TITLE:
Predisposed Agency: A New Term for Free Will Because Our Will Isn’t So Free
AUTHORS:
Randall S. Firestone
KEYWORDS:
Predisposed Agency, Agency, Free Will, Libertarian Free Will, Partial Free Will, Limited Free Will, Compatibilism, Classical Compatibilism, Determinism, Determinists, Moral Luck, Responsibility, Blame, Praise, Stanford Prison Experiment
JOURNAL NAME:
Open Journal of Philosophy,
Vol.13 No.4,
September
28,
2023
ABSTRACT: This paper proposes that we rename free will, also called libertarian free will, to the more accurate characterization of “predisposed agency.” This is needed for two reasons: First, classical compatibilists have redefined free will to mean something quite different than and in fact contrary to libertarian free will, and thus have introduced needless confusion into the concept. More importantly, even those who believe in libertarian free will recognize that our will is not so free in that we are predisposed toward the decisions we make and the actions we take due to our genetics and our environment, which include our temperament, our character, our past experiences, our past decisions, our habits, the people we have been with, and the situations we find ourselves in, among other things. But the term “free will” totally ignores the fact that we are predisposed toward certain actions. The danger in this is that if we use the lexicon of free will, and believe in free will, then we are apt to judge others harshly for their actions since if they have free will then it would seem they bear both full responsibility and blame for their actions. But this seems unfair since each of us is predisposed to think, decide, and act as we do. The author proposes a distinction between having responsibility and deserving blame and praise. Specifically, it is argued that if we do have agency (or libertarian free will) then we are fully responsible for what we do, but due to our predispositions, which we necessarily and unavoidably have and are often largely out of our control, we frequently do not deserve full blame or praise.