TITLE:
Meta-Analysis of Bio-Char, Bio-Oil, and Gas Yields of Different Types of Straw under Different Carbonization Conditions
AUTHORS:
Lianfa Li, Yaxin Li
KEYWORDS:
Meta-Analysis, Bio-Char, Bio-Oil, And Gas Yields, Carbonization Conditions, Pyrolysis, Forest Plot
JOURNAL NAME:
Journal of Materials Science and Chemical Engineering,
Vol.14 No.11,
November
16,
2026
ABSTRACT: Straw is a large-scale and widely distributed agricultural biomass. On the one hand, its disposal poses challenges to local governments. On the other hand, its resource utilization is crucial for achieving agricultural carbon neutrality and the circular economy. Though some individual studies have paid attention to the carbonization mechanism of single or several types of straw, a meta-analysis study or systematic literature review on this aspect has not been reported yet. Therefore, this research aims to explore the bio-char, bio-oil, and gas yields of different types of straw under different carbonization conditions using meta-analysis. It extracts data from 11 studies, published between 2015 and 2026. Though the meta-analysis has issues with heterogeneity and publication bias due to the small sample size, it addresses a meaningful and practical topic and draws several conclusions: 1) there is a significant statistical difference in the average bio-char, bio-oil, and gas yields of the selected types of straw; 2) carbonization conditions (types of straw, temperature, heating rate, retention, and atmosphere) have impacts on the bio-char, bio-oil, and gas yields; 3) bio-char, bio-oil, and gas yields are the result of the combined effect of multiple factors representing the overall outcome. Thus, this research generates the hypothesis that it provides a practice guide for industry and research institutions to formulate targeted carbonization plans based on different types of straw, in particular by making good use of the traditional tile kiln and charcoal kiln.