TITLE:
The Role of the “Reproduction” 乃 Character in Chinese Writing: 282 Characters and 59 Definitions
AUTHORS:
Jennifer Ball
KEYWORDS:
Ancient Egyptian Hieroglyphs, Anthropology, Bu Shou, Chinese, Chinese Characters, Chinese Writing, Chinese Written Language, Clustering, Database, Decomposition, Double-Lobed Shape, English, Female Breasts, Gestalt, HanaMinA Typeface, Hanzi, HanziFinder, Latin Roots, Legos of Linguistics, Mandarin, Meaning, Non-Native Speaker, Phonetic, Phonetic Component, Pian Pang, Pie Chart, Language Acquisition, Prediction Tool, Pregnancy, Pronunciation, Punitive, Quantifiable, Radical, Radical-Phonetic Components, Reproduction, Semantic Probability, Structure, Substructures, Sumerian Cuneiform, Universality, Utility, Vocabulary Retention, 乃, 孕, 太太, 奶, 奶奶, 生殖, 繁殖
JOURNAL NAME:
Open Journal of Modern Linguistics,
Vol.13 No.5,
September
28,
2023
ABSTRACT: The acquisition of Chinese characters and their meanings poses a significant challenge for non-native speakers. This paper proposes that an aid to character comprehension is recognizing Chinese substructures, akin to using Latin roots when analyzing English. Specifically, this paper focuses on not just the radical (部首 bu4 shou3) which allegedly carries the character’s meaning, but also on the phonetic component (often generically referred to as 偏旁 pian1 pang2, though that term lacks specificity) which is alleged to only code for pronunciation. Our research shows that the phonetic component also codes for meaning, and this additional semantic information can be harnessed in order to more effectively retain vocabulary. HanziFinder, a first-of-its-kind search engine for Chinese Hanzi characters, was developed to investigate the potential meaning contribution of the phonetic component. The search engine utilizes a database of 88,884 Chinese characters from the HanaMinA typeface acquired freely from GitHub and then redrawn into searchable nodes and lines. From this database HanziFinder can assemble a list of characters containing a specific substructure which can then be sorted by meaning using definitions from Chinese Text Project and Wiktionary. This sorting reveals that characters with the same substructure often cluster around specific semantic themes, making this organization a predictive tool. A pie chart representation further illustrates the clustering phenomenon, enabling the quantification of a substructure’s weight in driving a character’s meaning. This study examined the character “to be, thus, so, therefore; then, only, thereupon; really, indeed; as it turned out, after all; namely; (literary) you, your, be, hence, but, surprisingly, unexpectedly” (乃) (shortened to “be” 乃) as an example, showing that a character containing 乃 had a 59% likelihood of having a meaning related to reproduction, a 24% likelihood of being associated with utility, and a 17% likelihood of having a meaning associated with a punitive situation. Chinese writing exhibits a gestalt quality, where multiple substructures converge to collectively convey meaning. Consequently, the “x, y” strategy of using a radical and phonetic component together to narrow down meaning space is not robust enough. In this scenario, two different axes—x and y—work together to hew irrelevant possibilities, with x representing meaning, and y representing the pronunciation. Traditionally, in a “x, y” coordinate plane, x and y are equally weighted variables. However, in Chinese, the pronunciation component’s significance is devalued as it is considered solely phonetic. This devaluation is re-evaluated as this study finds correlations between structures, substructures, and meanings, suggesting phonetic components contribute meaning, just like radicals. The universality of certain symbols—such as the double-lobed structure of “be” (乃) in representing a pregnant female mammal’s body, female mammal breasts, and the concept of reproduction—resonates across several ancient written languages, emphasizing the significance of symbols in cultural propagation and survival. The author proposes that understanding such correlations could enhance literacy in Hanzi and perhaps other written languages.