TITLE:
Retention of Skills with and without Debriefing Three-Months after Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation Training in Makkah, Saudi Arabia: A Randomized Controlled Trial
AUTHORS:
Rehab Mohammed Gaafar, Soha Aly Elmorsy, Abdulmajeed Soliman Khan, Mohammad Kamel Al-harazi, Shaimaa Kamel Al-harazi, Nouf Kamel Al-harazi
KEYWORDS:
Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation, Debriefing, Retention, Skills, Saudi Arabia
JOURNAL NAME:
Open Journal of Preventive Medicine,
Vol.9 No.11,
November
27,
2019
ABSTRACT: Background: Evidence of cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) performance has driven interest in procedures, e.g., debriefing to improve CPR quality. Aim: To investigate retention of skills with and without debriefing 3-months after CPR training on high-fidelity manikins (HFM) among participants involved in the “Heart Safe City Initiative” event (HSCI) in Makkah, Saudi Arabia. Methodology: A randomized controlled design was used during October 2017-January 2018. Participants were divided into two groups: an intervention group to receive debriefing after CPR (debriefing group or “subjects”), and a non-intervention group (“controls”). Participants were tested repeatedly: before training (pre-training test), immediately after and 3-months after training (retention or late test); and scores for each test were recorded. Results: The study’s subjects and controls did not vary by age, sex, nationality, and profession’s criteria (p > 0.05, all analyses). The mean retention posttests scores significantly varied between subjects and controls [t>(df = 200) = 27.7, p p = 0.18). Further, the immediate posttest scores were significantly higher than the pretests’ within the study population as a whole group [mean difference 38.05% ± 27.59%, t>(df = 201) = 13.5, p t>(105) = 14.31, p t>(df = 95) = 13.50, p t>(df = 201) = 20.85, p t>(df = 105) = 21.46, p t>(df = 95) = 22.12, p t>(df = 200),4.76, p t(df = 97) = -2.95, p Conclusions: Debriefing using HFM training achieves the target of improving the public’s skills of CPR. Considering the urgent need to recruit every society member to be a heartsaver; debriefing after CPR training helps improve the quality and retention of basic CPR skills.