TITLE:
Public Defenders in a Homicide Division: The Courtroom Workgroup, Plea Bargaining, Career Motivations, Views on the Causes of Crime, Perceptions of Prosecutors’ Views of Crime, and Dealing with Occupational Stress in Their Daily Lives
AUTHORS:
Carolyn Field, Alexandra Bentz, Olivia Zizzo
KEYWORDS:
Plea Bargaining, Courtroom Workgroup, Public Defenders, Prosecutors, Sym-bolic Interactionism, Goffman, Homicide, Death Penalty
JOURNAL NAME:
Advances in Applied Sociology,
Vol.13 No.4,
April
23,
2023
ABSTRACT: This study examines the courtroom workgroup, focusing on the plea-bargaining process for public defenders and their relationships with prosecutors in theircourtroom workgroup. Using grounded theory method, this research examines semi-structured interviews of public defenders (N = 6) in the homicide division of a large East Coast American city. Qualitative analysis of the interviewsreveals themes of disconnect in this jurisdiction’s courtroom workgroup.Public defenders of this jurisdiction perceive a stark contrast between theirviews on the causes of crime when compared to their perception of prosecutor’sviews. Results further show that there is limited constructive communication between the defense and prosecuting attorneys in this courtroom workgroup.Interviews also revealed that the public defenders mostly saw structural societal issues as the causes of crime, whereas their perception of prosecutor’s views on crime wasstarkly different. A symbolic interactionist perspective of these results suggests that workgroup disconnect between the public defenders and prosecutors of this jurisdiction inhibits the plea bargain process, thus enhancing occupational stress and frustrations for the public defenders, who dealt with that stress in many unique ways in each of their personal lives.