as a provisional account of how faculty may perceive opportunities and recognition as contingent on conformity to informal organizational expectations (Acker, 2006; Morrison, 2014; Settles et al., 2024). The findings support attention to transparent workload allocation, contextualized teaching evaluation, explicit advancement criteria, mentoring, and credible reporting mechanisms.